CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Havering
Cabinet, Wednesday 14 January 2026 at 7.00pm

Comments of Overview and Scrutiny Board on Requisition of Cabinet Decision - Future Proposals for Former Library Premises

Approved Executive 1 paper

AI summaryCabinet approved in principle a six person respite centre for children with disabilities at Gidea Park, subject to a business case. It agreed disposal of the South Hornchurch Library site and noted ongoing evaluation at Harold Wood, with capital requests of £120,000 and £110,000. [D]

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedGidea Park in principle, South Hornchurch disposal, Harold Wood evaluation. [D]
Money£120,000 and £110,000Capital requests for Gidea Park and South Hornchurch sites. [D]
What happens nextBusiness case and future reportsGidea business case, Harold Wood proposal and South Hornchurch report. [D]
Who it affectsChildren with disabilitiesGidea Park centre, Harold Wood proposal, South Hornchurch disposal. [D]

What was decided

Cabinet approved in principle the repurposing of the former Gidea Park Library site for a six person accommodation facility for children with disabilities, subject to a separate business case being submitted to and agreed by Cabinet. It endorsed a £120,000 capital budget request for inclusion in the 2026/27 capital programme and approved submission of a related planning application for demolition.

Cabinet noted the ongoing evaluation of the Harold Wood Foundation proposal for temporary use of the former library, including a seven year lease with a three year break clause. Any later decision on the proposal will be presented to a future Cabinet.

Cabinet agreed to dispose of the former South Hornchurch Library site, as shown in Appendix A, and instructed officers to report back on marketing and best value. It endorsed a £110,000 capital expenditure request and approved submission of a related planning application for demolition, with final demolition reserved to Cabinet. It delegated authority to the Assistant Director of Regeneration and Place Shaping, consulting the relevant Cabinet member, Section 151 officer and Deputy Director of Legal and Democratic Services, to progress the recommendations.

Why

The Overview and Scrutiny Board upheld the requisition of the 10 December 2025 Cabinet decision by six votes to 2 with one abstention. Under the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules, Cabinet had to respond to each recommendation and say whether it would change or continue the original decision. Report P5, P6

The Board wanted confirmation that Gidea Park is large enough and not too close to the proposed special school, plus clearer detail on disability types and use of existing respite care by Havering residents. It also wanted clarity on Harold Wood when the three year break clause is reached, with the longer term decision brought to members well before then. Report P2

The Board sought officer decisions with Cabinet member consultation and a lower financial threshold for Cabinet decisions. It also sought final use decisions at Cabinet level, a separate recorded decision for each site, business plans presented to Cabinet and scrutiny before disposal or repurposing, option scores in business cases and Area Based Asset Review Process minutes. Report P3

What happens next

Cabinet must receive and agree a separate business case before the Gidea Park repurposing is confirmed. The £120,000 capital request is for inclusion in the 2026/27 capital programme, and Cabinet approved submission of a related planning application for demolition.

Any further Harold Wood proposal will be presented to a future Cabinet for decision.

Officers must report the South Hornchurch marketing outcome and best value recommendations to a future Cabinet, with the final demolition decision returning to Cabinet.

The money

  • £120,000 Gidea Park capital budget request for inclusion in the 2026/27 capital programme
  • £110,000 South Hornchurch capital expenditure request

Options considered

  • Chosen: Repurpose Gidea Park Library for a six person accommodation facility for children with disabilities. Approval is in principle and requires a separate business case agreed by Cabinet.
  • Chosen: Dispose of the former South Hornchurch Library site. Marketing and best value recommendations must return to a future Cabinet.
  • Chosen: Continue evaluating temporary use of the former Harold Wood Library. Any further decision will be presented to a future Cabinet.
  • Chosen: Submit a planning application to demolish Gidea Park Library. Cabinet approved submission of a related planning application.
  • Chosen: Submit a planning application to demolish South Hornchurch Library. Cabinet approved submission, with the final demolition decision reserved to Cabinet.

Implications

  • Financial: The Overview and Scrutiny report has no financial implications because it seeks an initial Cabinet response. Revised proposals may require a separate report with full implications. Cabinet separately endorsed £120,000 and £110,000 capital requests for Gidea Park and South Hornchurch. Report P8
  • Legal: The Overview and Scrutiny report has no legal implications or risks. Revised proposals may require a separate report with full implications. Report P9
  • Staffing: The report has no staffing implications or risks. Revised proposals may require a separate report with full implications. Report P10
  • Equalities: The report has no equality implications or risks. Revised proposals may require a separate report with full implications. Report P11
  • Climate: The report has no environmental or climate change implications or risks. Revised proposals may require a separate report with full implications. Report P11
  • Financial: Business cases should include option scores so the financial benefits of a preferred option are clearer. Report P3
  • Other: Final use decisions should be taken and recorded separately at Cabinet level. Business plans should be presented to Cabinet and brought for scrutiny before any disposal or repurposing decision. Report P3
  • Risk: The Board sought confirmation that Gidea Park is large enough and not too close to the proposed special school. It also wanted clarity on Harold Wood at the three year break clause. Report P2

Who and where

  • Children with disabilities
  • Former Gidea Park Library site
  • Former South Hornchurch Library site
  • Former Harold Wood Library site
  • Harold Wood Foundation
  • Havering residents using respite care Report P2
  • The proposed special school Report P2

Timeline

  • 10 December 2025: Cabinet made the original decision on future proposals for the former library premises. Report P5
  • 8 January 2026: The Overview and Scrutiny Board upheld the requisition by six votes to 2 with one abstention. Report P5
  • 2026/27: The £120,000 Gidea Park capital request is for inclusion in the capital programme.
  • future Cabinet: Further Harold Wood proposals and the South Hornchurch marketing report will be considered.
  • three year point: The longer term Harold Wood position should be brought to members well before this point. Report P2

Plain English for the jargon

  • Respite Centre: The proposed six person accommodation facility for children with disabilities. [D]
  • break clause: The three year point in the proposed seven year Harold Wood lease. [D]
  • Scheme of Delegation: The Council arrangement referred to when deciding which officers may take future site decisions. [P3]
  • business case: A document Cabinet must agree for Gidea Park, which should also be scrutinised before site decisions. [D] [P3]
  • Appendix A: The red line plan identifying the former South Hornchurch Library site for disposal. [D]
  • Area Based Asset Review Process: The former library sites review process whose meeting minutes should be made available to the Overview and Scrutiny Board. [P3]
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item71

Resolved

Report Title: Comments of Overview and Scrutiny Board on Requisition of Cabinet Decision - Future Proposals for Former Library Premises Presented by: Councillor Julie Wilkes – Deputy Chair of the Overview & Scrutiny Board. Response from: Councillor Graham Williamson, Lead Member for Development & Regeneration Following the call-in considered by Overview and Scrutiny Committee on the 8th January 2026 and after consideration of the comments made, Cabinet have clarified the recommendations made in the report for transparency: Cabinet are asked the following: Former Gidea Park Library site: Approve in principle the re-purposing of the former Gidea Park Library site for the development of a 6-person accommodation facility for children with disabilities, subject to a separate business case being submitted to and agreed by Cabinet. Endorse a request for capital budget in the sum of £120,000 to be included in the 2026/27 capital programme and approve the submission of any related planning application for the demolition of the former library building at Gidea Park. Agreed by Cabinet Former Harold Wood Library site: Note the ongoing evaluation of the proposal received from the Harold Wood Foundation in respect of the temporary use of the former Harold Wood library premises including the granting of a 7-year lease with a 3-year break-clause. Note that any decision to be made in relation to the further proposals for the former Harold Wood Library site will be presented to a future Cabinet for decision. Agreed by Cabinet Former South Hornchurch Library site: Agree to the disposal of the former South Hornchurch library site, as identified in the red line plan shown in Appendix A. Agreed by Cabinet Instruct officers to report back to a future Cabinet the outcome of the evaluation of the marketing of the site and premises of the former South Hornchurch library site with officer recommendations as to how achieve best value for the site can be achieved. Agreed by Cabinet Endorse a request for capital expenditure in the sum of £110,000 and approve the submission of any related planning application for the demolition of the former library building at South Hornchurch. – the final decision to demolish will be subject to the decision by Cabinet detailed above. Agreed by Cabinet Delegate authority to the Assistant Director of Regeneration & Place Shaping, in consultation with the relevant Cabinet Member, Section 151 officer and Deputy Director of Legal and Democratic Services to conduct all appropriate steps to progress the recommendations above. Agreed by Cabinet
Word for word from the decision Havering published for this meeting. Source: democracy.havering.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Havering's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet, 4 pages

Recommendation

That Cabinet confirms whether it wishes to reconsider the original Cabinet decision and responds to the following recommendations made by the Overview and Scrutiny Board:

1. Clarity should be given on whether the Gidea Park site is large enough to accommodate the planned Respite Centre and whether the site is too close to that of the proposed Special School. 2. More detail and clearer definitions should be given on the type of disabilities catered for at the Respite Centre and how existing respite care opportunities are used by Havering residents. 3. More information should be given about the position at the Harold Wood site when the three year break clause is reached. Any final decision on the longer term position should be brought to Members well before the three year point is reached.

4. Whilst acknowledging the Council’s Scheme of Delegation, future decisions on the former library sites should be taken by officers but in consultation with the relevant Cabinet Member(s). There should also be a lower financial threshold for the point at which decisions such as these should be considered by Cabinet. 5. Final decisions on the use of the former library sites must be taken at Cabinet level and there should be a separate recorded decision for each site. This latter point reflects the fact that the future plans for each site are markedly different and will have different consequences for each area. 6. Business plans for the use of the former library sites should be brought for scrutiny at the first opportunity and also presented to Cabinet before any decision on disposal or repurposing of the sites takes place. 7. The scoring of options should be included in the business cases for the sites in order that the financial benefits to the Council of any preferred option are more clearly identified. 8. Minutes of the Area Based Asset Review Process meetings in relation the former library sites process should be made available to the Overview and Scrutiny Board.

REPORT DETAIL

At its meeting on 8 January 2026, the Overview and Scrutiny Board agreed, by six votes to 2 with one abstention, to uphold the requisition of the Cabinet Decision of 10 December 2025 re Future Proposals for Former Library Premises.

Under the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules, a report must be submitted to Cabinet giving the Board’s comments and recommendations on the proposals. These are shown above and Cabinet is required to give a response to each of these as well as indicate whether it wishes to change or continue with the original Cabinet decision.

IMPLICATIONS AND RISKS

Financial implications and risks: None of this report which purely seeks an initial response from Cabinet. Should Cabinet be minded to consider revised proposals in response to the Board’s recommendations, these may require a separate report with full implications.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Comments of Overview and Scrutiny Board on Requisition of Cabinet Decision: Future Proposals for Former Library PremisesDecisions 4 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Havering

Search all
  1. Comments of Overview and Scrutiny Board on Requisition of Cabinet Decision - Future Proposals for Former Library PremisesThis decision
  2. Comments of Overview and Scrutiny Board on the Council's Budget 2026/27Noted
  3. Comments from Place Overview & Scrutiny on MLH and Business PlansRefused
  4. Joint People/Place Overview & Scrutiny Comments - Launder's Lane (Arnold's Field)Agreed
  5. People Overview & Scrutiny Comments - Education & Employment Skill StrategyDecided

More from Havering Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
16 Sep 2026 AnnouncementsThe Chair outlined the procedures to be followed in the event of a fire alarm or any other emergency requiring the ev... Decided Open
16 Sep 2026 Apologies for absenceAll Cabinet members were in attendance. Decided Open
16 Sep 2026 Disclosures of InterestThere were no disclosures of interest. Decided Open
16 Sep 2026 MinutesThe minutes of the meetings held on 12 th August 2026 , were agreed as a correct record and the Chair signed them. Agreed Open
16 Sep 2026 Implementation of a School-Based Nursery and expansion of the SEND Unit at R J Mitchell Primary SchoolReport Title: Implementation of a School-Based Nursery and expansion of the SEND Unit at R J Mitchell Primary School ... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies