DECISION REF. 2016/10 TITLE Community Right to Bid – Compensation Claim (The Auctioneers Arms, Caverswall ). RECORD OF THE DECISION TAKEN That the claim for financial compensation by White Acre Estates be refused. STATEMENT OF THE REASONS FOR THE DECISION The Auctioneers Arms Public House was approved by the Council as an asset of community value on 29 th September 2016. Council policy provides for owners of such a property to make a claim for compensation and to appeal should such a claim be refused or determined as less than the amount claimed. ANY ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS CONSIDERED That the claim for compensation be accepted (Not recommended). A RECORD OF ANY CONFLICT OF INTEREST DECLARED No declaration made. A NOTE OF ANY DISPENSATION IF GRANTED None. DATE DECISION WAS TAKEN 3 rd April 2017. DATE OF PUBLICATION OF DECISION 4 th April 2017. NAME OF DECISION TAKER Councillor Mike Bowen. AUTHORITY OF DECISION TAKER Portfolio Holder for Communities.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
2.1That the claim for financial compensation by White Acre Estates be refused.
Executive summary
3.1On the 19th September 2016 the Council approved the listing of The Auctioneers Arms Public House, The Green, Caverswall, Staffordshire ST11 9EQ as an asset of community value.
3.2On the 20th December 2016 the Council received a claim of £5,526.45 in compensation from White Acre Estates, the owner of the Auctioneers Arms.
3.3Council policy, in accordance with the Localism Act, provides for owners of a property listed as an asset of community value to make a
1 claim for compensation and to appeal should such a claim be refused or determined as less than the amount claimed.
3.4Officers have assessed the claim and recommend refusal.
4. How this report links to Corporate Priorities
4.1The Community Rights measures in the Localism Act 2011 have the potential to support the delivery of the Council’s Corporate Aims and Priorities.
5. Options and Analysis
5.1That the claim for compensation be refused (Recommended)
5.2That the claim for compensation be accepted (Not recommended)
6. Implications
6.1Community Safety - (Crime and Disorder Act 1998)
No implications. . 6.2 Workforce
No implications.
6.3Equality and Diversity/Equality Impact Assessment
No implications.
6.4Financial Considerations
No implications as refusal has been recommended.
6.5Legal
Regulation 14 of the Assets of Community Value (England) Regulations 2012 provides that an owner or former owner of listed land or previously listed land is entitled to claim compensation from the Local Authority “of such amount as the Authority may determine” in the circumstances where the person making the claim has “incurred loss or expense in relation to the land which would be likely not to have been incurred if the land had not been listed”.
2 Without prejudice to other types of claim, the following claim may be made:-
1. Claims arising from any period of delay in entering in a binding agreement to sell the land which is wholly caused by relevant disposals of the land being prohibited during the interim moratorium or full moratorium periods; and
2. Claims for reasonable legal expenses incurred in a successful appeal to the First-Tier Tribunal against the Council’s decision to list the land, to refuse to pay compensation or with regard to the amount of compensation offered or paid.
Claims for compensation must be made to the Council within 13 weeks of the loss or expense being incurred. They must state the amount of compensation claimed with supporting evidence. The Council is required to give the Claimant written reasons for its decision.
6.6Sustainability
No implications.
6.7Internal and External Consultation
No implications.
6.8Risk Assessment
In the event that the Council refuses a compensation claim the Owners of the listed property can appeal the decision. Ultimately this appeal could be heard by a First tier Tribunal with additional costs arising from a successful appeal added.
7. Background and Detail 7.1 On the 19th September 2016 the Council approved the listing of The Auctioneers Arms Public House, The Green, Caverswall, Staffordshire ST11 9EQ as an asset of community value.
7.2On the 20th December 2016 the Council received a claim for financial compensation from White Acre Estates, the owner of the Auctioneers Arms.
Attached Appendix 1: White Acre Estates Compensation Claim
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Leisure Facilities Capital ImprovementDECISION: That the Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Tourism approved the use of capital funds that had been included ...
Alliance MyActive Wellbeing LimitedDECISION: 1) The appointment of [name removed] as an Independent Director of Alliance MyActive Wellbeing Ltd, be appr...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.