Decision Date Recommendation Decision Appeal Decision SMD/2017/0388 6 Market Place, Leek 18 December 2017 – Delegated Refuse Refused 31 May 2018 -Dismissed SMD/2018/0001 5 Badgers Croft, Werrington 26 February 2018 – Delegated Refuse Refused 21 June 2018 – Allowed SMD/2017/0705 The Stable, Mollats Wood Road, Leek 19 January 2018 – Delegated Refuse Refused 22 June 2018 - Dismissed It was noted that costs were awarded against the Council in the third appeal case, relating to The Stable . Jane Curley outlined that this had been a partial award and confirmed the circumstances that had led to the award being made. Essentially the Case Officer had submitted the Council’s Statement one day late. This had been rejected by PINS but after a challenge by the Council was later accepted. It was considered to be a slightly unfair award but nevertheless a new process had been put in place (automatic diary alerts) to ensure that this did not recur. The actual planning decision however was a good one for the Council. RESOLVED – That the report be NOTED .
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
Proposal: 600mm back halo and front lit (text only) sign.
Level and Date of Decision: Delegated 18th December 2017
Recommendation: Refuse Decision: Refused
Appeal Decision and Date: Dismissed 31st May 2018
Method of Decision: Written Representations
Major / minor: Minor
Inspector: Siobhan Watson BA(Hons) MCD MRTPI
Costs awarded: No
Main Issues:
The main issue is whether the proposed sign would preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the conservation area.
Conclusions:
The Inspector concluded:
Although small, the sign, as proposed on the fascia of the building, would be prominent and the internal illumination would make it strident and incongruous with its historic and traditional surroundings. the sign would neither preserve, let alone enhance the character or appearance of the conservation area and I dismiss the appeal.
Officer Comment:
This is a good decision for the Council and it is reassuring to see that the Inspectorate support the strict line which the Council applies in ensuring suitable signage within the historic town centre.
Proposal: addition of a dining area to the existing kitchen and the addition of a dressing room and balcony to the master bedroom
Level and Date of Decision: Delegated 26th February 2018
Recommendation: Refuse
Decision: Refused
Appeal Decision and Date: Allowed 21st June 2018
Method of Decision: Written Representations Major / minor: Minor
Inspector: Paul Cooper MSc MRTPI
Costs awarded: No
Main Issues:
i) The character and appearance of the dwelling and the surrounding area ii) the living conditions of the residents of No 59 Washerwall Lane in terms of the privacy of that dwelling.
Conclusions:
The Inspector concluded:
would be very difficult to obtain any significant view of the extension from a public vantage point. As such, the extension would not to be prominent. Consequently the angle of the balcony screen would hardly be noticeable. he principal purpose of the balcony would be to enjoy the wider panoramic views, rather than seeking to obtain views of the adjacent garden. The limited size of the balcony means that it could not accommodate a significant number of people, and being an outdoor space, open to the elements, it is highly unlikely that it would be used in inclement weather. Therefore, while at certain times the next door neighbour could be aware of the balcony being used, any perception of being overlooked would be negligible.
Officer Comment:
This is obviously a disappointing decision and Officers continue to believe that the balcony will appear incongruous and would result in a perception of overlooking for neighbours.
Application No. SMD/2017/0705
Location: The Stable, Mollatts Wood Road, Leek.
Proposal: conversion of existing redundant stable into 1 bedroom single storey dwelling
Level and Date of Decision: Delegated 19th January 2018
Recommendation: Refuse Decision: Refused
Appeal Decision and Date: Dismissed 22nd June 2018
Method of Decision: Written Representations
Major / minor: Minor
Inspector: Gareth Wildgoose BSc (hons) MSc MRTPI
Costs awarded: Yes
Main Issues:
Whether the proposal was inappropriate development in the Green Belt Whether it was consistent with the objectives of rural housing policy Whether there are any Very Special Circumstances
Conclusions:
The Inspector concluded:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.