That the Tree Preservation Order be confirmed (as modified, see 2 below) for the reasons given at 5 ( i ) a-b notwithstanding the objection raised; and 2. That the Tree Preservation Order be modified to make a distinction between land known as Lees Hall Quarry and that which is known as Chunal Fields as shown on the proposed modifications to the TPO at appendix 2 to the report.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
A temporary emergency TPO was made on 9th July 2019 in response to a planning enforcement investigation with regards to various engineering works at and near Lees Hall Quarry. Some trees had been removed/ affected by these works. A Derbyshire County Council Tree Preservation order (DCCTPO61) covers the site, the plan of which is shown at Appendix 1, but does not protect all the trees and due to the age and type of TPO it is extremely difficult for DCC to enforce. Accordingly the TPO was made to protect the remaining trees on the site. The owners of Lees Hall Quarry have made objections to the order to be considered here.
3. RECOMMENDED
i) The Committee confirms the Tree Preservation Order for reasons given at 5 (i) a-b notwithstanding the objections raised. But that the TPO is modified to make a distinction between land known as Lees Hall Quarry and that which is known as Chunal Fields as shown on the proposed Modifications to the TPO at Appendix 2.
Background
i) On 19/5/1960 DCC made a TPO on may trees and woodlands around Glossop including this site (Appendix 1). The trees were protected as an Area designation which protects all trees present when the order was made. The TPO is now 59 years old and therefore only trees greater than this age are protected by this order.
ii) The site was used for many years as a tree contractors yard and the main current occupier purchased the site in 2009. He is also a tree work contractor. iii) The engineering works on site were being investigated by the Planning enforcement team (HPC/2019/0113). The impact on the trees was brought to the attention of DCC and the TPO reviewed. Given the status of the DCC TPO it was decided that it would be appropriate to consider superseding the existing DCC TPO with a Woodland designation in a new emergency TPO. A woodland designation protects all trees no matter what species or age and includes trees which are subsequently planted or establish naturally within the designated area.
iv) An assessment of the trees and their amenity was made by the Arboricultural Officer in June 2019 (Appendix 3) and using the council’s procedure for making Tree Preservation Orders. It was concluded that it was appropriate to make a TPO in respect of the trees as it was expedient in the interests of amenity and the woodland was under potential threat of harm or removal.
v) The TPO was duly made on 9th July 2019 and served on the owners of the trees and their agents.
vi) On 25th July 2019 formal objections to the order were received from [name removed] the owner of Lees Hall Quarry. The objections were considered and a response sent to the objection Appendix 4 and 5).
vii) A comment was also received from the owner of a small section of the woodland to the south with regards to the naming of their land within the order. (Appendix 6).
5. ISSUES AND OPTIONS
i) Reasons for confirming the order.
a) It is expedient in the interests of amenity b) The woodland is under potential threat of harm or removal.
ii) Summary of objections raised by [name removed]
a) There is an existing order which protects the older higher value trees b) The woodland is not under threat of removal and a felling license would be required to remove more than a ‘few small trees’. c) The TPO would prevent normal management of the woodland, including the thinning of younger trees which were planted by the previous owner.
iii) Summary of comments of Wendy Beesley
a) They have no objection to the order but advise that it is registered with DEFRA as Chunal Fields
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.