Resolved
That, notwithstanding the objections raised, the Tree Preservation Order be confirmed for the reasons given at paragraph 5 ( i ) a-b of the report, and the objectors and original applicant be advised on the next course of action.
Development Control Committee decided this item on Monday 22 February 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That, notwithstanding the objections raised, the Tree Preservation Order be confirmed for the reasons given at paragraph 5 ( i ) a-b of the report, and the objectors and original applicant be advised on the next course of action.
A TPO was made on 16th September 2020 in response to a Conservation Area notification of the intention to fell 2 trees (ref 2330). The reason given was they have been implicated in damage to Eton House 22 Broad Walk, Buxton. The evidence provided to substantiate this claim was inconclusive and does not support the removal of the trees. Further information was requested but was not forth coming. Three objections to the order were received which are considered in this report.
3. RECOMMENDED
i) The Committee confirms the Tree Preservation Order for reasons given at 5 (i) a-b not withstanding the objections raised. The objectors and original applicants are advised on the next course of action.
i) The trees are located on the boundary between Eton House and Carlisle House on the Broad Walk. They are mature trees within the Buxton Park Conservation Area and contribute to its landscape setting. A Location plan is provided as supporting Document 1
ii) Damage to Flat 2 Eton House 22 Broad Walk was reported to insurers in 2018. Investigations were undertaken including site investigations, a structural assessment and an arboricultural appraisal report. Copies of these reports and the original notification are available as supporting documents 2- 5
iii) The reports provided concluded that the damage was due to subsidence damaged cause by moisture abstraction by nearby vegetation and recommendations were made to fell 2 trees (TPO T1 and T2). Although some ambiguity in the report suggests that third tree is also recommended for removal.
iv) An assessment of the submitted reports was made and the Notification was acknowledged. The applicant, MWA Arboriculture Ltd was advised of the assessment and asked for additional information. Supporting Document 6
v) The main issues were that roots were identified below the foundations but not from the trees in question, the soil below the foundations was not desiccated. Other possible causes such as drains hadn’t been fully investigated. The damage to the property is classed as BRE 2 which is described as slight or very slight: and can be regarded as ‘aesthetic’ issues that require only redecoration.
vi) No further communications or information was provided by the applicant. Based on the information provided it was concluded that felling wasn’t justified so consideration was given to making a Tree Preservation Order.
vii) An assessment of the trees and their amenity was made by the Arboricultural Officer in September 2020 (Supporting Document 7) and using the Council’s procedure for making Tree Preservation Orders. It was concluded that it was appropriate to make a Tree Preservation Order in respect of the trees as It is expedient in the interests of amenity and the trees are under potential threat of harm or removal. It was considered appropriate to include all the mature trees on the boundary for consistency
viii) The Tree Preservation Order was made on 16th September 2020 and served on the owners of the trees and their agents (Supporting Document 8).
ix) 3 formal objections to the Order were received from the owners of 23 and 22 Broad Walk and one leaseholder Copies of these are attached as (Supporting Documents 9-11) . No objection was received from the original Applicant or their clients the insurance company
5. ISSUES AND OPTIONS
i) Reasons for making the order.
a. It is expedient in the interests of amenity b. The trees are of high amenity c. The trees are under threat of removal
ii) Summary of objections raised by Julia Lisser Carlisle House 23 BroadWalk
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Appendix /152Appendix | 534 KB | Download |
PDF |
Tree Preservation Order at Eton House and Carlisle House, Broad Walk, Buxton (295)Report | 85 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Development Control Committee at High Peak and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Aug 2026 | Minutes of the previous meetingThat the minutes of the meeting held on 13 July 2026 be approved as a correct record. | Approved | Open |
| 10 Aug 2026 | Update SheetThat the update sheet be noted. | Noted | Open |
| 10 Aug 2026 | Planning ApplicationsThat the report be noted. | Noted | Open |
| 10 Aug 2026 | HPK/2026/0134 - The Natural Baths, The Crescent, BuxtonThat the application be approved as set out in the report, subject to the amended condition from DCC Archaeology as s... | Approved | Open |
| 10 Aug 2026 | HPK/2026/0184 - Buxton Opera House, Water Street, Buxton, DerbyshireThat Listed Building Consent be granted as set out in the report: 2. That in the event of any changes being needed to... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.