DECISION: 1. That the allocation of £435,000 for investment in Leek Market Hall be approved for the purposes of improving facilities to support the establishment of permanent units for retail, food and beverage uses as set out in the Business Case (Appendix A of the report) and to replace the asbestos roof. 2. That the responsibility for the procurement of necessary goods and services and the implementation of the capital works be delegated to the Executive Director (Place). 3. That authority be delegated to the Leader to agree to a variation in capital costs if necessary following completion of the open market procurement exercises, up to and not exceeding 30% of the original budget allocation. 4. In circumstances where tender returns rise beyond 30% of the budget allocation approval will be sought via an Cabinet Delegated Decision. 5. That a further Cabinet report be required to detail the future Markets Operation that will be necessary to provide support for market traders and market customers.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
2.1That the Cabinet approve the allocation of £435,000 for investment in Leek Market Hall for the purposes of improving facilities to support the establishment of permanent units for retail, food and beverage uses as set out in the Business Case (Appendix A) and to replace the asbestos roof..
2.2That the responsibility for the procurement of necessary goods and services and the implementation of the capital works is delegated to the Executive Director (Place). 2.3 That authority be delegated to the Leader to agree to a variation in capital costs if necessary following completion of the open market procurement exercises, up to and not exceeding 30% of the original budget allocation.
2.4In circumstances where tender returns rise beyond 30% of the budget allocation approve will be sought via an Independent Executive Decision.
2.5That a further Cabinet report be required to detail the future Markets Operation that will be necessary to provide support for market traders and market customers.
Executive summary
3.1The Leek Market Hall Options Appraisal ( Appendix B) identified four options for change including a do nothing scenario:
Do Nothing – current 32 Tables ‘Do Minimum’ Market and out of hours use – 32 Tables and some additional events Enhanced market with 2/3 food and beverage units with improved 24 display tables/ stands Permanent units for mixed use – 9 fixed units and 12 improved display tables/ stands
3.1The options were scored against the critical successful factors with Option B and C scoring joint highest (see section 7.6). and it is these two options that have been taken forward to a full business case so that these wider factors can be considered alongside a more detailed understanding of refurbishment costs and longer term management overheads.
3.2The business case identified the preferred option as B with a Benefit Cost Ratio of 1.6 capital costs and 2.4 net public sector costs. It would provide the highest values in relation to local benefits in terms of footfall, visitor/shopper expenditure, employment, and GVA, and also the highest wider benefit score, with an acceptable level of risks. On this basis Option B would be preferred to Option C, which at this stage does not achieve as good value for money and local benefits and represents a higher risk. Nonetheless the successful implementation of option B would allow for further improvements in market facilities to be considered in the future. Option A only performs well in terms of affordability and doesn’t provide a structural opportunity to improve the market offer in Leek.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.