That Tree Preservation Order No.315, with modifications to replace the current Area A1 by individual trees T1-T27 inclusive, and groups of trees G1-G4 inclusive, as shown on the proposed amended plan and amended schedule appended to the report, be confirmed as permanent; 2. That the site be reassessed and any variations to the Order be considered at a future meeting, prior to which a site visit will be undertaken by members of the Committee.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
A TPO was made on 6th February 2024, following reports that tree felling was taking place at the site, with a planning application also having been submitted.
For expediency, the Order was made as a single Area (“blanket”) designation covering the whole site, automatically but indiscriminately protecting every tree present at that time. A copy of the existing provisional TPO is appended to this report.
A single objection to the TPO was initially received from the owners of Moor Edge. The objection was made on several grounds partly on points of principle against the whole Order and partly in detail in respect of various trees considered to be in poor condition.
The Council’s arboricultural officers have subsequently carried out more detailed amenity assessment of the many trees on site and now propose modification of the Order on confirmation to specifically identify and maintain protection over those considered to hold sufficient amenity value whilst omitting those with insufficient amenity value and/or which have been found to be in poor condition.
The detailed amenity assessment and proposed modifications have been discussed with the site owners, and further refined as a result, to the extent that the owners are now happy with the proposed modifications and have withdrawn their objection on the basis that the Order is confirmed in accordance with such modifications. In this event, and subject to the TPO being confirmed with these modifications, there are no remaining unresolved objections to this TPO.
Two representations of support for the TPO have been received, from residents at 69 and 113 New Mills Road which back onto Moor Edge.
3. RECOMMENDED a. The Committee confirms Tree Preservation Order No. 315 with modifications to replace the current Area A1 by individual trees T1 – T27 inclusive and groups of trees G1 – G4 inclusive, as shown on the proposed amended plan and amended schedule appended to this report.
Background
a. Moor Edge is situated directly behind (south-east of) a series of terraced houses along New Mills Road, and abuts the open countryside beyond. A site location plan is appended to this report. The site comprises an extensive plot containing the dwelling, its collection of outbuildings in various states of repair, and large well - wooded but long unmanaged gardens mainly reverted to nature.
b. The trees are mainly appropriate native species in keeping with the semi-rural location, although there are one or two more unusual species also present reflecting a presumed past era of the gardens being more cared for.
c. In combination, the collection of trees provides a useful screening buffer between built-up area and countryside. From longer range publicly accessible viewpoints along Sitch Lane to the north of the site, the trees at Moor Edge contribute usefully to the wider landscape-scale setting of Birch Vale in its wooded valley location.
d. From closer viewpoints along New Mills Road, other than a slightly more open but brief view into the site along its access drive between Nos. 91 and 93, only the upper parts of the taller trees are readily visible.
e. The most prominent view of the trees, again mainly in combination and across an intervening field, is obtained from the public footpath running to the east of the site along Morland Road.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.