HPK/2023/0328 - Portland Nursing Home, 8 Park Road, Buxton
ApprovedPlanning2 papers
AI summaryHigh Peak Borough Council approves conversion of former Portland Nursing Home, Buxton, to 13 homes, dropping 3 affordable units and a £17,281.55 leisure contribution after an independent viability review found the scheme unviable.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApproved13 planning conditions attached, no affordable housing or leisure contributions secured
Money£17,281.55 not securedOriginally sought S106 contribution for play, open space, parks, gardens and allotments
What happens nextDecision notice to be issuedHead of Development Services delegated to amend wording with the Chair
Who it affectsFormer care home site, Buxton13 residential units to be created through conversion and extension
What was decided
The Committee approved planning permission for the conversion and extension of Portland Nursing Home to 13 residential units, without the S106 Agreement previously required. [D] [4.1] Report 4.1
The 3 affordable housing units and the £17,281.55 financial contribution towards play, open space, parks and gardens, and allotments, originally required under the May 2025 resolution, will not be secured. [3.5] [P8] [P22] Report 3.5, P8, P22
Authority was delegated to the Head of Development Services, in consultation with the Committee Chair, to make any minor wording changes to conditions, informatives or planning obligations before the decision is issued. [D] [P29] Report P29
Why
The applicant submitted a further Viability Appraisal in December 2025 arguing the scheme could not support affordable housing or leisure contributions. [3.1] [3.2] Report 3.1, 3.2
Fisher German independently reviewed the appraisal and found the development unviable, with a deficit of -£259,672 and a 7.6% development profit on a 100% open market basis, meaning no S106 contributions or affordable housing could be supported. [3.3] [P14] [P22] Report 3.3, P14, P22
Officers concluded there are no longer reasonable grounds to require the Section 106 matters previously sought, and that granting permission subject to conditions remains appropriate. [3.4] [3.5] [4.1] Report 3.4, 3.5, 4.1
What happens next
A decision notice will be issued with the 13 conditions set out in the report, covering matters such as materials, construction management, drainage, ecology, tree protection and radon mitigation. [4.1] [P27] [P28] Report 4.1, P27, P28
The Head of Development Services may amend wording of conditions, informatives, planning obligations or reasons before the decision is issued, in consultation with the Committee Chair, provided the substantive decision is not altered. [D] [P29] Report P29
The money
£17,281.55 Originally sought S106 contribution towards play, open space, parks and gardens, and allotments; no longer being secured Report P8, 3.5
-£259,672 Deficit identified in the applicant's Viability Appraisal by Development Consultancy on a 100% open market basis, with 7.6% development profit Report P14
£345,000 Fisher German's assessed Benchmark Land Value, lower than the applicant's £400,000 Report P16
£2,745,000 Fisher German's assessed Gross Development Value, higher than the applicant's £2,545,000 Report P17
Options considered
Rejected: Approve subject to conditions and a Section 106 Agreement securing 3 affordable units and the £17,281.55 leisure contribution (the May 2025 resolution). Independent viability review by Fisher German concluded the development cannot support any S106 contributions or affordable housing Report 3.5, P22, 4.1
Chosen: Approve subject to conditions, without any Section 106 Agreement. Officers concluded there are no longer reasonable grounds to require affordable housing or leisure contributions, as the scheme is unviable even on a 100% open market basis Report 3.5, 4.1, P27
Implications
Financial: No affordable housing or leisure contributions will be secured through a Section 106 Agreement, despite being previously resolved by the Committee in May 2025. [3.5] [4.1] Report 3.5, 4.1
Legal: Planning permission is granted subject to 13 conditions, including a 3-year time limit, approved plans, materials, drainage, ecology, construction management and radon mitigation requirements. [P27] [P28] Report P27, P28
Equalities: The loss of the former care home use was previously found acceptable under Local Plan Policy CF5 and national policy, following a viability case reviewed by Fisher German. [2.3] Report 2.3
Risk: Independent viability review concluded the scheme is unviable even on a 100% open market basis and cannot support any S106 matters. [3.3] [P21] [P22] Report 3.3, P21, P22
Who and where
The applicant, who sought to convert and extend the former Portland Nursing Home at 8 Park Road, Buxton, into 13 residential units Report 2.1, 3.1
Future residents of the proposed 13 residential units Report 2.1, P27
Users of play, open space, parks, gardens and allotment provision in the area, who will not receive the originally sought £17,281.55 contribution Report P8, 3.5
People in need of affordable housing, as the 3 affordable units previously required will not be secured Report P7, 3.5
Timeline
19th May 2025: Committee resolved to grant full planning permission subject to a Section 106 Agreement securing 3 affordable housing units and a £17,281.55 leisure contribution, and planning conditions Report 2.1, P7, P8
December 2025: Applicant submitted a further Viability Appraisal prepared by DG Development Consultancy challenging the S106 requirements Report 3.1, 3.2
2026-07-13: Development Control Committee approved the application subject to conditions, without a Section 106 Agreement Report 4.1
Plain English for the jargon
Section 106 Agreement: A legal agreement between a developer and the local council under which the developer agrees to provide contributions or facilities as part of a planning permission
S106: Shortened reference to a Section 106 Agreement used in the report
Viability Appraisal: An assessment of whether a development can deliver enough value to support its costs, including planning policy requirements such as affordable housing and contributions
Benchmark Land Value (BLV): The value used in a viability appraisal as the starting point for land costs, against which the residual value of a scheme is compared
Gross Development Value (GDV): The total value of a completed development, used in viability calculations
C2 Use Class: The planning use class covering residential institutions such as care homes
NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the government's national planning policy in England
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item27/20
Resolved
That the application be approved as set out in the report; and 2. That in the event of any changes being needed to the wording of the Committee’s decision (such as to delete, vary or add conditions/ informatives /planning obligations or reasons for approval/refusal) prior to the decision being issued, the Head of Development Services be delegated authority to do so in consultation with the Chair of the Committee, provided that the changes do not exceed the substantive nature of the Committee’s decision.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
2.1In May 2025, the Committee resolve to grant full planning permission for the conversion and extension of the building to create 13no residential units, subject to securing affordable housing and financial contributions relating to leisure and recreation through a S106 Agreement, and planning conditions.
2.2The Committee Report presented to Members on 19th May 2025 is attached as Appendix 1 to this report.
2.3The principle of the loss of the former Care Home was found to be acceptable having regard to Local Plan Policy CF5 and relevant national planning policies in light of a Viability Appraisal submitted with the applicant being independently reviewed by Fisher German, that concluded that the continuing use of the building as a Residential Care Home or indeed any other use falling within the C2 Use Class is not financially viable.
2.4The application was found to be acceptable with regards to all technical matters relating to Design & Conservation, Residential Amenity, Trees,
1 Ecology and Highway Safety, subject to appropriately worded planning conditions being applied to the Decision Notice.
2.5As the proposed development constituted Major Development, and having regard to comments from relevant consultees, Members resolved to grant planning consent, subject to a S106 Agreement securing the following:
- 3no affordable housing units
- £17,281.55 towards Play, Open Space, Parks & Gardens, and Allotment provision
3. S106 CONTRIBUTIONS AND VIABILITY
3.1Since the application was considered by Committee in May 2025, the applicant has sought to challenge the requirement to deliver the 3no affordable housing units and financial contributions relating to leisure and recreation on the basis that this would make the scheme financially unviable.
3.2The applicant has submitted a Viability Appraisal prepared by DG Development Consultancy (December 2025). The Council appointed Fisher German (one of the market leaders in the field) to carry out an independent review of the applicant’s Appraisal and advise whether the conclusions of this document are valid and reasonable.
3.3The Conclusions made by Fisher German are presented in full below:
We have reviewed the Applicant’s submission as part of the above planning application, namely the financial viability appraisal of Development Consultancy.
Development Consultancy’s own appraisal concludes that the development is unviable, even on a 100% Open Market basis. The appraisal prepared indicates a deficit of -£259,672 and provides a development profit of 7.6%. Development Consultancy have not provided an assessment based upon a policy compliant scheme. No supporting information or commentary is included within their Report as to how the scheme will be delivered with such a significant viability gap.
We have undertaken an appraisal to consider the viability of the proposed development upon an open market and policy compliant position from this. In comparison with Development Consultancy’s assessment;
• We consider that the Benchmark Land Value (BLV) is lower than that proposed by Development Consultancy (£345,000 vs £400,000).
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.