Resolved
That this Council notes that Hillingdon has the highest number of asylum seekers housed in hotels or dispersed accommodation of any local authority in London (more than 4.5 times the London average) and possibly the highest nationally. It is unfair and unsustainable to require Hillingdon's residents to carry the grossly disproportionate burden of supporting former asylum seekers evicted from hotels as required by law. Council also notes with concern the commitment of Government to evict into this borough more than 2,300 asylum seekers presently housed in our hotels by the end of the present Parliament. To protect the interests of Hillingdon's residents, this Council requires Government to cease the practice of evicting former asylum seekers from hotels and dispersed accommodation within our borough without the necessary future support and accommodation having been secured and funded by the Home Office and to refund the cost shouldered by Hillingdon's residents to date. Furthermore, this Council calls on our three Members of Parliament to work with Government to secure the immediate funding for Hillingdon's asylum cost to date, to ensure that the responsibility for supporting and accommodating those evicted from hotels in the borough will, from this point on, be equitably shared nationally, and that the funding of port authorities is commensurate with the additional responsibilities that they discharge on behalf of the nation. 8.2 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR MATHERS Councillor Mathers moved, and Councillor Gill seconded, the following motion: That this Council is seriously concerned at the Cabinet’s broken promises to its residents with reversal of the affirmation agreed in July 2023 by Full Council that: “this Council affirms our commitment to free weekly bin collections, including recycling and green waste collections and thanks our Council staff for their dedication to their work.” And that this: “Council reaffirms that it rejects the idea of charging residents for the collection of garden waste”. The Cabinet reasons for supporting policies that have introduced an initial £70 subscription charge for this service in the borough was to save £34 million to balance the budget and avoid bankruptcy. Therefore, this Council calls on the Cabinet to refer the implementation and introduction of charges for waste to the relevant select committee in order to scrutinise the effectiveness of this measure in achieving the desired savings at regular intervals over the coming financial year to assure residents that this and other aspects of the savings programme will raise the required funds in year to remain within budget. Those speaking in support of the motion suggested that the introduction of a £70 garden waste subscription represented a serious breach of the Conservative administration’s manifesto promise to maintain free weekly green waste collections. It was noted that there was no clarity provided on future charge increases and it had been framed as part of a broader trend of rising fees and broken commitments. Residents already faced steep increases in parking permits and service charges, and the Council had committed to annual 5% rises in fees since 2024. 79% of residents opposed the charge in the consultation, with many indicating that they would resort to fly-tipping or dispose of green waste in general waste bins. These actions could cost the Council more than the revenue generated. A lack of transparency and scrutiny were also criticised, with only 17% of residents reportedly indicating they would subscribe, casting doubt on the projected £2.5 million income. The motion had been presented as a call for accountability, with a referral to a select committee for review urged, alongside a restoration of public trust through honouring commitments and ensuring proper oversight. Those speaking against the motion noted that the Council’s decision to introduce a garden waste subscription had been a regrettable but necessary response to financial pressures, which had been caused by broken promises from the Labour government. It was explained that the Council had been forced to abandon its July 2023 commitment due to an unexpected rise in employer National Insurance contributions, which had initially been promised to be offset by the government but had not been delivered. As a result, a budget gap had been created and needed to be addressed through the new charge. Criticism was also directed at the Labour government for its failure to control illegal immigration, rising public debt and its contribution to inflation and job losses, all of which were said to have intensified financial strain on local authorities. The motion was described as one that ignored these broader economic realities and unfairly targeted a voluntary £70 charge which was lower than those imposed by many neighbouring Labour councils, while overlooking the Council’s efforts to manage its finances responsibly. It was suggested that free disposal options remained available to residents and that the motion was politically motivated rather than a genuine attempt to address challenges. The motion was put to the vote and lost. 8.1 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR CURLING Councillor Curling moved, and Councillor Gardner seconded, the following motion: That this Council notes the devastating impact that a third runway, at Heathrow airport, would have on our borough and its residents. Council further notes the well documented detrimental impact on the environment, as well as the adverse impact on the health and well-being of a significant number of residents within our borough, should a third runway be built and brought into operation. This Council therefore reaffirms its strong, cross party, opposition to a third runway at Heathrow Airport. Support from all parties was expressed for the motion on the grounds that the proposed third runway at Heathrow would cause irreversible harm to the environment and local communities, and that the Council’s long-standing cross-party opposition should be reaffirmed. The proposed expansion would threaten historic villages, increase pollution, worsen health outcomes and contribute to the climate crisis. It was noted that Heathrow had already impacted more residents than any other major European airport, and that proposed mitigation measures were not considered adequate. Social impacts such as the loss of family homes, the rise in HMOs and the breakdown of community cohesion were also highlighted. Successive governments were criticised for prioritising economic growth over public health and environmental sustainability. The motion was a call for stronger Council action through planning controls and enforcement as the runway would cause unacceptable disruption and long-term damage and continued opposition was essential. The motion was put to a recorded vote: Those voting in favour: The Mayor (Councillor Philip Corthorne), the Deputy Mayor (Councillor Reeta Chamdal), Councillors Abby, Ahmad-Wallana, Banerjee, Basit, Bennett, Bhatt, Bianco, Burles, Burrows, Roy Chamdal, Choubedar, Curling, Davies, Denys, Dhot, Edwards, Farley, Gardner, Garelick, Garg, Gill, Goddard, Gohil, Higgins, Islam, Kaur, Lakhmana, Lavery, Lewis, Makwana, Mand, Martin, Mathers, D Mills, R Mills, Money, Nelson, Nelson-West, Palmer, Punja, Riley, Sansarpuri, Singh, Smallwood, Sullivan and Sweeting. Those voting against: None. Those abstaining: None. The motion was unanimously agreed, and it was: That this Council notes the devastating impact that a third runway, at Heathrow airport, would have on our borough and its residents. Council further notes the well documented detrimental impact on the environment, as well as the adverse impact on the health and well-being of a significant number of residents within our borough, should a third runway be built and brought into operation. This Council therefore reaffirms its strong, cross party, opposition to a third runway at Heathrow Airport. 8.3 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR PUNJA Councillor Punja moved, and Councillor Mathers seconded, the following motion: That this Council agrees to call on Councillor Lavery, Cabinet Member for Community and Environment to reconsider the Cabinet decision to close the retail operations of the Rural Activities Garden Centre made on June 26 th 2025 for the following a) failure to accurately analyse or calculate financial income year on year income under Financial Implications b) failure to have sought and costed alternative providers for the site to remain open. c) failure to have scoped, costed, assessed and consulted on new provision for gardeners with social care package to ensure a safe environment d) misleading information on £1.2m needed for investment to meet Health and Safety standards as this cost was based on an improvement plan proposal. e) failure to provide reasonable adjustments for adults with learning disabilities as per guidance in the Equalities Act at the initial engagement meeting of 30 th May 2025 This Council values robust reporting to make high quality decisions and asks the Cabinet member for Community and Environment to instruct officers to provide an updated report addressing, but not limited to, the concerns listed above and submit to the relevant Select Committees for scrutiny before going to Cabinet for a decision. Support was expressed for reconsidering the closure of the Rural Activities Garden Centre, which had been valued for its beneficial and inclusive services. Despite strong public opposition, the Conservative administration was reported to have approved the closure of its retail operations, with key Cabinet Members absent during the decision. The Cabinet report was criticised for inaccuracies and procedural failings and concerns were raised over the lack of alternative provision and consultation. A 90 day fundraising period was requested to avoid reliance on Council subsidy. The decision-making process was condemned as lacking integrity and compassion. Opposition to the motion was based on the view that the Rural Activities Garden Centre had been a commercial, not commissioned, service. The subsidy withdrawal was defended as financially responsible, consistent with previous decisions on non-essential services. Confidence was expressed in adult social care services and assurances were given that alternative support would be provided. The closure was described as limited to retail operations, with horticultural activities under review and engagement with families ongoing. It was maintained that the Council lacked the mandate to run a commercial garden centre. The motion was put to a recorded vote: Those voting in favour: Councillors Abby, Basit, Burles, Curling, Dhot, Farley, Gardner, Garelick, Garg, Islam, Kaur, Lakhmana, Mand, Mathers, Money, Nelson, Nelson-West, Punja, Sansarpuri, Singh and Sweeting. Those voting against: The Mayor (Councillor Philip Corthorne), the Deputy Mayor (Councillor Reeta Chamdal), Councillors Ahmad-Wallana, Banerjee, Bennett, Bhatt, Bianco, Burrows, Roy Chamdal, Choubedar, Davies, Denys, Edwards, Goddard, Gohil, Higgins, Lavery, Lewis, Makwana, Martin, D Mills, R Mills, Palmer, Riley, Smallwood and Sullivan. Those abstaining: None. The motion was lost.