CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
London Borough of Hillingdon
Council, Thursday 27 November 2025 at 7.30pm

Motions

Refused Committee 1 paper

AI summaryHillingdon Council called on its Leader to seek urgent clarity on health hub funding and, if necessary, reopen Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit until long term services are in place.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedPossible reopening if necessary
MoneyNo funding allocatedFor construction of promised health hubs
What happens nextLeader seeks funding clarityWritten request to Health Secretary
Who it affectsResidents and hospital servicesUrgent and diagnostic health provision

What was decided

Council said it was deeply disappointed that the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit had closed. Report P14

Council called on the Leader to ask the Secretary of State for Health when funding for the promised health hubs would become available. Report P16

Council called for reopening of the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit if necessary, until long term solutions were in place. Report P16

Why

The closure happened before adequate alternative provision had been secured, placing a further burden on the Accident & Emergency Unit at Hillingdon Hospital. Report P15

The hospital rebuilding was delayed by the Government. The promised health hubs were still years away, and no funding had yet been allocated for their construction in Hillingdon. Report P15

The unit was relied upon by thousands of residents, and more than 27,000 people signed a petition opposing closure. A recent survey showed strong support to retain it, while many believe no meaningful public consultation took place. Report P14

What happens next

The Leader should write to the Secretary of State for Health seeking urgent clarity on when funding will be made available. Report P16

Seek reopening of the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit if necessary until long term solutions are in place. Report P16

Options considered

  • Chosen: Seek urgent clarity on health hub funding. No construction funding has yet been allocated in Hillingdon. Report P15, P16
  • Chosen: Seek reopening of Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit if necessary. The closure came before adequate alternative provision had been secured. Report P15, P16

Implications

  • Financial: No funding has yet been allocated for construction of the promised health hubs in Hillingdon. Report P15
  • Risk: The closure adds further burden to the Accident & Emergency Unit at Hillingdon Hospital. Report P15
  • Other: The promised health hubs remain years away. Report P15
  • Other: Reopening the urgent care unit may be needed until long term solutions are in place. Report P16
  • Other: The funding request is for urgent and diagnostic health services for Hillingdon residents. Report P16

Who and where

  • Hillingdon residents Report P14, P16
  • People who relied on the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit Report P14
  • Accident & Emergency Unit at Hillingdon Hospital Report P15
  • Hillingdon Council and its Leader Report P16

Timeline

  • 27 November 2025: Council made the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit decision. Report P14, P16, P17

Plain English for the jargon

  • Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit: The closed urgent care unit at the centre of the decision.
  • Health hubs: Promised services intended to provide urgent and diagnostic health services.
  • Accident & Emergency Unit: The Hillingdon Hospital unit described as carrying a further burden.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item39

Resolved

That this Council expresses its deep disappointment at the closure of the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit, a service relied upon by thousands of residents. More than 27,000 people signed a petition opposing the decision, yet their views were dismissed, and many believe no meaningful public consultation was undertaken. A recent survey again showed strong public support to retain the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit. The closure has taken place before adequate alternative provision has been secured placing a further burden on the Accident & Emergency Unit at Hillingdon Hospital. The rebuilding of the Hospital has been delayed by the Government and the promised health hubs remain years away with no funding having yet been allocated for their construction in Hillingdon. This Council therefore calls on the Leader to write to the Secretary of State for Health seeking urgent clarity on when funding will be made available to Hillingdon to develop the promised health hubs to provide urgent and diagnostic health services to Hillingdon residents and, if necessary, to reopen the Mount Vernon Urgent Care Unit until long-term solutions are in place. 11.1 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR GARELICK (held over from Council meeting on 11 September 2025) Councillor Garelick moved, and Councillor Mathers seconded, the following motion: That this Council recognises that the presentation and cleanliness of our residential streets across the whole borough have been in sharp decline this year, clearly indicating that the Council’s financial troubles are having a significant impact on our frontline services such as refuse collection, street cleansing, and weed removal. Therefore, this Council calls on the administration to take action to improve these frontline services, in order to keep our streets clean and restore a sense of pride in our communities. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that residents were frustrated, angry and embarrassed about the condition and state of Hillingdon’s streets which needed to be cleaned up. This was not thought to be the street cleaning teams’ fault but had been a short-sighted move, driven by budget cuts to deliver efficiencies which had had a big impact on residents. The Council had started to charge residents for bulky waste and green waste collections (which had proved to be a false economy) and had stopped closing some parks at night to save money. Some residents in the south of the Borough did not see street sweepers and residents had seen a sharp decline in basic services alongside an increase in their Council Tax. Residents had been submitting complaints about the litter around bus stops and shops and deserved a commitment to help restore pride in their community. Action needed to be undertaken to work with local businesses to reduce packaging and with HMO landlords. Neglected streets sent a message that no one cared about the area which then attracted fly tipping and resulted in further neglect. There were no campaigns to address the condition of the Borough’s roads and the prohibition notices on lampposts were small and no fines were issued which meant that nothing changed. The number of fly tipping hotspots had been multiplying every week and, as there were only six enforcement officers for the whole Borough, it was suggested that mobile CCTV be utilised to help deal with this increase. Those speaking against the motion noted that it did not reflect the reality of services. Complaints had reduced by 17%, £1.5m had been raised through the green waste collection charges and seven new street sweepers had been put into operation. A new Love Clean Streets app would soon be rolled out and weed spraying had been completed across the Borough. Hillingdon had been rated as the seventh best performing local authority in London for recycling and additional action was being investigated to further improve efficiency. Everyone agreed that residents deserved clean streets. Members on the Council’s Residents’ Services Select Committee had been briefed on the scale of pressures and the lack of funds and, despite this, Hillingdon had delivered exceptionally well and had continued its weekly waste collections. It was noted that fly tipping had not increased following the introduction of the green waste charge. The motion was put to the vote and lost. 11.2 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR CURLING Councillor Curling moved, and Councillor Gardner seconded, the following motion: That this Council expresses its concern and disappointment that the Labour Government have u-turned on the issue of mandating developers to install ‘Swift bricks’ in all new developments. This Council also notes the campaigns by organisations such as the RSPB and other rare bird organisations for the inclusion of swift bricks in all new developments. As a responsible council and one that believes that we should do all that we can to protect wildlife, rare birds, and generally enhance our biodiversity, this Council calls on the Cabinet to consider ways in which we could either introduce our own local policy on swift bricks or at least encourage developers to include them on future new builds. Those speaking in support of the motion believed that it should not be a contentious matter. Some places that birds used to nest were no longer accessible and Steve Reed MP (the former Environment Secretary) had now withdrawn his support for ‘Swift bricks’ since becoming the Housing Secretary, despite each only costing around £30. It was hoped that a local arrangement could be agreed. A new flatted development would only need 4-10 Swift bricks and a house would need about two so this would not result in huge costs. Those speaking against the motion advised that they supported wildlife and, whilst the spirit of the motion was welcomed, any action taken needed to be practical and not add complexity. The Government decision had recognised that one size would not fit all and that it would be important not to hinder home building. The requirement for Swift bricks would increase the cost of affordable homes at a time when the number of affordable homes needed to increase. Biodiversity could be delivered through a range of initiatives that could really make a difference. The motion was put to the vote and lost. 11.3 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR PUNJA Councillor Punja moved, and Councillor Mathers seconded, the following motion: That this Council notes the findings of the October/November 2025 Budget Monitoring Report, which confirm the comprehensive financial failure of this Conservative administration, specifically: · Hillingdon is now dependent on Exceptional Financial Support from the Labour Government simply to remain a going concern. · The Administration has failed to deliver its £34m in-year savings, resulting in a £36m overspend at Month 6 and rising. · Reserves have collapsed from +£70m to –£34.5m, a total deterioration of £104.5m under this administration. · The Council’s financial position is now unsafe and unsustainable, with no general fund unearmarked reserves left, depleted general · reserves, mismanaged operational overspend, future asset sales with the only option being anticipated Labour government support. · Repeated failures - from the FMP and GRIP programme to green waste subscription - have further destabilised the Council’s finances, placing the burden of Conservative mismanagement squarely on Hillingdon residents. That this Council also acknowledges that any lawful budget must be: 1. that the budget should be balanced or sustainable in-year 2. that the budget should be supported by adequate reserves to manage financial risk This Administration’s budget meets neither test nor can any longer credibly be defended as lawful. Therefore, this Council believes the situation is critical and requests the relevant Statutory Officers to urgently consider: 1. Issuing a Section 114 Report, under the Local Government Finance Act 1988, recognising that the Council has an unlawful, unbalanced budget that fails the 2 binary tests and cannot meet its expenditure commitments 2. At the same time, issuing a Section 5 Report under the Local Government and Housing Act 1989, confirming the full legal implications and consequences and advising on direct, indirect and consequential implications for the Council and Councillors on the failures of governance that have led to this position. 3. Requesting a Report in the Public Interest (RIPI), commissioned under the Local Audit and Accountability Act. To be undertaken by the Council’s external auditor (EY) with independent oversight from CIPFA, ensuring full objectivity and compliance with the statutory Best Value duty (Section 3, Local Government Act 1999). The RIPI – to be reported publicly to Full Council in January 2026 - must provide an unqualified, independent account of: · The collapse of reserves from +£70m to –£34.5m, a deterioration of £104.5m under this administration. · The Month 6 overspend, failure to deliver savings, and decisions leading to the Council’s effective insolvency. · An examination of the past 15 years of “delivered” savings against budgeted savings, including whether the administration’s repeated claims of balanced budgets were in fact undelivered savings and overspends covered up by the year-on-year depletion of reserves. · The governance, oversight and leadership failures that enabled this financial collapse. 4. Establishing an Emergency Financial Recovery Team, working directly under the control of central government, external inspectors and statutory officers to halt further financial deterioration and stabilise the authority. 5. Producing a Wednesbury Compliance Report. The Monitoring Officer to provide written legal advice to Full Council setting out the personal legal risks to the Administration and all Members who voted for the February 2025 Budget, should their decisions be found to violate the Wednesbury principles of reasonableness, given the escalating negative reserves - including the additional £13.9m deterioration in the last two months alone under this Administration. Those speaking in support of the motion noted that the Administration had inherited £70m of useable reserves which had now gone. Various Cabinet Members had repeatedly stated that the Council had been in a stable financial position, that Section 114 (S114) was not happening, that every London Borough had been in the same financial position, that the budget had been robust and the reserves were adequate and that EFS was prudential stewardship. The evidence of this assurance that everything was fine had been recorded despite everything not being fine and the Administration’s response to institutional failure had been to set unreasonable budgets. Over £14m of accounting adjustments had been wiped out straight away and zero savings had been delivered. The SEND deficit, high cost acquisitions and scrapping Goss had contributed to the reduction in Hillingdon’s reserves but there were questions over where the money had gone and when the non-essential spend would end. An independent audit would identify what had happened and why as it appeared that the Council’s finances had failed by choice, not chance. It was reiterated that the motion sought a S114 report, not a request to issue a S114 notice and it was queried why the motion would be rejected if the Administration had nothing to hide. The Government had cut local government to the bone for a decade yet the Administration had been blaming everyone but themselves for the Council’s current financial situation. Those speaking against the motion noted that it would force officers to spend time doing things that they did not have time for and would not meet the Wednesbury principle of reasonableness. Members had received a large amount of paperwork in relation to the last budget, the Audit Committee had been scrutinising the action being taken and progress made and all Select Committees had been looking at the budgets within their remits. The Labour motion would enable the Government to raise more money off of Hillingdon residents. It was suggested that the motion smacked of political opportunism as a S114 would be disastrous for residents and staff and should be avoided at all costs. ____________________________________ At 10.30pm, Councillor R Mills moved, and Councillor Edwards seconded, that the meeting continue so that Agenda Item 11.3 (the final item on the agenda) could be concluded. The motion was carried. ____________________________________ Councillor R Mills moved Standing Order 13j, that the question be now put. The motion was seconded by Councillor Edwards and carried. ____________________________________ The motion was put to the vote and lost.
Word for word from the decision Hillingdon published for this meeting. Source: modgov.hillingdon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Hillingdon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council, 3 pages

MOTIONS 11.1 MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR GARELICK (held over from Council meeting on 11 September 2025)

That this Council recognises that the presentation and cleanliness of our residential streets across the whole borough have been in sharp decline this year, clearly indicating that the Council’s financial troubles are having a significant impact on our frontline services such as refuse collection, street cleansing, and weed removal.

Therefore, this Council calls on the administration to take action to improve these frontline services, in order to keep our streets clean and restore a sense of pride in our communities.

11.2MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR CURLING

That this Council expresses its concern and disappointment that the Labour Government have u-turned on the issue of mandating developers to install ‘Swift bricks’ in all new developments. This Council also notes the campaigns by organisations such as the RSPB and other rare bird organisations for the inclusion of swift bricks in all new developments.

As a responsible council and one that believes that we should do all that we can to protect wildlife, rare birds, and generally enhance our biodiversity, this Council calls on the Cabinet to consider ways in which we could either introduce our own local policy on swift bricks or at least encourage developers to include them on future new builds.

11.3MOTION FROM COUNCILLOR PUNJA

That this Council notes the findings of the October/November 2025 Budget Monitoring Report, which confirm the comprehensive financial failure of this Conservative administration, specifically:  Hillingdon is now dependent on Exceptional Financial Support from the Labour Government simply to remain a going concern.  The Administration has failed to deliver its £34m in-year savings, resulting in a £36m overspend at Month 6 and rising.  Reserves have collapsed from +£70m to –£34.5m, a total deterioration of £104.5m under this administration.  The Council’s financial position is now unsafe and unsustainable, with no general fund unearmarked reserves left, depleted general reserves, mismanaged operational overspend, future asset sales with the only option being anticipated Labour government support.  Repeated failures — from the FMP and GRIP programme to green waste subscription — have further destabilised the Council’s finances, placing the burden of Conservative mismanagement squarely on Hillingdon residents.

Council – 27 November 2025 That this Council also acknowledges that any lawful budget must be: 1. that the budget should be balanced or sustainable in-year 2. that the budget should be supported by adequate reserves to manage financial risk

This Administration’s budget meets neither test nor can any longer credibly be defended as lawful.

Therefore, this Council believes the situation is critical and requests the relevant Statutory Officers to urgently consider:

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
MotionsReport 3 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

47 of 61 attended
PC
Councillor Philip Corthorne MCIPDMayor, present
RC
Councillor Reeta ChamdalDeputy Mayor, present
NA
Councillor Naser AbbyCommittee Member, present
SA
Councillor Shehryar Ahmad-WallanaCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Kaushik BanerjeeCommittee Member, present
LB
Councillor Labina BasitCommittee Member, present
AB
Councillor Adam BennettCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Kishan BhattCommittee Member, apologies
JB
Councillor Jonathan BiancoCommittee Member, apologies
WB
Councillor Wayne BridgesCommittee Member, present
TB
Councillor Tony BurlesCommittee Member, present
KB
Councillor Keith BurrowsCommittee Member, present

All 61 on the meeting page

On this subject at Hillingdon

Search all
  1. MotionsThis decision
  2. MotionsNoted
  3. MotionsNoted
  4. MotionsNoted
  5. MotionsAgreed
  6. MotionsAgreed

More from Hillingdon Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 Sep 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the Council meeting held on 9 July 2026 be agreed as a correct record. Agreed Open
24 Sep 2026 Report of the Head of Democratic ServicesThat the urgent decisions be noted. 6.2 POLITICAL GROUPS ON THE COUNCIL, CALCULATION OF POLITICAL BALANCE AND COMMITT... Noted Open
9 Jul 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 26 February 2026 and 14 May 2026 be agreed as correct records. Agreed Open
9 Jul 2026 Report of the Head of Democratic ServicesThat: i) the urgency decisions detailed in the report be noted. ii) a) the result of the election in Hillingdon West ... Noted Open
9 Jul 2026 West London Waste Plan Regulation 19That: the publication and consultation of the Proposed Submission (Regulation 19) West London Waste Plan, as attached... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies