Resolved
Please see the report of the Licensing Officer (agenda item 3) The application was heard by Councillors Brad Fisher, Elizabeth Hughes and Shantanu Rajawat. The report was presented by Nigel Farmer, Head of Business Regulations and Legal Adviser to the Panel was Simon Jones. The applicant was represented by [name removed], Barrister and [name removed], Licensing Consultant. [name removed] presented the report and advised that the application had been varied by the applicant to permit the sale of alcohol for consumption off the premises between the hours of 07:00 to 23:00 Monday to Sunday and that late night refreshment was no longer part of the application. The report was agreed to be otherwise correct. The application was first part-heard on 11 September 2012. At that hearing Leo Charalambides acknowledged that the data provided did not meet the Panel’s request for the information needed to establish primary use. He stated that the company would have had to hire a market research company to obtain the necessary data and had decided against that course of action on grounds of cost. [name removed] requested an adjournment to enable the data to be gathered and supplied. The Panel decided to adjourn the hearing until 23 October to obtain the information. [name removed] requested a further adjournment on 23 October as the requested information had still not been obtained. He advised that if the Panel considered the matter at that time he would make no submission but would consider appealing a decision. Questioned by [name removed] on the extent of the information under discussion [name removed] acknowledged that Shell were gathering data that significantly exceeded that requested, however he stated that he was unfortunately not in a position to submit the data the Panel had requested. He assured the Panel that he could obtain the requested information plus additional data. [name removed] advised that the Panel could make a decision on whether to grant the licence based purely on the licensing objectives, but the applicant would not be able to legally supply alcohol even if the licence were to be granted unless it could be established that the premises was not primarily a garage, under s176 of the Licensing Act 2003; therefore further information was necessary if any Premises Licence were to be used. The hearing was adjourned until 22 January 2013 to obtain the further information listed below under “Resolved.” At the 22 January hearing [name removed] advised that he wished to make a preliminary application for the hearing to proceed without s176 data for the same reasons as given for the Shell Sunbury application. (Please see decision on agenda item 2). He advised that there was no police representation for this item but accepted that there were a greater number of public objections than had been the case for the Sunbury application. The Panel adjourned to obtain legal advice. Having fully considered the oral representations from the applicant’s barrister and considered legal advice, the Panel found that the licensing objectives had ...