Item3
Resolved
Please see the report of the Licensing Officer (agenda item 3) The application was heard by Councillors Darshan Grewal, Tom Bruce and Adrian Lee. The report was presented by Nigel Farmer, Head of Business Regulations and Legal Adviser to the Panel was Caroline Eaton. This application was heard before the Shell Sunbury application (agenda item 2) as a resident who had submitted a representation, [name removed], attended the hearing to speak. The applicant was represented by [name removed], Barrister and [name removed], Licensing Consultant. The application was first part-heard on 11 September 2012 when the matter had been adjourned until 23 October to enable the applicant to present additional information at the Panel’s request, for the purpose of establishing primary use under s176 of the Licensing Act 2003. (S176 permits the sale of alcohol under a Premises Licence if primary use is as a convenience store, rather than a garage, defined as a business mainly dealing in fuel and/or vehicle sale or repair). At the 23 October hearing the data provided still did not meet the Panel’s request for the above information and the Panel decided to adjourn the hearing until 22 January 2013 to obtain the information requested. At the 22 January hearing [name removed] made a preliminary application for the hearing to proceed without s176 data as had the premises licence application by the petrol retailer and convenience store Malthurst Jolly Sailor (MSJ), heard on 16 January 2013 by Hounslow’s Licensing Panel. The Panel decided that it was unable to determine the issue of primary use without the additional information requested and therefore decided to adjourn the hearing until 16 April 2013 so that the applicant could supply the further information. At the 16 April hearing [name removed] advised that the application had originally been for a 24/7 alcohol licence and 11 pm to 5 am late night refreshments. The police had made a representation against the Shell Sunbury application as a responsible authority and Shell had amended both their applications as a direct response to those police concerns. The store would continue to open 24 hours a day and, if a licence were to be granted, would sell alcohol through a hatch between the hours of 11 pm and 7 am; all groceries were currently sold that way as the doors closed between those hours. [name removed] acknowledged the difficulty of interpreting the Secretary of State’s s182 guidance to the Licensing Act 2003, particularly in the light of the fact that case law was based on the Licensing Act 1964. He acknowledged that the Panel had the right to ask for any additional data that was relevant and material to decision making based on the licensing objectives and advised that he had prepared a detailed argument on the principles, established by older cases, that turnover and footfall information could be used to establish primary use. [name removed] stated that the s182 guidance allowed the Panel to ask for all information necessary to determine primary ...
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.
Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk