Resolved
It was agreed that if the wheelie bin trial was expanded significantly, a further report would be brought to the scrutiny panel.
Housing and Environment Scrutiny Panel agreed this item on Monday 17 March 2014. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
It was agreed that if the wheelie bin trial was expanded significantly, a further report would be brought to the scrutiny panel.
Final report on the wheeled bin trial for Housing and Environment Committee 17th March 2014
A report evaluating the wheeled bin trial was presented to Cabinet and Scrutiny during February. At this point not all of the data had been captured so a follow up report was agreed to be provided to this meeting.
The report evaluated the following indicators:
1. Providing customers with an excellent service 2. Keeping rubbish off the Streets 3. Increasing recycling and composting Rates 4. Increasing participations rates 5. Reducing the volume of rubbish collected
Final data for indicators 2, 3, and 4 was included in the original report so they have not been analysed any further.
Providing customers with an excellent service
2466 residents in the trial areas responded to the consultation survey. This is a very high response rate of 34%. In total 94% off all respondents were in favour of the use of wheeled bins for the collection of their household rubbish. This was highest in Hounslow West with 98% of respondents in favour of the wheeled bins and lowest in Chiswick Riverside with 84% of respondents in favour of the wheeled bins. 97% were in favour in Syon; 96% in Feltham West; 94% in Heston West and 89% of respondents who did not provide their street name were in favour of the use of wheeled bins. This means that the vast majority of residents across all five trial areas were in favour of using wheeled bins for the collection of their household rubbish.
82% of respondents thought that levels of spillage and littering had reduced as a result of the wheeled bin collections, with 64% of respondents reporting a lot less spillage and littering and 18% of respondents a little less spillage and littering. The percentage of respondents reporting a reduction in spillage and littering was highest in Feltham West and lowest in Chiswick Riverside. However, even in Chiswick Riverside 76% of respondents noticed a reduction in spillage and littering.
48% of respondents across all areas of the trial thought that using a wheeled bin for the collection of their household rubbish had helped them to recycle more. This is demonstrated in the increase in recycling rates previously reported and the reduction in waste in the trial area, reported below.
88% of respondents would also like to continue using the wheeled bin for the collection of their household rubbish. 89% of respondents were either satisfied or very satisfied with the collection of their rubbish in a wheeled bin, with 56% very satisfied and 33% satisfied. This ranged from 63% very satisfied and 28% satisfied in Feltham West to 50% very satisfied and 34% satisfied in Chiswick Riverside.
Full analysis of the data can be found in Appendix 1. Reducing the volume of rubbish
Tonnage data has now been evaluated for the whole duration of the trial (July 2013- January 2014). The data and calculations can be found in Appendix 2. As more data is collected and analysed, a more accurate estimate of the effect of the trial can be presented. Analysis of 6 months shows similar results as 4 months data, with a slight improvement. The waste produced per household in the wheeled bin trial has continued to be produced at the same rate. Consequently the revised estimate for the volume of rubbish produced by households in the trial is 456kg per household per year; a 1kg decrease from the estimate reported at Scrutiny in February. This result is positive given that households generally produce more waste over the Christmas period. Across the rest of the borough there has been an increase in waste by 2kg per household per year to 535kg. This final data shows 79kg less rubbish per annum is produced by the households using wheeled bins compared to all other households in the borough. This is a 32% reduction in rubbish.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
Wheeled Bin TrialReport | 145 KB | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
Wheeled Bin TrialsReport | 95 KB | Download |
Follow Housing and Environment Scrutiny Panel at Hounslow and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 Apr 2023 | Finalising RecommendationsInformed by engagement, data and evidence, the Panel agreed recommendations for Cabinet to consider based on effectiv... | Agreed | Open |
| 18 Apr 2023 | Discussion about topics for work programme 2023/24To note the suggestions | Noted | Open |
| 29 Apr 2019 | Hounslow's response to the implementation and impact of the new Tri-Borough Command Unit model on HounslowThe Panel noted Hounslow's response to the implementation and impact of the new Tri-Borough Command Unit model on Hou... | Noted | Open |
| 29 Apr 2019 | Update from Task and Finish group: Prevention of fly-tippingThe Panel noted the update to the TFG on fly tipping | Noted | Open |
| 29 Apr 2019 | Workshop: Review of the 2018/19 Housing and Environment Scrutiny Panel activities and impact and recommendations for the next work programmeThe Panel noted its work programme for the year 2018/2019 | Noted | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.