Resolved
That planning permission for planning application 00527/2/P6 for the conversion of building to single dwellinghouse , demolition of existing extensions and garage, erection of a single storey rear extension and outbuilding, alterations to the driveway and front garden, erection of four houses at rear of site with associated alterations, parking and landscaping at 17 Hartington Road, Chiswick be refused for the following reasons: a) The proposed new-build houses in the rear garden on no.17 Hartington Road would, by way of their bulky scale, intrusive design and inappropriate location within a back garden setting, detract from the character and appearance of the site and the surrounding conservation area, contrary to Local Plan Policies SC1, CC1 and CC4 and the intent of the Grove Park Conservation Area Appraisal. b) The proposal has failed to demonstrate that the new-build houses and associated works would not result in unacceptable and irreversible harm to biodiversity at the site, arising from the loss of mature trees and planting and the longer-term impact through light pollution and human activity. The proposal would run contrary to Local Plan Policy GB7. c) The proposal has failed to demonstrate that the existing flood defences in place at the site are sufficient to withstand future flood risk, and consequently the Council cannot be assured that the new-build houses and associated works would not result in harmful fluvial or tidal flood risk to future occupiers of the site or neighbouring properties. The application is therefore contrary to Local Plan policy EQ3 and the intent of the National Planning Policy Framework. (Members moved suspension of standing orders to complete the business on the agenda at this point in the meeting).