Resolved : a) That planning permission for planning application P/2021/3347 for the change of use of the basement from bookmakers ancillary office to E(g) office use and the construction of a side door opening to the first floor flat, be refused as the developer had not used ‘secured by design’ principles in the design of the proposal and there were concerns about security. b) A further reason for refusal was that there would be an impact on privacy and residential amenity of the existing tenant.
Word for word from the decision Hounslow published for this meeting.Source: democraticservices.hounslow.gov.uk
1.1The proposal is for the change of use of the basement from an office ancillary to the use of the ground floor betting shop to a self-contained office with a new side entrance for independent access.
1.2Due to the small -scale nature of the proposal, it is considered that the introduction of the self-contained office use in this location would not have any unacceptable impact on the office provision in town centres or other economic centres nearby; and is considered acceptable in principle.
1.3The proposal would avoid harm to the living condition of neighbouring properties in terms of noise and disturbances, and would also avoid harm to the appearance of the Conservation Area.
1.4The applicant has now appealed to the Planning Inspectorate on the basis that the Local Planning Authority did not determine the application within the statutory 8 week timeframe. This is called an ‘Appeal against non – determination. There is a period of ‘dual jurisdiction’ within which the authority can approve a scheme. In the event of members resolving to refuse the application this will form the grounds on which officers defend the decision on appeal.
Planning approval is therefore recommended subject to conditions.
2.0SITE DESCRIPTION
2.1The subject site contains a two-storey, mid-terrace property, with a betting shop to the ground floor (Use Class: Sui Generis), with ancillary office space at basement level and a dwelling to the first and second floors. The subject property is characterised by a full width, blue powder coated shop front, with fascia signage above. The main entrance to the betting shop is from South Street, with a red painted double timber arched doorway to the east of the shopfront, within the application’s red-line boundary. The covered side entrance facilitates access to the first floor flat and their rear garden, as well as being the main entrance for the three dwellings at the eastern neighbour 35 South Street.
2.2The site is located within Isleworth Riverside Conservation Area, and is designated as a Large Neighbourhood Centre.
2.3To the east and west of the site are further two-storey terraced properties with commercial units to the ground floor and flats above. To the north of the site on the oppsite side of South Street and two, three-storey flats blocks. With predominately two-storey residential properties to the south.
Figure 1: Site Location Plan
3.0Relevant History
01031/37/P1 Installation of a new shopfront. Granted: 15/06/1965
01031/37/P2 Use of shop premises as betting office and to carry out alterations, including the installation of a new shopfront and the erection of an extension at the rear. Granted: 14/01/1965
01031/37/P4 Continued use of shop as betting office. Retention of extension at rear and new shopfront. Granted: 21/04/1971
01031/37/PA1 Prior notification for change of use from Betting shop to create two residential units. Refused: 26/07/2017
01031/37/LAW1 Certificate of lawfulness to install door between staircase and enclosed covered access way at ground floor level. Granted: 18/01/2023
4.0DETAILS
4.1This application is for the change of use of the basement from an office ancillary to the use of the ground floor betting shop to a self-contained office with a new side entrance for independent access. The installation of the new entrance door would be the singular external alteration, and would be accessed from the existing shared side covered access, which is secured from South Street by the lockable timber arched door. The existing and proposed floor plans are shown below: 4.2 Amendments received on 31/10/2022
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.