CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Huntingdonshire District Council

HUNTINGDONSHIRE DESIGN REVIEW PILOT PROJECT

Decided Planning 4 papers

Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009 decided this item on Monday 18 December 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item70

Resolved

RESOLVED that a Working Party comprising the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Panel together with Councillors [name removed], C R Hyams, C J Stephens and G S E Thorpe be established to consider the method and procedure of the proposed design review.
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Huntingdonshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009

Background

2.1The Design Review flows from the work resulting from the implementation of the Huntingdonshire Design Guide 2004. It is intended to provide a method for ‘scoring’ developments once they are complete and to provide a level of feedback to further improve the application and design process.

2.2The Huntingdonshire Design Review ‘Method and Procedure’ paper, attached in Appendix 1, explains the proposed process for development scoring.

3. THE DESIGN REVIEW

3.1Over the last two to three years there has been a significant improvement in the submission of application material and development outcomes helped, in the main, by officers’ and members’ ability to refer to best practice guidance material in the form of the Design Guide, on-going officer and member training and by more pro-active methods of negotiation. At the present time, there is currently no formal means of measuring these improvements or for identifying areas of weakness that still remain.

3.2It is therefore intended to operate a ‘design review’ of completed developments. The review method is to be based on that developed for the Building for Life awards. This method has been adopted by the Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) for some of their regional assessments of building quality which have received significant press attention in recent months. ‘Design for Homes’, who contribute to the Building for Life awards, have already been involved with this Council as the co-organiser of the Civic Trust coach trip attended by a number of Panel members in 2003 when we visited schemes in Bedfordshire and Ely. Design Reviews are encouraged by CABE in their publication How to do design review: Creating and running a successful panel, published in July 2006.

3.3The Huntingdonshire Design Review looks at 20 parameters of design. These range from assessing contributors to ‘character’, to issues of road design, car parking, methods of construction, housing mix and proximity to community facilities etc. By scoring each criterion between 0 and 5, a total score is achieved with a maximum of 100. 3.4 Within the Core Strategy, the Council has undertaken to ensure that at least 60% of developments in the district achieve the Building for Life Silver Standard or equivalent, representing a score of 70 or more.

4. THE PILOT PROJECT

4.1The pilot project proposes to set a threshold for measuring schemes at a gross site area of >0.5 hectares or 10+ units. For the purposes of the pilot, schemes completed in 2003 or later will be considered (numbering approximately 25).

4.2To operate the scheme, at least ten individual scores must be provided on each scheme, at least four of which should be presented by Development Control Panel Members. The remainder will be scored by officers. The scores will be averaged and will then form the final score for each development.

4.3The results of the pilot project will be presented in 12 months time, with a report noting the feedback from the review and any proposed refinements of the method resulting from its operation.

4.4A training session on the scoring method was offered to Panel members on 18 September, followed by a trial exercise on site on 21 September, involving members and officers. The results of this event are attached in Appendix 2. The purpose of the training was to assess how comfortable members and officers were with operating the method. As a result of this event, a number of refinements have been made to the scoring method to reduce apparent repetition and to include issues relating to hard and soft landscaping, and the quality of detailing/workmanship.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
HUNTINGDONSHIRE DESIGN REVIEW PILOT PROJECTReport 20 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
design review dec06Appendix 1 12 KB Download
PDF
design review dec06Appendix 3 25 KB Download
PDF
design review appendix 2: amend2Appendix 121 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 18 attended
GB
G BarrowdaleMember, in attendance
MM
Councillor Mrs Madhabi BanerjeeMember, present
MB
Councillor Mrs Barbara Elizabeth BoddingtonMember, present
PL
Councillor Peter Leonard Ernest BucknellMember, present
ER
Councillor Eric Richard ButlerMember, expected
DB
Councillor Douglas Bernard DewVice-Chair, present
PJ
Councillor Peter James Downes OBEMember, present
JD
Councillor Jeff DuttonMember, apologies
JD
Councillor James Dudley FellMember, present
CR
Councillor Colin Richard HyamsMember, present
PG
Councillor Peter Gerald MitchellChair, present
RP
Councillor Ray PowellMember, present

All 18 on the meeting page

On this subject at Huntingdonshire

Search all
  1. HUNTINGDONSHIRE DESIGN REVIEW PILOT PROJECTThis decision
  2. The Huntingdonshire Design GuideApproved
  3. Huntingdonshire design guide review: pilot projectApproved
  4. Adoption of supplementary planning documents: huntingdonshire design guide & landscape and townscape assessmentAgreed
  5. Draft supplementary planning documents: huntingdonshire design guide and huntingdonshire landscape and townscape assessmentApproved
  6. Draft Supplementary Planning Document: Huntingdonshire Design GuideApproved

More from Huntingdonshire Development Control Panel: changed to Development Management Panel - May 2009

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
20 Apr 2009 Development controlRESOLVED (a) Erection of four floodlight columns and floodlights, informal open space, north-east of 46 High Street ,... Approved Open
16 Mar 2009 Development controlRESOLVED (a) Removal of Condition 9 of Reserved Matters Approval 07/02174/REM to allow floodlighting, land at Gifford... Approved Open
16 Mar 2009 S106 agreement advisory groupRESOLVED that Councillor J S Watt be appointed to the vacancy in the membership of the Section 106 Agreement Advisory... Agreed Open
16 Mar 2009 Exclusion of press and publicRESOLVED that the public be excluded from the meeting because the business to be transacted contains exempt informati... Agreed Open
16 Mar 2009 Change of use to gypsy site without planning permission, land 800 metres east of woodwalton nature reserve and south of harpers drove, ramsey heights, huntingdon - 09/00038/encaraRESOLVED that the approach outlined in the report now submitted be endorsed, namely the issuing of an enforcement not... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies