CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Huntingdonshire District Council
Development Management Committee, Monday 20 June 2016 at 7.00pm

Felling of large Oak tree - Thatched Roofs, School Road, Broughton - L/TPO/385

Decided Committee 1 paper

Development Management Committee decided this item on Monday 20 June 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item14b

Resolved

RESOLVED that Tree Preservation Order L/TPO/385 be confirmed.
Word for word from the decision Huntingdonshire published for this meeting. Source: democracy.huntingdonshire.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Huntingdonshire's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Development Management Committee

Purpose of report

1.1To consider an objection to the Tree Preservation Order (TPO) L/TPO/385 made on 16 January 2016 and 05 February 2016 and determine if the order should be confirmed or confirmed subject to modifications.

2. DESCRIPTION

2.1The protected tree is a mature Oak Tree, which stands within the garden of the ‘Thatched Cottage’ a detached dwelling. The area is predominantly residential within the Broughton Conservation Area. The tree is an attractive, prominent feature of the area and is clearly seen in public views from adjoining roads and houses.

3. REASON FOR TPO

3.1The order was made provisionally following the receipt of a Conservation Area Section 211 Notification on the 05 December 2015 for the felling and removal of an oak tree by the owners of the property.

3.2The emerging Draft Local Plan to 2036 currently under consultation, states that:

“Where specific trees or groups of trees are of particular value (such that their removal would have a significant impact upon the local environment and its enjoyment by the public), and are potentially under threat, the Council will make Tree Preservation Orders to protect them.

3.3The saved Policy EN19 of the Huntingdonshire Local Plan states that:

“The district council will make tree preservation orders where it considers that trees which contribute to the local amenity and/or the landscape are at risk.”

3.4An Amenity Evaluation Checklist is used by the Councils Arboricultural Consultant, which provides a systematic approach in determining whether or not a Tree Preservation Order should protect a tree or trees. The Oak Tree was assessed as having high amenity value to the area and Tree Preservation Order L/TPO/385 was made to ensure the protection and retention of this tree. A copy of the checklist is appended for information.

3.5The property owner, [name removed], submitted a letter dated 16 January 2016, objecting to the order. A further letter was submitted dated 05 February 2016. 4. OUTLINE OF OBJECTION

4.1The grounds for objection may be summarised as follows:

4.2The Oak Tree is a danger to the adjacent cottage, garden and its occupiers. It is too large for the garden

4.3Further, the tree attracts wood pigeons and squirrels, which are considered a nuisance by the owner.

4.4Extensive pruning works have been carried out to mature trees in a nearby property. The approach to tree applications by the council is not consistent therefore.

5. RESPONSE TO OBJECTION

5.1The Oak Tree is located in the side garden of the ‘Thatched Cottage’. It is a significant feature of the local landscape that contributes to the character and amenity of the area. The loss of this tree would change the character of the conservation area and its enjoyment by members of the public.

5.2The Oak Tree has additional merit in that it contributes to the rural character of the locality particularly in the context of its juxtaposition to the nearby cottage.

5.3The Oak Tree is mature and has a safe useful future life expectancy in excess of 40-50 years. An assessment has been made by your Officers of the contribution this tree makes to the amenity of the area and its suitability for a preservation order using the Tree Evaluation Method for Preservation Orders (TEMPO) evaluation method. The tree was found to be of meet the standard for protection by a tree preservation order.

5.4Having reservations with respect to the size of the tree, the home owner also has worries about it dropping debris and branches, and shading his thatched roof. These concerns are not taken lightly; however, as an alternative to complete removal they could, at least in part, be overcome by pruning.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Felling of large Oak tree: Thatched Roofs, School Road, Broughton: L/TPO/385Report 994 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
12MINUTESOn the agenda 14aNew temporary site access for construction traffic. This includes no dig haul road, drop kerb access via public highway, removal of existing hedge. For duration of construction works - Land at Former Golf Course, Houghton Road, St Ives - 16/00679/FULDeferred
14bFelling of large Oak tree - Thatched Roofs, School Road, Broughton - L/TPO/385This decision
15aDevelopment of the site in principle for no greater than 8 units - Land South East of 12 to 20 Royce Road, Alwalton - 16/00346/OUTApproved 16aOutline planning application with all matters reserved (appearance, landscaping, layout and scale) except means of access for residential development of up to 150 dwellings (including affordable housing), ground remodelling, drainage featurApproved 17aChange of use of detached dwelling to residential care home (Class C2) including single storey rear extension and erection of two detached annexe buildings providing 6 flatlets (Class C2) to allow semi-independent living.On the agenda 17bDemolition of existing bungalow, erection of 6 dwellings and alterations to access - 161 Herne Road, Ramsey St Marys - 15/00770/OUTOn the agenda 17cProposed dwelling, gardens and car parking and proposed alterations to 19 Beech Drive, St Ives - 16/00447/FULOn the agenda 17dProposed residential development of 4no dwellings with garages with ancillary works comprising of access roadway, drives and parking for visitors and hard and soft landscaping - Land North of 13 Moorfield Way, Great Stukeley - 15/01753/FULOn the agenda 17eChange of use from storage barn to a residential dwelling - Church Farm, Gidding Road, Hamerton - 16/00434/FULOn the agenda 17fConversion of existing double garage to residential use - 5 Brookside, Huntingdon - 15/01520/FULOn the agenda 17gConversion of existing pub building, demolition of outbuildings and new build to form five, two bedroom dwellings - The Sun, 78 Hartford Road, Huntingdon - 15/02256/FULOn the agenda 18APPEAL DECISIONSNoted

Who was there

14 of 16 attended
JD
Councillor Jason David AblewhiteMember, present
KM
Councillor Keith Morton BakerMember, present
PL
Councillor Peter Leonard Ernest BucknellMember, present
GJ
Councillor Graham John BullMember, present
ER
Councillor Eric Richard ButlerChair, present
MS
Councillor Mrs Sarah Joanne ConboyMember, present
JE
Councillor James Edward CorleyMember, present
DB
Councillor Douglas Bernard DewMember, apologies
ID
Councillor Ian Derek GardenerVice-Chair, present
JP
Councillor John Paul MorrisMember, present
PD
Councillor Peter David ReeveMember, present
TD
Councillor Thomas Douglas SandersonMember, present

All 16 on the meeting page

More from Huntingdonshire Development Management Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Sep 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
17 Aug 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
20 Jul 2026 Application requiring reference to the development management committee - change of use of site to coach depot and workshop and erection of security fencing - wansford railway station, old great north road, stibbington, peterborough - 25/01775/fulRESOLVED that the application be not determined. Decided Open
20 Jul 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open
22 Jun 2026 Appeal decisionsRESOLVED that the contents of the report be noted. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies