Recommendations: 1.1. Approve the cessation of the current project to redevelop the Finsbury Leisure Centre site and the withdrawal of the associated planning application. 1.2. Approve an initial drawdown of £2.321m from the budget risk reserve to meet the general fund element (at current actual value) of the associated aborted scheme costs and recommend to Council at its meeting in May 2025 the deletion of the current project from the capital programme. 1.3. Delegate authority to the Corporate Director Community Wealth Building, following consultation with the Acting Corporate Director of Resources and the Director of Law and Governance, to terminate as appropriate all commercial arrangements associated with the current scheme and to approve any additional costs that may be incurred as part of the commercial settlement process. 1.4. Note the outline proposals set out in this report to continue investing in Finsbury Leisure Centre and its surroundings and to support delivery of a new medical centre. 1.5. Note the Council’s continuing commitment to delivering much needed affordable homes. 1.6. Note that alternative proposals for the site will be considered by Executive when finalised. DECISIONS: AGREED RECOMMENDATIONS Reasons for the decision – as detailed in the report Other options considered – as detailed in the report Conflicts of interest / dispensations granted – none
Word for word from the decision Islington published for this meeting.Source: democracy.islington.gov.uk
Reason for Urgency: The project incurs costs of around £363k per month. The Council is seeking to reach a decision as quickly as possible to enable, if the recommendations in this report are approved, the termination of related commercial agreements to minimise ongoing costs. The scheme has also reached a major gateway review stage, so it is an opportune time to cease the scheme. Similarly, call-in provisions have also been waived as it would not be possible for any members calling in the decision to give it proper consideration before the next Corporate Resources and Economy Scrutiny Committee meeting on 1 May and the time delay in arranging a subsequent extraordinary meeting would further increase costs to the Council.
1. Recommendations Executive is asked to:
1.1Approve the cessation of the current project to redevelop the Finsbury Leisure Centre site and the withdrawal of the associated planning application.
1.2Approve an initial drawdown of £2.321m from the budget risk reserve to meet the general fund element (at current actual value) of the associated aborted scheme costs and recommend to Council at its meeting in May 2025 the deletion of the current project from the capital programme.
1.3Delegate authority to the Corporate Director Community Wealth Building in consultation with the Acting Corporate Director of Resources and the Director of Law and Governance to terminate as appropriate all commercial arrangements associated with the current scheme and to approve any additional costs that may be incurred as part of the commercial settlement process.
1.4Note the outline proposals set out in this report to continue investing in Finsbury Leisure Centre and its surroundings and to support delivery of a new medical centre.
1.5Note the Council’s continuing commitment to delivering much needed affordable homes.
1.6Note that alternative proposals for the site will be considered by Executive when finalised.
2. Report summary 2.1. The Council has decided to cease the project to redevelop the Finsbury Leisure Centre site to deliver 200 homes, new leisure and medical facilities, and improved public spaces. The reasons for this decision and the basis for alternative investments are set out in the report.
3. Details of the proposal 3.1. Executive was last updated on the Finsbury Leisure Centre scheme in July 2024, and it approved the continuation of the project subject to ongoing gateway reviews. The scheme has reached its next gateway review - to progress to RIBA Stage 4. In parallel, a planning application has been submitted, and it is currently scheduled to be considered by the Council’s Planning Committee in July 2025.
3.2Following detailed review, the Council has decided not to proceed with the current scheme and to withdraw the associated planning application. There are two principal reasons for this decision:
• despite the importance of delivering more affordable housing, having listened to local residents and acknowledging the lack of open space in this part of the south of the borough, the Council has concluded that the significant development proposed would not be appropriate • whilst the project remains viable, wider economic conditions are not improving and, if anything, are worsening, and the Council now considers on balance that it is not prudent for it to continue to accept the risk of a single, large project of this nature.
3.3The financial implications of this decision are set out later in the report, including releasing significant funds that can potentially be utilised elsewhere and/or be used to support the Council’s wider financial sustainability.
3.4The Council is still proposing to deliver a significant package of improvements for the local area:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Q1 Financial Risk Monitor 2026-27Recommendations: i. Noted the Q1 Financial Risk Monitor for 2026/27, including the key financial risks, forecast pres...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.