(1) That the current position with regard to the receipt and assessment of complaints be noted; (2) That the membership of the Assessment and Review Sub Committees should remain as two elected and one independent Member or vice versa; (3) A Consideration Sub Committee be convened to consider the Investigating Officer’s report into an alleged breach of the Code of Conduct by Members; the Sub Committee to comprise the same three Members as those who commissioned the investigation at the Assessment or Review stage
Word for word from the decision Kent published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kent.gov.uk
1. At the meeting of the Standards Committee on 25 November 2008, it was agreed that a report would be submitted to the Committee every six months, giving the relevant details of the current stage of any complaints that had been considered by the Assessment or Review Sub Committee. Accordingly, attached at Appendix 1 is a schedule detailing this information.
Operation of the Assessment and Review Sub Committees
2. The Terms of Reference of the Assessment and Review Sub Committees are as follows:
Assessment Sub Committee
“To consider initial complaints that a Member or co-opted Member is alleged to have breached the Code of Conduct and decide whether, (a) the complaint appears to show a breach of the Code and (b) whether the complaint merits investigation.”
Review Sub Committee
“If so requested by the original complainant, to review any decision of the Assessment Sub Committee to take no action in respect of allegations
3. The guidance issued by Standards for England to reflect the Standards Committee (England) Regulations 2008 says that the Assessment and Review Sub Committees should consist of at least three Members of the Standards Committee including at least one independent Member and that the Sub Committee must be chaired by one of the independent Member. In practice, this means that, on occasions, either Sub Committee might have two elected and one independent Member. The Standards Committee is invited to consider whether it wishes to formally amend its previous decision on membership of these two Sub Committees, so that there are always two independent Members at every Sub Committee meeting. This exceeds the minimum requirements of the Regulations, but is deemed to represent best practice, as there would always be a majority of independent Members making assessment and review decisions.
Consideration and Hearing Sub Committee
4. The Standards Committee also needs to appoint a Sub Committee to consider reports from the Monitoring Officer or other appointed Investigating Officer, where the Standards (Assessment) Sub Committee or the Standards (Review) Sub Committee has referred a complaint to the Monitoring Officer for local investigation. This Sub Committee will have the following Terms of Reference:
“To consider the Monitoring Officer’s Investigation Report and decide whether, (a) it accepts the Monitoring Officer’s finding of no failure (a finding of acceptance); or (b) the matter should be considered at a hearing of the Standards Committee, or (c) the matter should be referred to the Adjudication Panel for England for determination.”
5. As in paragraph 3 above, the Committee is invited to express its views on whether the membership of the Consideration and Hearing Sub Committee should be the same as what is now proposed for the Assessment and Review Sub Committees, i.e. 3 Members each, of whom 2 should be independent Members. The Committee is also invited to note that, in those cases where the Consideration and Hearing Sub Committee agrees to hold a hearing, that this will involve different Members to those who considered the investigation report.
DVD from Standards for England – “Assessment made clear”
6. Standards for England have recently released a new training DVD called “Assessment made clear” and the Chairman has agreed that the DVD will be shown as part of the Committee meeting. The running time for the DVD is 44 minutes.
Recommendation: 7. The Committee is invited to:
(a) Formally note the current position with regard to the receipt and consideration of complaints (Appendix 1);
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.