(1) That the outcome of the Call-In Review (Children’s Scrutiny Panel), held on 7 August 2019, be received and noted. (2) That it be noted that, pursuant to ( i ) above, the determination of the Panel was that the decision of Cabinet on 16 July 2019 be freed for implementation, but that learning points relating to capacity, openness and lawfulness were highlighted. (3) That it be noted that regular updates on Almondbury Community School will be considered by Children’s Scrutiny Panel.
Word for word from the decision Kirklees published for this meeting.Source: democracy.kirklees.gov.uk
To inform the Cabinet on the outcome of the Scrutiny call in review meeting into the Cabinet decision of 16 July 2019 on Future Options for Almondbury Community School. The scrutiny review meeting will take place on 7 August 2019 and the outcomes, including potential recommendations for Cabinet to consider, will be made available after that meeting.
Is it likely to result in spending or Yes - the original Cabinet saving £250k or more, or to have a decision that has been reviewed significant effect on two or more was a key decision electoral wards? Is it in the Council’s Forward Plan? Yes
Is it eligible for “call in” by Scrutiny? No
Date signed off by Director & name Rachel Spencer-Henshall 05.08.2019 Is it signed off by the Director of Finance? N/A
Is it signed off by the Service Director - Legal Governance and Yes 05.08.2019 Commissioning? Cabinet member portfolio Learning Aspiration and Communities - Cllr Carole Pattison Children’s Services – Cllr Viv Kendrick
Electoral wards affected: All
Ward councillors consulted: N/A
Public or private: Public Report
(Have you considered GDPR?)
Yes GDPR has been considered. The information in this report does not identify any individuals. 1. Key Points
1.1On 7th August 2019, the Children’s Scrutiny Panel will consider a call in request on the decision made by Cabinet on 16 July 2019 on ‘Future options for Almondbury Community School – Final Decision.
1.2The Panel will consider evidence from the Councillors who are signatories to the Call-In, the Cabinet Member for Learning Aspiration and Communities, the Cabinet Member for Children’s Services, officers from the Children’s Service, and members of the public.
Set out below are the three decision making principles that the panel will look at and the specific area of focus:
1. Relevant considerations Issues connected with the capacity of secondary school places
2. Openness Issues relating to the availability of information
3. Lawfulness and financial propriety Clarity of the legislation relevant to the issue of the statutory notice
1.3At the time of writing the call in review meeting has not taken place. According to the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules, the panel will have three options available to it:
(1) To take no further action and free the decision for implementation. (2) To refer it back to Cabinet with recommendations for amendment. (3) In exceptional circumstances (and after advice from relevant senior officers and the Service Director Legal, Governance and Commissioning) to refer it back to the next Council, if the Panel consider that the decision was not consistent with the budget or any policy previously agreed by the Council.
1.4The outcome of the review meeting will be available at the conclusion of the scrutiny meeting and will be forwarded to Cabinet for consideration and added as an appendix to this report.
2. Implications for the Council There are no specific implications for the Council within this report as the Panel does not have decision making powers. However as a result of hearing the call in evidence, recommendations may be made to Cabinet to amend its decision which, if accepted, could result in implications for the Council.
3. Consultees and their opinions No consultation was appropriate in respect of the contents of this report. 4. Next steps
(1) If there are any recommendations made to Cabinet as a result of the call in review meeting on 7 August 2019, these will be considered by Cabinet and officers will implement any agreed actions.
(2) As required constitutionally the call in and its outcomes will be reported to Council in September 2019.
5. Officer recommendations and reasons
That Cabinet consider the Children’s Scrutiny Panel findings as set out at appendix one and determine one of the following courses of action:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.