RESOLVED – (i) that the Highway Construction Schemes Framework Agreement be awarded to the following suppliers for a period of 12 months (commencing 1 September 2014) with an option to extend the agreement for a further 12 month period:- · A E Yates Limited; · Dowhigh Limited; · Knowsley Contractors Limited (trading as King Construction); and · Wrenco (Contractors) Limited; and (ii) that the Council’s Head of Legal Services be authorised to execute all relevant contract documentation in relation to the award of the Highway Construction Schemes Framework Agreement.
Word for word from the decision Knowsley published for this meeting.Source: councillors.knowsley.gov.uk
The purpose of this report is to seek approval to award the Highway Construction Schemes Framework Agreement for a period of 12 months (commencing 1 September 2014) with an option to extend the agreement for a further 12-month period.
Recommendations
Members of the Cabinet are recommended to:-
(a) Agree to award the Highway Construction Schemes Framework Agreement to the following suppliers for a period of 12 months (commencing 1 September 2014) with an option to extend the agreement for a further 12-month period:-
A E Yates Limited; Dowhigh Limited; Knowsley Contractors Limited (trading as King Construction); and, Wrenco (Contractors) Limited; and,
(b) Authorise the Council’s Head of Legal Services to execute all relevant contract documentation in relation to the award of the Highway Construction Schemes Framework Agreement. 3. BACKGROUND
3.1Through its Highways and Transportation service, the Council delivers a range of highway construction schemes to a typical annual total of approximately £2m, with individual schemes ranging between £0.020m and £0.500m. A Framework Agreement has been the Council’s delivery mechanism for such schemes in recent years.
3.2The current Framework Agreement expires on 31 August 2014. An option exists to extend the current Agreement, but is not being taken due to the insolvency of one of the contractors involved, resulting in only two contractors remaining on the Agreement at present. It was therefore considered appropriate for the Council to re-procure a new Framework Agreement to ensure an increased level of competition and the achievement of value for money.
3.3A Commissioning Review is currently considering the business cases for the Council’s various highways-related contracts. Re-procuring the Highways Construction Schemes Framework Agreement for a further year until 31 August 2015 would serve to synchronise the timelines of a suite of such contracts and thus better facilitate the work of the Commissioning Review.
3.4Procurement Exercise
3.4.1 In accordance with the Council’s Contract and Financial Procedure Rules and European procurement legislation and also to ensure value for money, a full open tender exercise was conducted. The tender was advertised in the Official Journal of the European Union and also electronically through the Council’s e-tendering system (The Chest).
3.4.2 It was made clear in the tender documentation that the four highest scoring suppliers would be appointed onto the Framework.
3.4.3 64 suppliers expressed an interest and 12 companies then submitted a tender.
3.4.4 The evaluation was based on the following criteria and weightings, which were determined as the optimum ratio (having regard to the nature and value of works undertaken) to secure the most economically advantageous suppliers:-
Quality 70%; and, Price 30%.
3.4.5 In order to evaluate the financial element, each supplier was provided with and instructed to provide a total financial submission for an example package order. The bids were then awarded a score for price on the basis of the relative total financial submission figure of their bid compared to the lowest submitted financial submission figure. 3.4.6 The scores for the financial and quality elements were then combined to give a total score for each tender. The final results are shown in the table below:-
Quality Price Bidder Total Score Score A 53.90 30.00 83.90 B 52.50 26.41 78.91 C 52.50 24.39 76.89 D 51.10 22.33 73.43 E 52.50 18.44 70.94 F 52.50 17.85 70.35 G 52.50 16.50 69.00 H 52.50 15.87 68.37 I 52.50 15.04 67.54 J 42.00 21.41 63.41 K 49.70 11.09 60.79 L 39.20 10.18 49.38
4. RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS
4.1Financial
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Kirkby Town Centre Investment (*)RESOLVED – That:- (i) the grant of a new lease in Kirkby Town Centre on the headline commercial terms detailed at App...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.