Resolved that – (i) the congratulations of the Board be extended to Chris Walsh, Head of Committee Services and Ian McFarlane, Scrutiny and Best Value Services together with all the other Officers involved for an excellent piece of work; and (ii) it be noted that the Overview and Scrutiny Select Committee is to consider the proposal in detail at a special meeting to be held on 4 November and that the outcome will be reported to the next meeting of this Board.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
The purpose of this report is to outline issues raised to date in the operation of the Select Committee process, to recommend actions to be taken to better support arrangements and to further develop the understanding of scrutiny in Liverpool.
Recommendation
That the recommendations outlined within the report be endorsed
INFORMATION 1. Introduction
1.1The report responds to recent discussions from various members groups i.e. governance review group, Executive Board and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee concerning the scrutiny function of the council and how it can be taken forward
1.2In terms of reviewing the scrutiny function we need to take stock as to where we are at. The phrase I would use is ‘in the middle of the pack’. We have come along way and made good progress since the system was introduced in 1999. The authority has experimented with the number, scope and format of the select committee meetings over the last 4 years.
1.3A training/workshop session for members was arranged recently facilitated by Frances Taylor who is the co-author of the ODPM paper on effective scrutiny. The training was targeted at select committee chairs and a number of key issues were raised during the day. The recommendations and observations from that session are largely addressed within this report – see full list of comments Appendix A
The session identified the strengths of our scrutiny arrangements as –
• executive members are involved and being held to account • there has been good cross party working • there has been a willingness and opportunity to try different approaches • they have involved members in a different way and helped them to gain new skills
the weaknesses being –
• the presentation of information in reports does often not facilitate scrutiny • most of the Select Committees are in reactive mode, considering too many items at a relatively superficial level • to be more pro active needs clear officer support • the engagement of the public is poor So there is the opportunity to improve the effectiveness of the process.
1.4It is evident that members want to properly conduct real scrutiny. Members must lead and own the process; this is key, we need to identify roles as well as the support for those roles from officers. There needs to be clarity as to what effective scrutiny means in Liverpool so the benefits of scrutiny can be apparent to all. Additionally, we also need to raise awareness of scrutiny both internally within the authority and externally with our partners and the public.
2. Support arrangements
2.1The overall aim is to ensure that scrutiny is effectively supported by officers and encourages a healthy culture of open debate and reporting.
2.2In Liverpool, as in a number of other authorities, in terms of support there has been quite a discussion and various trains of thought regarding setting up dedicated teams with officers having specific responsibility for scrutiny alone or adopting an integrated approach.
2.3Having considered the alternatives and the experience of other authorities it is believed that the council needs to develop an integrated approach as the stand alone option could promote division rather than alignment behind our common objectives. In developing an integrated approach there needs to be direct officer support from a variety of sources: Committee services, Scrutiny and best value and most vitally the portfolio/ service officers. Any dedicated Scrutiny unit cannot expect to replicate the full range of professional skills in the authority which they may need access to in carrying out a particular scrutiny exercise.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.