Resolved that – (i) the Local Education Authority publish appropriate Statutory Notices to discontinue Watergate Primary Special School with effect from 31 August 2005 and to establish a separate Resource Base with 24 reserved places for pupils with special educational needs at Beaufort Park Primary School; (ii) parents of pupils at the Watergate Primary Special School be offered places as appropriate in Beaufort Park Primary School or Meadow Bank Secondary Special School following individual pupil-placement consultations with parents and staff; (iii) in view of the strength of feeling amongst parents that the speech and language units should be retained on their present sites, officers consult on an altered proposal to establish an additional speech and language unit at Beaufort Park Primary school, and if during the consultation no direct opposition to this proposal emerges, following consultation with the Executive Member (Education and Lifelong Learning), the Chair of the Education and Lifelong Learning Select Committee and the opposition spokesperson, an appropriate Statutory Notice be published; (iv) responsibility for the speech and language unit currently at Watergate Primary Special School (North) be transferred to Meadow Bank Secondary Special School for as long this provision is required by the existing pupils, in order to create stability for the current cohort; (v) discussions continue with the governing bodies of Croxteth Primary School and Corinthian Primary School with a view to establishing speech and language units at those schools at a future date; and (vi) the decision be referred to the Education and Lifelong Learning Select Committee.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
In December 2002, permission was given to consult formally on a proposal to close Margaret Beavan Special School and age phase the remaining 4 schools for pupils with complex learning difficulties (See Report No. DE/179/02).
Considerable attention, during the consultation, centred on the location of Watergate School as the proposed primary school for pupils with complex learning difficulties (CLD). Travelling time to and from the school was thought to be excessive by some parents. A suggested alternative was to relocate Watergate School to split sites in the North and South of the City: • Beaufort Park • Sherwoods Lane site in Fazakerley
In addition, the consultation raised timescale as a recurring area of concern. Staff and families considered that August 2003 was too short a period to allow age-phasing and the appointment of staff to be carried out in a measured way. Those involved in the consultation welcomed a revised timescale, with an implementation date of September 2004.
The current proposal is to close Watergate School for pupils with complex learning difficulties (CLD) and to replace the provision with resourced places for pupils with special educational needs (SEN) at Beaufort Park CP School has been the subject of consultation across the sector. Under this proposal, the Speech and Language Units (Sp&L units) currently based at Watergate School would be relocated to Croxteth and Corinthian mainstream primary school sites.
Whilst the LEA considers this proposal to represent a step towards developing a more inclusive approach to provision for pupils with special educational needs, particularly as many LEAs have already closed their provision for such pupils, those who oppose the scheme regard it as an unnecessary disruption to current provision for pupils with complex learning difficulties within the city. Consultations were held with staff, governors and parents at both Watergate and Beaufort Park schools. The record of these consultations is attached at Annex A.
The Chair of Governors of Watergate School prepared a questionnaire for parents, a copy of which is attached at Annex B. Parents of 20 out of the 67 pupils at the school completed and returned the questionnaire. Eighteen were totally opposed to the proposal, one welcomed it and one wanted their child to go into mainstream at a later stage. Most took the opportunity to add a comment about their particular child’s inability to cope in mainstream.
Seventeen individual letters objecting to the proposed closure were received from parents, carers or family members and one from a pupil at the school. One negative response was received via e-mail and two people requested amendments to the minutes of the consultation meeting (one parent and the second from a member of staff at Beaufort Park School). All responses will be available at the meeting for members to read.
Over the last two years there has been a dramatic reduction in the number of pupils with CLD placed in the primary special sector, from 140 to 67 across Watergate’s 2 sites; Sherwoods Lane in the North of the City and Upper Essex Street in the South/Centre. It is envisaged that this contraction will continue and the numbers will be as low as 47 in September 2005. The proposal would seek to manage the contraction in numbers, while providing, wherever possible, pupils with an inclusive educational experience.
A particular area of concern voiced throughout the consultation was the disruption of pupils through the proposed relocation of the Speech & Language Units on to mainstream sites.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.