The Board considered a recommendation that – (i) the Authority begins formal consultations, in conjunction with the Anglican Diocese, on a proposal to discontinue Garston CE Primary School with effect from 31 August 2006 and offer parents of pupils at the school a place at local Community Primary Schools; and (ii) a decision of the Garston Neighbourhood Committee of 8 December recommending that – “The Executive Board be advised that this Neighbourhood Committee is opposed to the closure of Garston Church of England School” Resolved that the recommendation be approved.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1. In the autumn of 2001, following a review of primary school organisation, the Council proposed to close Garston CE Primary School where the number on roll had been declining steadily for a number of years and there was a high percentage of surplus places.
2. In January 2001, when he reported the outcome of statutory consultations, the Executive Director said that he had been persuaded that the school should be given more time to implement a plan for recovery which it had devised. He stressed, however, that failure of the school’s recovery plan would inevitably lead to its closure and that its viability must remain under review. This recommendation was agreed by the Executive Board.
3. The school’s recovery plan has not worked. In the intervening years the number on roll has continued to decline, as shown in the following table, and the percentage of surplus places at the school has risen from 25% to 48%. Garston CE Primary Reception intake No on Roll Jan 2000 11 135 Jan 2001 12 127 Jan 2002 17 111 Jan 2003 5 89 Jan 2004 13 91 Jan 2005 11 85 Sep 2005 9 81
4. Banks Road Community Primary school, which also serves the Garston area, has seen a similar drop in numbers on roll over the same period, as will be seen in the following table. Banks Road Primary Reception intake No on Roll Jan 2000 29 210 Jan 2001 24 189 Jan 2002 31 197 Jan 2003 29 194 Jan 2004 26 189 Jan 2005 17 182 Sep 2005 22 181 While the situation at Banks Road is not as problematic as at Garston CE school, the trend is none the less a cause for concern. 5. Two Catholic primary schools also serve the area and their numbers on roll have also declined. The map at Annex A shows the location of primary schools in Garston and the immediate surrounding area, all of which have surplus capacity. The Authority’s primary school population projections suggest a further decline across the Garston Neighbourhood Committee Area of 7.2% over the next five years, even taking full account of known housing developments and residential planning consents. Clearly the area cannot sustain the present number of primary schools. 6. The Diocesan Board of Education recently considered the matter and, whilst noting the short term effect of a recent £80,000 legacy from a former parishioner, the Board shares the Executive Director’s concerns about the future viability of Garston CE Primary School.
7. Garston CE School was inspected by Ofsted under Section 5 of the Education Act 2005, in September 2005. The school was found to be in need of significant improvement resulting in the issue of a Notice to Improve. The inspection judged the school to be failing to give its pupils an adequate standard of education and, therefore, it provides unsatisfactory value for money.
8. Parents of pupils at Garston CE Primary School would be offered a place for their child at local Community Primary Schools. Parents would, in addition, be free to seek admission to any other school with places available. Alternative provision exists at nearby Banks Road, Gilmour and Springwood Heath Community Primary schools (See map at Annex A) both of which have places available. Executive Director recommendation:
Colin Hilton recommends that the Authority begins formal consultations, in conjunction with the Anglican Diocese, on a proposal to discontinue Garston CE Primary School with effect from 31 August 2006 and offer parents of pupils at the school a place at local Community Primary Schools.
Key Decision: Yes - since it involves school closures and the Policy for Primary School Organisation forms part of policy framework for the Council.
Forward Plan: Yes
Implementation effective from: 4 January 2005
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.