Resolved that the Executive Board agrees – (i) to fund the preparation of a masterplan and management plans by Groundwork St Helens, Knowsley , Sefton and Liverpool in the sum of £3,000 exclusive of VAT for the development of the site of Thingwalll House as a nature park for use by schools and targeted at children with special needs; (ii) subject to the preparation of viable plans for the nature park, to pursue the principle amending the Scheme governing the charity so as to transfer management to Managing Trustees, with the City Council remaining Custodian Trustee; (iii) the recovery of the balance due to the City Council’s general fund from the trust fund be not pursued; (iv) that future rental income, or a sum representing rent foregone, in relation to Dovecot Lodge, be credited to the trust fund, net of any costs; and (v) that officers report back on the masterplanning exercise and on the level of support for the nature park project when it is concluded.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1. The grounds of Thingwall House, including Dovecot Lodge, are part of the permanent endowment of the Knotty Ash Special School Trust. The City Council is the trustee. It is under a duty to use the trust property for the purposes of the trust, that is to say for the benefit of children with special educational needs. The objects of the trust are “(1) the provision of items, services and facilities for any schools in the area of benefit providing special educational needs (2) the provision of the education of persons who are in need of financial assistance and who are attending or who have at any time attended such schools”.
2. In the past, consideration has been given to selling the property and investing the proceeds to produce income which could be used directly to benefit special needs schools or children. There was local opposition to the redevelopment of the site, and a suggestion that the House could be retained as a Museum of Comedy (with adjacent City Council non-trust land added to the development site, so that the Trust would have received full value, but with Council selling its land at less than full value to subsidise the Museum). This idea was abandoned when two arson attacks to the House itself meant that it had to be demolished.
3. At the same time, the planning framework changed very significantly. The planning issues are as follows. First, the Thingwall House site, the surplus Council owned land, and the allotments to the rear are all identified as a ‘green space’ in the UDP and are covered by the provisions of policy OE11. This policy does not prevent development but establishes criteria in relation to openness, recreational use, linkage and existence of flora/forna, which must be taken into account. Secondly, the whole site is covered by a Tree Preservation Order, with the main areas of tree cover around the Thingwall Lane/Thomas Lane frontages. Thirdly, the site is included within the Knotty Ash Conservation Area, whereby the Council has a duty to protect and enhance the area. The key change, though, is that significant new residential development of a site of this type is now difficult to achieve given changes to national and local planning policy. There is probably no residential redevelopment value for the Thingwall House site, and even the possibility of re-building flats on the site of the House is considered no longer sustainable in planning terms.
4. Last year the the Knotty Ash Village Conservation Society approached the City Council with a new proposal. They suggested that the grounds could be retained and laid out as a wildlife area and an amenity and educational facility for children.
5. On the 29 November 2004 the Executive Board resolved as follows:-
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.