Agreed that the motion be approved and submitted to the next meeting of the Executive Board. Resolved that - (i) arrangements be made for the Officers to meet with the Ward Councillors in order to discuss this matter further and submit a report on the outcome to the Neighbourhood Committee; and (ii) all Members be asked for their comments in relation to District Signs within their Wards following which a City Wide review will be carried out if necessary.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Agenda Item 9 – Review and Revision of District Signs affecting the Three Parks area – Motion by Councillors John Coyne and Peter Allen
Agreed that subject to the insertion of the words “and location of” after “revision of”, the Motion be agreed.
Response:
The implementation of the new district boundary signs throughout the City are as a result of over 2 years research and consultation. However, Highways Management have been unable to locate a historic boundary plan showing any previous boundaries or sign locations. Liverpool Central Library, the City Council archives, the Post Office, Ordnance Survey and Geographers A-Z Map Company have all be contacted but to no avail. Indeed, the company responsible for producing the A-Z of Liverpool has previously attempted to classify the City into districts but was unable due to the lack of qualitative evidence available. As a result of this, the boundaries previously consulted upon are founded upon certain existing sign locations, obvious natural boundaries, postal boundaries, classifications from A-Z and local knowledge from locally elected Members and residents.
The district boundary signs once implemented throughout the City of Liverpool were incoherent, inconsistent and most importantly, only installed on a piecemeal basis. The new district boundary scheme, whilst no doubt causing some contention, have been implemented holistically and therefore will not avoid those areas that are disputatious, as was previously the case.
The boundary sign proposals were submitted to all (previously elected) 99 ward councillors and comments that were made were acted upon. In the case of Dingle a keen local history enthusiast actually determined the location of the Dingle boundary signs as a result of difficulties faced by officers in establishing the definitive boundary.
Clearly there is every likelihood that some signs may not be located where some people perceive them to be correct; as such Liverpool City Council will consider all comments received and, if deemed appropriate, certain signs will be moved.
It is also of the note that the location of the boundary signs are consistent with the direction signing so that movement around the City, particularly for those not familiar with the area, will be more coherent.
Officers have contacted Councillors Peter Allen and John Coyne. It would appear from Members comments that the main areas of concern are the signs installed on Riverside Drive.
This location was particularly difficult to sign as it does not appear to have ever been explicitly designated. The signs currently in-situ effectively continue the districts that are geographically north of Riverside Drive down toward the river.
Various suggestions have been made, such as moving the Aigburth sign back towards the City Centre, leaving the area unsigned and creating a new district called Riverside. All of these were considered by Officers during the scheme design but none were deemed wholly satisfactory.
Moving the Aigburth sign back toward the City would perhaps be misleading for motorists as the area, geographically is not Aigburth. In addition this would still leave an area to the west between the City Centre and Aigburth signs as contentious. Residents may also be in opposition to such a proposal.
Leaving the contentious areas as unsigned was a distinct fault of the previous boundary signing ‘attempt’, in the 1980’s. A boundary signing scheme needs to be extensive so that it is comprehensible and does not leave difficult districts anonymous. It is these anonymous districts that city wide boundary sign scheme needs to address to assist in movement across the City.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.