CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Liverpool City Council
Executive Board, Thursday 13 April 2006

Value for Money

Decided Executive 3 papers

Executive Board decided this item on Thursday 13 April 2006. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item193

Resolved

Resolved that – (i) there be two evaluations of conducted and reported upon each year in June and December; (ii) a further report from the Executive Director (Resources) be prepared identifying those service areas where the Council’s base expenditure is comparatively high cost; (iii) the following services currently identified as high cost and low performing within the Budget report bring forward reports for consideration, within two cycles, by the appropriate Select Committee(s) The report should identify specific areas that lead to these conclusions and set out suitable targets for reducing costs and improving performance within a reasonable period of time, having regard to a realistic assessment of available resources; (iv) the Executive Director (Resources) make arrangements for the Members involved in the consideration of such issues to receive specific training or guidance in the evaluation of Value for Money; (v) with immediate effect all decisions (whether taken by the Executive Board or under delegated authority) to initiate new initiatives (either through new spending or new ways of working) or new capital investments, must include a Value For Money assessment that demonstrates the impact of the proposal of spending upon service costs (both unit and total) and service performance. Such assessments to be prepared in consultation with the Executive Director (Resources) or his nominated officers. The Council’s Financial Regulations be amended to incorporate these requirements; (vi) the Executive Director (Resources) bring forward proposals as to how arrangements should be established to enable Select Committees to undertake post implementation reviews; and (vii) reports on the improvements in cost reductions and improved value for money obtained through and projected through improved procurement be presented to the Resources Select Committee in October and April each year.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting. Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Liverpool's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Executive Board, 8 pages

Executive summary

The Comprehensive Performance Assessment – Use of Resources framework, introduced last year an assessment of Value for Money (VFM) by seeking the answers to two questions:-

• Does the Council currently deliver Value for Money? • Does the Council consider and seek to improve Value for Money?

The proposed CPA Use of Resources criteria for judgement in respect of these Key Lines of Enquiry for 2006, are set out in Annexe A to this report.

In 2005 the Auditor’s assessment was that for both of these key lines of enquiry the Council was only ranked at Level 1 – less than adequate. The identified areas of weakness were as follows:-

• a number of key areas where performance has remained poor to fair;

• spending is higher than other (comparison) councils in most areas;

• the very high levels of deprivation clearly have a significant impact on costs in Liverpool but the extent of this is unknown;

• the Council’s approach to VFM is underdeveloped and so the evidence to support improvements at service level has not been collected;

• the overall approach to strategic procurement is underdeveloped although there is an innovative approach to developing partnerships and joint ventures. These have supported the Council in improving services. Investments and improvements in corporate procurement are being put in place and targets for deficiencies have been set. The Budget report advised Members that on the basis of the current CPA regime that unless the Council’s VFM rating for 2006 improves to a score of Level 2 or above, then the Council’s overall CPA rating will decline to only 1 star.

In approving the Budget for 2006/07 the Council therefore instructed the Chief Executive to submit to the Executive Board, a report setting out the processes the Council should adopt for reviewing and improving VFM that will lead to significant improvements in services as identified as high cost and/or low performance.

In summary, the Council needs to establish arrangements such that:-

• It has regard to the overall delivery of VFM as part of its financial strategies;

• It is aware of which services are high cost and low performance;

• It gives consideration to improving the cost and/or performance of such services, having regard to its Aims, Priorities and Objectives;

• It takes into account VFM considerations as part of its decision-making, particularly when considering new initiatives and/or new capital investments.

As part of the considerations of Value for Money, authorities are expected to utilise the financial information collected by the Audit Commission from authorities using government returns. The financial information collected by the Audit Commission relates to the total gross expenditure of each local authority regardless of how such expenditure is financed.

For Liverpool, the Council has total gross expenditure £1.3 billion, however, £443 million (34%) is funded by specific service grants – a proportion that is significantly higher than the majority of comparable authorities. As a result, the service costs for Liverpool will inevitably be comparatively high.

Included as Annexe B to this report is the Annexe from the Budget report for 2006/07. This was an evaluation to:

• identify how the Council performs in comparison with comparator authorities in terms of providing VFM – at the macro level;

• assess the extent to which the ‘very high cost of deprivation’ - impact on costs in Liverpool;

• identify which services could be considered ‘low performing and high cost’. That evaluation concluded that:

• Liverpool generally provides above average performing services;

• a quarter of performance indicators are in the low/bottom quartile;

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Value for Money: Annexe AAppendix 4 pages Download
PDF
Value for Money: Annexe BAppendix 9 pages Download
PDF
Value for MoneyReport 8 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Liverpool

Search all
  1. Value for MoneyThis decision
  2. Work Programme Issue - Corporate Improvement and Value for Money Programme UpdateAgreed
  3. Work Programme Item - Adult Social Care - In-house Provider Services Value for Money Review UpdateAgreed
  4. Value for Money Programme (CP/2)Approved
  5. Statement of Accounts 2006/07 and Audit opinion and Value for Money ConclusionApproved

More from Liverpool Executive Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
23 Apr 2010 Minutes of the Last MeetingResolved that the minutes of the meeting held on 9 April 2010 be approved as a true record. Approved Open
23 Apr 2010 New Growth Point - Revised Programme of Development (SSC/43)Resolved that - (i) authority be granted for capital and revenue projects as identified as ‘Priority 1’ in Appendix 1... Decided Open
23 Apr 2010 2010/11 Housing Market Renewal Fund (HMRF) (SSC/44)Resolved that - (i) authority be granted for the Executive Director (Regeneration) to accept a Housing Market Renewal... Decided Open
23 Apr 2010 Refresh of Children and Young People's Plan 2010/11 (ESE/41)Resolved that it be recommended to the City Council that the recommendation and views of the Education and Skills Sel... Approved Open
23 Apr 2010 Croxteth Primary New Build School - Final Business Case (ESE/42)Resolved that - (i) in accordance with the decision (Minute No. 50(b)) of the Executive Board of 12 September 2008 th... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies