Resolved that- (i) subject to the inclusion of Councillor Andrew Makinson as Deputy Chair, the addition of Councillor Dave Antrobus as also attended and the removal of Councillor Richard Marbrow from those present as he was present in his capacity as Executive Member (Central Services) and not a Member of the Committee, the minutes be noted; and (ii) in relation to Minute No. 16 relating to the Forward Plan arrangements be made for Member Training to be provided in connection with the use of the Forward Plan and that the Governance Review Group be asked to consider the call in arrangements in relation to decisions asking for consultations to be carried out.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
PRESENT: Councillor Robert Quinn (Chair) Councillor Andrew Makinson (Deputy Chair) Councillors John Clucas, Alan Dean, Richard Marbrow and Ian Phillips and Richard Roberts.
EXECUTIVE Councillor Richard Marbrow MEMBER
OFFICERS: Ian McFarlane, Chris Walsh and Joan Leonard
APOLOGIES: Councillors Joe Anderson, Eddie Clein, Ron Gould, Stephen Munby, Laurence Sidorczuk and Hazel Williams
_____
11. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
Members and officers were given the opportunity to declare an interest in any item on the agenda and Councillor Ian Phillips declared a personal but not prejudicial interest as a Board Member of Lee Valley Housing in relation to Minute No relating to the new entries in the Forward Plan.
12. Minutes of the Last Meeting
Agreed that the minutes of the Select Committee of 11 July 2006 be approved as a true record. 13. Review of Scrutiny Panels
Agreed that a report outlining the work being undertaken and the progress of the Scrutiny Panels appointed by Select Committees, be noted
14. Performance Framework for Select Committee Chairs
The committee considered a possible performance framework for Chairs of Select Committees.
Chris Walsh explained the purpose of the framework and that it would mirror the framework already agreed by the Neighbourhood Chairs, which is reported each cycle to the Executive Board.
The Chair pointed out that this framework should provide the framework for each Select Committee agenda, ensuring that each topic is covered every meeting. He also said that the framework will be periodically revisited to make sure that it is still relevant.
Agreed that the performance framework be approved and –
a) all Chairs be required to report to each meeting of this Select Committee on progress in relation to the following performance framework –
• Progress with the Work Programme • Progress of the Scrutiny Panels were appropriate • Review of the poor performing performance indicators • Consideration of equalities issues • Effective management of call ins • Consideration of new items in the Forward Plan
(b) the completed proformas be considered by this Committee each cycle and be circulated to the Executive Board with the minutes of this Committee.
15. Scrutiny of Partnerships
The Committee considered a report on the possible arrangements for the scrutiny of partnerships.
Ian McFarlane explained the background to the report and Chris Walsh pointed out that some Select Committees are already undertaking scrutiny of partnerships through their work programmes.
Members discussed the types of partnership that the Authority needs to scrutinise and the framework needed to deliver effective meaningful scrutiny.
Agreed that –
(a) a copy of the list of partnerships be circulated to all Chairs and Deputy Chairs and they be requested to identify the 15 to 20 priority partnerships which they would wish to scrutinise first;
(b) a matrix be prepared for each partnership defining the relationship with the City Council with details of - • what is their remit; • what type of partnership it is; • how they are accountable and details of their governance arrangements ; • Membership and who they represent; • Is there any scrutiny already being undertaken
16. Forward Plan - New Entries
The Committee considered the new Entries in the Forward Plan for the period November to February 2007
The Chair expressed concern that key decisions not appearing in the Forward Plan was continuing to cause problems for pre decision scrutiny, in particular he made reference to the item about Improved Health, Social Care and Housing Support in Anfield and Everton Areas.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.