Resolved that - (i) the City Council commits £ 314,657 from Dedicated School Grant (DSG) to cover the additional costs of the Croxteth Children’s Centre; (ii) the City Council enters into a development agreement with the Trustees of the Catholic Archdiocese for the Croxteth Children’s Centre development financed from £1,143,657.00 (inclusive of fees and charges) £829,000 to be funded from Sure Start Children’s Centre Capital and £314,657 to be funded from DSG; (iii) the City Council enter into 25 year lease (being the Sure Start grant claw back period) with the Trustees of the Catholic Archdiocese and any other ancillary agreement required to protect the Council’s interests as may be advised by the Acting City Solicitor; (iv) detailed terms and conditions be agreed by the Executive Director for Children’s Services in consultation with the Acting City Solicitor and the Head of Property and Asset Management Services; and (v) the capital programme be amended accordingly. RES/22
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
CROXTETH WARD STATUS – PUBLIC CHS/17 Portfolios: Executive Members: Children Services / Resources Cllr Paul Clein / Cllr Keith Turner Date of submission: 17 / 29 August 2007 Subject: Croxteth Children’s Centre – revised funding Report No: CHS/56/07 Contact officer: Suzanne Metcalfe Background Papers: CHS/06/07 & Tel: 225 6251 CHS/06/06
Executive summary: The purpose of this report is to seek authority to commit £314,657 from Dedicated School Grant to cover increased costs of Croxteth Children’s Centre and to seek authority to amend the capital programme. The Schools Forum agreed at its meeting in July 2006 for unallocated DSG to be used to support Children Centre and school capital programmes.
On the 13th April 2007 Executive Board gave authority to commit £829,000 from the second phase of the City’s Capital allocation for 2006-08 to finance Children’s Centre Capital expenditure for the construction of a new Children’s Centre at Our Lady and St Swithins Catholic Primary School in Croxteth. (The scheme involves the relocation of the existing Altcross Day Nursery, resulting in the current building/site becoming surplus to requirements with a view to sale.)
The financial implications outlined in the report were as follows:
Estimated construction cost £ 715,000 Disbursements & statutory fees £ 7,550 Professional fees £ 92,950 Furniture & equipment £ 13,500
Total cost £ 829,000
Tenders for the project were received in May 2007. The lowest tender is £1,140,571 The difference between the lowest tender and the estimated construction cost of £715,000 is £425,571
Several factors are understood to have caused the significant difference between the estimated costs and the tender: • The building is a timber framed construction, externally clad in facing brickwork with feature panels of timber cladding. The roof consists of built up felt roofing on plywood decking and the loft space is insulated with minimal insulation quilt at ceiling level. Part L of the Building Regulations, which deals with energy conservation, was radically overhauled in April 2006. It introduced more stringent requirements including the need to consider improvements to existing buildings where extensions are proposed. The rules governing this vary dependent on the size of the extension relative to the existing building. In the case of Croxteth because the extension is actually larger in area than the existing building, the Regulation require the whole building to be treated as if it were a new building. The existing building therefore has to be upgraded to meet current standards of thermal efficiency.
The revised Part L had just become law when the original estimates were prepared. Since then the interpretation of the law is such that ‘consequential improvements’ of the fabric of a building have to be made in order to comply with the Building Regulations.
• The condition of the external fabric of the existing build, (such as replacing the rotten timber windows, door frames and cladding) and the extent of this was not envisaged when the original cost estimate was prepared.
A cost saving exercise has been undertaken and a total of £110,914.00 potential savings have been identified. These have been achieved by modifying elements of the scheme. Following the cost saving exercise the difference between the estimated cost and the revised tender amount is £314,657.00
There are no additional professional fees. 2020 Liverpool’s fee will remain capped at £92,950 This is the amount authorised by Executive Board (CHS/06/07) on the 13th April 2007
Executive Director recommendation: Stuart Smith recommends that –
(i) the City Council commits £314,657 from Dedicated School Grant to cover the additional costs of the Croxteth Children’s Centre;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.