Resolved that - (i) the lowest tender submitted in the sum of £8,796,359 for the rebuilding of Lower Lee Residential Special School on the site of the former Harold Magnay School, Woolton Hill Road, be accepted and the City Council enter into a contract with Birse Build Ltd; (ii) the City Council incur professional fees of £1,000,000 from 20:20 Liverpool Limited plus City Council residual costs of £120,000 and disbursements of £80,000; (iii) the total approved budget for the project be reduced to £10,196,359 from £11,500,000 to reflect the lower cost of the project inclusive of an additional contingency of £200,000 to pay for required alterations to the design following planning approval of the project and to reflect changes as a result of evolving Wave 2 Building Schools for the Future ( BSF ) designs. The corresponding increase in authorised expenditure and contract sum to be reported at a later date once costs are confirmed; (iv) the financing of the project be adjusted to reduce the commitment from unsupported borrowing to £4,674,359 as set out in annex A to report CHS/09/08 submitted; (v) to further minimise the impact on the Council’s future revenue budget position, Officers be requested to explore the early replacement of the revenue funding element of this project with an appropriate capital receipt; and (vi) the Capital Programme be amended accordingly. CHS/33
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Lower Lee Residential Special School is situated on Beaconsfield Road, Woolton and provides education for children with emotional, behavioural and social difficulties (EBSD) in the 13-16 age range. There are currently 46 pupils on roll with 28 living in the residential accommodation on site and the remainder placed in other City Council care homes, foster care or attending the school on a day basis.
Whilst the school offers a high standard of education, the condition and suitability of the school buildings is poor and the standard of residential accommodation does not meet the current guidelines established by the Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI), the independent inspectorate that regulates social, private and voluntary health care in the country.
At the Executive Board of 13 April 2007 approval was given to the financing of the proposed rebuilding of Lower Lee on the site of the former Harold Magnay school on the corner of Beaconsfield Road and Woolton Hill Road, in the sum of £11,500,000 inclusive of fees.
In consultation with Children’s Services, school staff, pupils and the governing body detailed designs for the new building were prepared by 20:20 Liverpool Ltd through spring and summer 2007. Following which, in accordance with EU Procurement Rules an OJEU notice was posted in July 2007. 19 pre qualification questionnaires were received by the closing date of 6th September 2007 from which a shortlist of 5 potential contractors were chosen and invited to tender.
All 5 companies submitted tenders by the closing date of 4th December 2007 with the lowest being from Birse Build Ltd in the sum of £8,793,359 This is within 20:20 Liverpool Ltd’s latest cost estimate for the project as well the approved budget. There was a difference of £205,000 between the two lowest tenders and 12.5% between the highest and lowest. The current tendering climate locally is believed to be highly competitive and the keen pricing of the tenders at the lower end reflects this view.
A list of arithmetical and technical queries was forwarded to Birse Build Ltd on 17th December. Further dialogue and queries ensued, culminating in agreement being reached on 8th January, whereupon the Bills of Quantities were corrected accordingly. The overall pricing of the works is considered satisfactory with a reasonable spread of monies throughout.
It is therefore recommended that the lowest tender from Birse Build Ltd is accepted and the City Council enters into a contract for the works.
Planning permission for the project was given on 11th December 2007 whilst the project was out to tender, following a review of the design by both LUDCAP and Places Matter design review panels. As a result there are a number of required alterations to the design that have not been priced within the tender. These include alterations to the detail of entrances and doors to the school and residential blocks, entrance gates and additional water attenuation measures. Finally, the discovery of a colony of bats on the former Harold Magnay site will necessitate measures required by Natural England for their relocation. This will impact on the site management of demolition programme and ultimately cost.
It is recommended that a sum of £200,000 is set aside from the existing approved budget to be added to the contract sum at a later date once designs have been finalised and a confirmation of costs of additional items have been received from Birse Build Ltd.
Financing
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.