Resolved that - (i) the Local Authority apply to the Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families for permission to publish proposals to establish a new ‘Roscoe’ Community Primary School without inviting rival proposals; (ii) if the Secretary of State grants such permission, the Local Authority publish statutory proposals to – · discontinue Roscoe Junior and Roscoe Infant Schools with effect from 31 August 2008; and · establish, in the premises of the existing schools, a new Community Primary School for 420 pupils, mainly of the age range 4 – 11 years, with a 26 place nursery class and a standard admission number of 60 with effect from 1st September 2008; (iii) the response to any objections received during the statutory notice period be prepared by the Executive Director (Children’s Services) and submitted to the schools adjudicator when he or she comes to decide the proposal; and (iv) if the Secretary of State refuses the application referred to in paragraph ( i ) above the issues facing the school be picked up in the City-wide review of primary school organisation, which was agreed by the Executive Board on 21 December 2007. HASC/ 9
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1. On 21 December 2007 the Executive Board was advised, in report CHS/73/07 (Executive Member recommendation CHS/29), that in accordance with the new decision making arrangements for school organisation proposals, the Executive Member for Children’s Services had given approval for consultation to take place on a proposal to amalgamate Roscoe Infant and Roscoe Junior Schools and that the results of the consultation would be reported to the Executive Board in due course. The Children’s Services Select Committee was advised of this on 15 November 2007.
2. During the summer term 2007, the two schools had federated under a single governing body and a single head teacher. The governing body subsequently requested that the authority begin statutory procedures to amalgamate the two schools to form a single primary school. A copy of a letter from the vice-chair of governors outlining the benefits from the point of view of the governing body is attached at Annex A.
3. The governors’ intention to pursue amalgamation was clearly stated in the consultation document for the federation, which was published in April 2007, and was recorded in the minutes of governing body meetings throughout the school year 2006/7. The school subsequently submitted additional information and a proposed staffing structure, which are attached at Annex B.
4. An amalgamation would require the closure of the infant and junior schools and the establishment of a new primary school. Following recent changes to school organisation legislation there is an expectation that a proposal to establish a new school will take the form of a competition, which is open to persons other than the local education authority. However, under Section 10 of The Education and Inspections Act, 2006 a local authority may, with the consent of the Secretary of State, publish proposals to establish a new community school without inviting rival proposals. If the Executive Board agrees to publish proposals, the Executive Director will seek such an exemption.
5. The admissions policy of the new school would reflect those of the existing schools.
6. The governing body of the two schools met on 14th November, 2007 to agree consultation arrangements, and a proposal to be issued to staff at the two schools. Copies of the minute and the governors proposal document are attached at Annex C.
7. The consultation ran from 16th November to 19th December 2007 and the procedure followed is detailed in the “Consultation” section of this report (below). A copy of the consultation literature is attached at Annex D, together with a simple pro-forma questionnaire devised by the school governing body. The record of the consultation meetings is attached at Annex E.
8. Concerns were expressed at the staff meeting about potential job losses and officers explained that, given the financial position of both schools, job losses were already an issue. The amalgamation might be a way to mitigate this.
9. Forty-eight people returned the governing body questionnaire: twenty parents with children in the infant school, thirty-one with children in the junior school (some overlapping) and seven members of staff.
All but one agreed with the proposal. Many added comments in support. Two gave qualified support. A list of all the additional comments is attached at Annex F.
The parent who voted against the proposal qualified it with the comment: “I would like to know how the management structure would be determined and how policies would be adopted if they were different. I feel there has been a lack of information so informed judgements are very difficult – hence the ‘no’ decision.”
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.