Resolved that consideration of the decision on the Statutory Proposal to close Croxteth Community Comprehensive School be deferred and that the Executive Director (Children, Family and Adult Services) be requested to re-submit report no. CHS/96/08 to the meeting of this Board to be held on Friday 13 February with additional information on the implications for the Council, the school and the pupils of the recommendation of the Education and Skills Select Committee and also on the proposal by the school to build upon their extended campus proposal by forming a National Challenge Trust Partnership which was presented to the Select Committee. (NOTE: The Executive Board noted that under the Education and Inspections Act 2006 (EIA 2006) they had no power at the meeting to be held on 13 February to approve the proposal by the Croxteth Community Comprehensive School as presented to the Education and Skills Select Committee on 29 Janu a ry).
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
1. On 5th November 2008 the Authority published a Statutory Proposal to close Croxteth Community Comprehensive School with effect from 31st August 2010 and offer parents a place for their child at Fazakerley High School, St John Bosco Arts College, or De La Salle Humanities College (including any subsequent provision on the De La Salle site) and advising them that they would, in addition, be free to seek admission to any other school with places available.
The period for people to make representations in response to the proposal ended on 17th December and this report informs members of representations received and seeks a final decision on the proposal.
2. Guidance from the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) states that there are four key issues which the Decision Maker should consider before judging the respective factors and merits of statutory proposals:
a. Is any information missing from the statutory proposal? b. Does the published notice comply with statutory requirements? c. Has the statutory consultation been carried out prior to the publication of the notice? d. Are the proposals linked or related to other published proposals?
In respect of these key issues the Executive Director confirms that all of the relevant sections of the statutory proposal have been completed. The statutory notice was published in accordance with statutory requirements and the period for representations ran from 5th Nov until 17th Dec 2008.
Statutory consultation was carried out prior to the publication of the statutory notice and this period of consultation ran from 11th June 2008 until 23rd July 2008.
The Executive Director confirms that the proposal, as defined by The Education and Inspections Act 2006, is not linked or related to any other published statutory proposal. This was explicitly stated in the statutory notice. 3. The DCSF has issued “Statutory Guidance – Factors to be Considered by Decision Makers” which is reproduced at Annex A. The Statutory Notice and Statutory Proposal published by the Authority are reproduced at Annex B and Annex C respectively. A number of individual responses to the Statutory Notice were received and these are reproduced at Annex D.
In addition George Howarth MP and Robert Wareing MP submitted copies of letters sent to them by their constituents. These have been included in Annex D with a copy of a speech [name removed] made on the matter in the House of Commons, which he asked to be taken as the reasons for his objection.
The Croxteth School Community presented an extensive dossier of documents. These are detailed and reproduced in Annex E and fall broadly into four categories:
• submission from CAP – children against the proposal; • submission from the school, with accompanying Annexes A – R; • copies of correspondence with Members of Parliament; and • general letters of support for the school.
4. The school in its submission claims that “many elements of the DCSF's Guidelines for Closing Maintained Mainstream School have not been followed” and lists “five main areas of concern”: Equality and Parity, New Options, Every Child Matters & Community Cohesion, Consultation and Shifting Criteria.
Much of the material in the dossier repeats material presented in response to the consultation and the points raised were addressed in the post-consultation report. Given this a summary of the Authority’s responses to four of the five “main areas of concern” is provided below.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.