Resolved that – (i) Cabinet endorse the proposed change to the Have Your Say procedure to provide a two-stage complaints procedure; (ii) the proposed Two Stage Have Your Say procedure be recommended for approval to the Annual General Meeting of the City Council to be held on 24 May 2012 for implementation immediately thereafter; and (iii) the City Council Constitution be revised accordingly. R&T/30
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Cabinet Member: Director: Councillor Paul Brant Chief Executive, Ged Fitzgerald Deputy Leader, Cabinet Member for Finance & Resources
Date of submission: Subject: 16 March 2012 Changes to the Have Your Say complaints procedure
Report No./Background papers: Contact Officer: Ann Ho, Customer Feedback Manager
Executive summary: The purpose of this report is to outline a proposed change to the Have Your Say Procedure in respect of the complaints process with effect from May 2012.
The Have Your Say Procedure details the processes used to record feedback received by the City Council in the form of comments, compliments and complaints. The proposed change is intended to streamline the complaints process from a three stage process to a two stage process.
The current Have Your Say Procedure has been in place since 2000, and since that time there have been many changes within local government. In 2010 the Local Government Ombudsman requested that complaints should be directed through each stage of the complaints process before referring a complaint to the Ombudsman. This resulted in an increase in stage two and stage three complaints of 3.2% and 71% respectively.
The proposed change will mean that complaints will be resolved through both stages within 42 days, whereas under the existing procedure this could take an additional 28 days, which is not in the interests of the customer or the Council. The customer will retain the right to refer their complaint to the Local Government Ombudsman for an independent investigation, but in a more timely manner. Cabinet Member/Director recommendation (Councillor Paul Brant, Deputy Leader, Cabinet Member for Finance ^ Resources/Ged Fitzgerald, Chief Executive):
That –
(i) Cabinet endorse the proposed change to the Have Your Say procedure to provide a two-stage complaints procedure;
(ii) the proposed Two Stage Have Your Say procedure be recommended for approval to the Annual General Meeting of the City Council to be held on 24 May 2012 for implementation immediately thereafter; and
(iii) the City Council Constitution be revised accordingly.
Corporate Aim: We will ensure services are efficient, effective and offer value for money
Key Decision: Yes
Forward Plan Not in the forward plan due to the urgency involved in implementing the new procedure against the planned deadline.
Implementation effective from: 24 May 2012
Timescale for action: All actions to be completed following the Council’s Annual general meeting in May 2012
Reason(s) for Recommendation: To implement a more efficient and responsive service to customers and to reduce bureaucracy and the cost of managing complaints to the Authority.
Alternative options considered: The option to keep the current three stage process was considered and rejected as being overly bureaucratic and costly. The current process is considered by complainants to be too long and bureaucratic and the introduction of a two stage process falls in line with guidance provided by the Local Government Ombudsman and with many other local authorities. Consultation including consultation with Ward Councillors and outcome: It is proposed to refer this report and recommendation to Cabinet for consideration.
Financial implications (Efficiency Savings): Stage 3 of the Have Your Say complaints process is a ‘review stage’ where a senior manager will be asked to review an investigation that has already taken place; it is not a further investigation. Statistics show that in all cases reviewed at Stage 3 in 2011 (60 cases), the review did not change the outcome of the complaint at Stage 2. Each review costs the City Council approximately £288.641 and during 2011 it cost the City Council approximately £17,318.40 in officer time to carry out these reviews. Therefore moving to a two stage process would also result in a saving to the organisation.
Legal implications: As this is a change to the Council’s Constitution the decision will have to be made by a meeting of the full Council.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.