RESOLVED that the personal details of respondents commenting on Planning Applications, be included in Officer reports , subject to the addition of suitable guidance to respondents to the letters to neighbours and on the Council website, ensuring compliance with the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR).
Word for word from the decision Maldon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.maldon.gov.uk
1.1Members have raised the issue that Area Planning Committee reports currently exclude the personal details of respondents commenting on Planning Applications. This paper highlights the issues regarding the potential inclusion of name details and seeks Member views on the appropriate process to be adopted by Maldon District Council.
1.2This report also provides a copy (in APPENDIX 1) of an email regarding the view of the then Director of Planning regarding the issue, for information.
Recommendation
That Members agree to one of the following options: a. Continuation of the practice of anonymised comments within Planning Reports; b. To include the location and number (e.g. Southminster (4)) within the reports, but not personal details; c. To include number of responses and the address, but not the name of the respondent in Planning Reports; d. To include personal details of respondents commenting on Planning Applications, subject to the addition of suitable guidance to respondents to the letters to neighbours and on the Council website, ensuring compliance with the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR).
3. SUMMARY OF KEY ISSUES
3.1In the past Officer reports to Area Planning Committees included the name and address details of individuals responding to consultations on Planning Applications. This practice was changed earlier this year.
3.2Members have raised issue with the practice of anonymised comments and requested that the Director of Planning and Regulatory Services review the practice in July 2018. A copy of the Directors response is presented in APPENDIX 1. Subsequently Members requested the opportunity to debate the way comments are presented in future Planning Reports.
Agenda Item no. 19 Our Vision: To make Maldon District a better place to live, work and enjoy 3.3 In considering the appropriate practice Members should note: Whilst the there is a need to be conscious of GDPR, provided the correct warnings are placed on the neighbour notification letters and the Council’s planning web pages there is no need for the introduction of GDPR to preclude the inclusion of the names of respondents being included within the Committee report. The practice in our nearest neighbouring Councils was reviewed for comparison and found that of the eight Councils that were reviewed, five state the number of responses received only, whilst the other three state the number and provide the address of the respondent; none of the eight provided the name of the respondent as Maldon has done historically.
3.4Members have raised concerns that if they are unaware of whom the respondents to planning applications are, then they could be criticised for not declaring some form of interest. However, it is the Officer view that by expressly not stating who the individual is, Members are protected to a greater degree, as they will only be attributing weight to the planning merit of the response, not to who made that response. If Members have not been informed of the name of the individual, they cannot be seen to be influenced by who the individual is.
3.5Under Planning Law, the key issue regarding comments received is the merit of the planning issue raised, and the weight accordingly then given to it. The merit of the issue and the weight applied to it should not be dependent on who made it or where that person lives.
4. CONCLUSION
4.1Whilst there is no clear best practice published regarding the inclusion of respondent details within Planning Reports, the professional view of officers is that it is not necessary inform a balanced decision and detailed consideration of the planning merit of comments and the weight then applied to them.
4.2Members have a range of options within the recommendations and are asked to make a decision accordingly.
5. IMPACT ON CORPORATE GOALS
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.