CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council
Standards, Friday 22 July 2005 at 2.00pm

Finding of Maladministration

Noted Committee 1 paper

Standards noted this item on Friday 22 July 2005. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item10

Resolved

RESOLVED That the Standards Committee noted the contents of the report.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting. Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Merthyr Tydfil's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Standards, 5 pages

Purpose of report

To consider and note the contents of the report.

Members of the Standards Committee will note that the attached Appendix 1 is a copy of my report that went to Council on 1ST June 2005.

Recommendation

That members note the contents of the report.

GARETH CHAPMAN DEPUTY CHIEF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CUSTOMER CORPORATE SERVICES INTERNAL REPORT CONSULTATION: The following officers have been consulted in respect of the proposals and recommendations set out in this report.

Chief Executive Director of Director of Adults, Director of Chief Officer, Integrated families and Customer Finance, audit Children’s lifelong Learning Community and Risk Services Services Management

BACKGROUND PAPERS: Title of Document(s) Document(s) Date Document Location

No background papers used. APPENDIX 1 MERTHYR TYDFIL COUNTY BOROUGH COUNCIL

DATE WRITTEN 16th May 2005 REPORT AUTHOR Peter Ballinger COMMITTEE Council COMMITTEE DATE 01st June 2005 ITEM NUMBER 04

TO: Mayor, Ladies and Gentlemen

FINDING OF MALADMINISTRATION

PURPOSE OF REPORT: To inform the Councillors of a finding of maladministration made against the Council by the Commissioner for Local Administration in Wales (Local Ombudsman).

1.0Introduction

1.1In December 2003 a complaint was made to the Local Ombudsman concerning the way in which the Council’s Grants Department had dealt with an application for grant moneys to refurbish the complainant’s property.

1.2The complaint was investigated thoroughly by the Ombudsman’s investigating officer over a period of almost a year. This involved extensive perusal of documentation held at the Council’s offices and a number of interviews with Council officers.

1.3The ombudsman decided that the investigation had “disclosed a number of unsatisfactory and unacceptable aspects of the Council’s practice.” These are summarised below. A copy of the full Report can be found in the Councillors’ library.

1.4In conclusion, the Ombudsman recommended that the complainant receive an apology from the Council and receive the sum of £1,000 in compensation. This recommendation was accepted by Cabinet on the 24th March 2005.

SUMMARY OF OMBUDSMAN’S CONCLUSIONS

The Ombudsman’s conclusions are that:

1. There were a number of unsatisfactory and unacceptable aspects of the Council’s practice, resulting in a lack of transparency.

2. Neither the public at large nor waiting enquirers were told about the system of fluidity between priority groups or about fast-tracking of applications for grants for renovation.

3. This was not an occasional occurrence, but an inherent feature of the system. 4. The system relating to priority categories, and its criteria, were not published so as to give every applicant an equal opportunity to make use of the system.

5. The Council had not always conformed with its own system, leading to the conclusion that the grants system was at times haphazard.

6. The Council’s system was designed with the intention of deterring people from making full applications on first contact with the Council, contrary to the information in its own circular.

7. One member of staff was unaware of the Council’s duty in relation to full applications.

8. Assurances were NOT given to the Complainant that he would definitely be awarded grant moneys.

FINDING

The Ombudsman has decided that:

1. The Complainant suffered an injustice because:

(a) the Grant system was

(i) haphazard

(ii) lacked transparency

2. This resulted in the following:

(b) It did not provide him with the opportunity to put forward his case for fast- tracking.

(c) Others had had such an opportunity to request fast-tracking.

(d) Some cases from lower priority groups received grant approvals contrary to the Council’s policy.

3. However, the Ombudsman could not say with any certainty that:

(e) Any application for fast-tracking would have been successful.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Finding of MaladministrationReport 5 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
9Review of Model Code of ConductDecided
10Finding of MaladministrationThis decision

On this subject at Merthyr Tydfil

Search all
  1. Finding of MaladministrationThis decision
  2. Finding of Maladministration by the OmbudsmanApproved
  3. Finding of MaladministrationApproved
  4. Finding of MaladministrationDecided
  5. Finding of MaladministrationNoted
  6. Finding of MaladministrationNoted

More from Merthyr Tydfil Standards

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
25 Sep 2026 Minutes of meeting Friday, 21 November 2025 of StandardsThat the minutes be approved as a correct record. Approved Open
25 Sep 2026 Minutes of meeting Monday, 2 February 2026 of StandardsThat the minutes be approved as a correct record. Approved Open
25 Sep 2026 Action LogThat the completed actions be noted Noted Open
25 Sep 2026 Ombudsman Annual Letter for Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council - 2024/25That the report be noted. Noted Open
25 Sep 2026 Annual Report of the Standards Committee 2025-2026That the Standards Committee Annual Report 2025/26 be approved. 2. That the report be submitted to the Public Service... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies