CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council
Full Council, Wednesday 7 February 2007 at 5.30pm

Finding of Maladministration

Approved Committee 1 paper

Full Council approved this item on Wednesday 7 February 2007. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item690

Resolved

RESOLVED That Council note and approve the contents of the report.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting. Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Merthyr Tydfil's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Full Council, 3 pages

Background

1.1In February 2006 the Council received notification from the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales (“the Ombudsman”) that he had received a complaint from a council tenant that the Council had failed to carry out repairs to defects in the complainant’s house.

1.2The defects with the building came to light as a result of a survey of the building carried out as part of the process of purchasing the house under the Right To Buy provisions. It was discovered that the panels to the flank wall of the complainant’s house were bowing outwards and there was the possibility of structural problems which meant that the property was not considered suitable for a loan or mortgage.

1.3Initially, the nature of the defect with the property and its possible remedy posed difficulties for the relevant department because the department was unable to locate any construction records for the property and were therefore unsure as to the method of construction.

1.4The department sought expert advice from an external consultant who was able to advice on the method of construction of the property and recommended appropriate remedial works.

1.5The consultant’s recommendations were agreed with the complainant and the remedial works were subsequently completed to the satisfaction of the complainant. SUMMARY OF THE OMBUDSMAN’S CONCLUSIONS The Ombudsman’s Conclusions are that:

”….the external appearance of the property was such as to make it obvious during any routine property inspection that further investigation was warranted and the Council had failed to do this. Then, the Council took far too long to identify and deal with the defects to [the complainant’s] property and did not keep him adequately informed during the period following the defect being reported.”

OMBUDSMAN’S RECOMMENDATIONS The Ombudsman has recommended that:

(i) The Council make a payment of £750 to the complainant per year for the three years it took to deal with the problem.

(ii) The Council agree to sell the property to the complainant at its 2003 valuation, subject to a deduction for any improvements made to the property (double glazing etc) during that period.

(iii) The offer to sell the property remain open for a period of 12 months from the date of the Ombudsman’s Report.

CONSEQUENCES (i) The Head of Housing has agreed the Ombudsman’s Recommendations and a payment of £2,250 has been made to the complainant.

(ii) The Council is now awaiting an application from the complainant to purchase the property under the Right To Buy legislation at the 2003 valuation.

Financial implications

2.1The Council has paid compensation of £2,250 to the Complainant which has been found from the Directorate’s existing budget.

2.2The property will be sold to the complainant at the 2003 valuation rather than at the 2007 valuation and this will of course result in a loss of revenue to the Council.

Recommendation

3.1That Council notes and approves the contents of the report.

G W CHAPMAN DEPUTY CHIEF EXECUTIVE & DIRECTOR OF CUSTOMER CORPORATE SERVICES INTERNAL REPORT CONSULTATION:

The following officers have been consulted in respect of the proposals and recommendations set out in this report.

Chief Executive Director of Director of Director of Director of Chief Officer, Integrated Integrated Adult Customer Corporate Finance, Audit Children’s Services Community Centre and Risk Services Services Management

Background papers

Title of Document(s) Document(s) Date Document Location

Ombudsman’s Report No. 15 January 2007 The Legal Division, Ty Keir Hardie 2004/0827

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Finding of MaladministrationReport 3 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
678Minutes of meeting Wednesday, 8th November, 2006 of Principal Scrutiny CommitteeOn the agenda 679Minutes of meeting Tuesday, 12th December, 2006 of Audit CommitteeOn the agenda 680Minutes of meeting Tuesday, 9th January, 2007 of Planning and Regulatory CommitteeApproved 681Minutes of meeting Tuesday, 9th January, 2007 of Planning and Regulatory CommitteeOn the agenda 682Minutes of meeting Wednesday, 10th January, 2007 of CabinetOn the agenda 683Minutes of meeting Wednesday, 10th January, 2007 of Full CouncilApproved 684Minutes of meeting Wednesday, 17th January, 2007 of Planning and Regulatory CommitteeOn the agenda 685Minutes of meeting Monday, 29th January, 2007 of CabinetOn the agenda 686Minutes of meeting Tuesday, 30th January, 2007 of CabinetOn the agenda 687Minutes of meeting Wednesday, 31st January, 2007 of CabinetOn the agenda 688Proposed new Bye-Laws for the Employment of ChildrenNoted 689Proposed new Bye-Laws for the Authority's Public LibrariesNoted
690Finding of MaladministrationThis decision
691Providing Indemnities to Councillors & OfficersNoted 692Amendment to Committee Appointments 2006/2007Decided 693Appointment of Independent Members of the Council's Standards CommitteeDecided 694Review and Revision of the ConstitutionApproved 695Revised Manual Handling PolicyApproved 696Revised Display Screen Equipment PolicyApproved 697First Aid at Work PolicyApproved 698Youth Service StrategyAgreed 699Receivership ServiceDecided 700Biffa Profit Sharing SchemeApproved 702Proposed New Standard Conditions for the Licensing and Control of Sex ShopsNoted

On this subject at Merthyr Tydfil

Search all
  1. Finding of MaladministrationThis decision
  2. Finding of Maladministration by the OmbudsmanApproved
  3. Finding of MaladministrationDecided
  4. Finding of MaladministrationNoted
  5. Finding of MaladministrationNoted
  6. Finding of MaladministrationNoted

More from Merthyr Tydfil Full Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
22 Oct 2026 Allocations Policy for Community HousingResolved; That the recommendations as contained within the report be approved Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 MTCBC Receiving and Awarding Grants PolicyResolved; That the recommendations as contained within the report be approved Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 Greenfield Special School - Satellite ProvisionResolved; That the recommendations as contained within the report be approved. Approved Open
22 Oct 2026 Youth Service Statutory 5-Year Strategic Plan 2027-32Resolved; That the recommendations as contained within the report be approved Approved Open
30 Sep 2026 Healthy Organisation Strategy: Workforce Strategy 2026-2029Resolved; That the recommendations as contained within the report be approved Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies