RESOLVED That Councillors are asked to note the contents of this report in particular the positive assessment of the effectiveness of the Audit Committee and the views expressed by the External auditors. That Audit Committee meet privately with the External Auditors and Internal Auditors on an annual basis to comply with the guidance issued by Cipfa and PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk
DATE WRITTEN 16 February 2007 REPORT AUTHOR Gary Evans HEAD OF SERVICE Mark Thomas COMMITTEE DIVISION Internal Audit COMMITTEE Council COMMITTEE DATE 7th March 2007
TO: Mayor, Ladies and Gentlemen
AUDIT COMMITTEE SELF ASSESSMENT
PURPOSE OF REPORT: To update Council on the effectiveness of the Audit Committee.
1 INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
1.1A report detailing the results of a self-assessment exercise conducted to establish the effectiveness of the Council’s Audit Committee was presented to the Committee on the 12th December 2006. The report identified a number of positive aspects and the Committee felt it appropriate that this information be reported to Council.
1.2The need to assess the effectiveness of the Audit Committee had been raised in previous Committee meetings and workshops. At an Audit Committee meeting held on the 9th October 2006 two checklist questionnaires were issued to Members of the Audit Committee to allow this assessment to be undertaken. These questionnaires were obtained from two separate documents:
1. Audit Committees - Practical Guidance for Local Authorities – produced by Cipfa.
2. Audit Committees - Good practices for meeting market expectations - produced by PricewaterhouseCoopers. This is a private sector orientated document but nevertheless relevant.
1.2Both the Cipfa checklist and the PricewaterhouseCoopers questionnaire contained 25 questions each. The Cipfa checklist required Yes/No answers whilst the PricewaterhouseCoopers questionnaire required a scored response ranging from 1 to 5.
1.3Members were asked to return these questionnaires to the Head of Audit, Counter Fraud & Risk Management so that they could be analysed. 2. FINDINGS
2.1Six sets of questionnaires were returned- a response rate of 60%. The returned questionnaires have been analysed by calculating average scores for each question in order to identify the general thrust/views of the Committee Members on each question. The Cipfa and PWC checklists were analysed separately due to the different scoring requirements of each questionnaire.
2.2Analysis of Cipfa checklist
• The maximum possible score for this questionnaire was 25. • The average score of the responses was 20 (80%). • The scores ranged from a low of 18 (72%) to high of 22 (88%). • This is a very positive response overall.
2.3It is worth noting some of the positive responses made before addressing some of the areas which merit further discussion and potentially further action.
Positive Responses: Table 1 No Cipfa Questions Yes 1 Have the committee's terms of reference been approved by 100% full council? 3 Does the committee approve the strategic audit approach and 100% the annual programme? 4 Is the work of internal audit reviewed regularly? 100% 6 Is the annual report, from the head of audit, presented to the 100% committee? 7 Are reports on the work of external audit and other inspection 100% agencies presented to the committee? 9 Does the committee ensure that officers are acting on and 100% monitoring action taken to implement recommendations? 10 Does the committee take a role in overseeing: risk 100% management strategies, internal control statements, anti- fraud arrangements, whistle-blowing strategies? 11 Has the membership of the committee been formally agreed 100% and a quorum set? 15 Can the committee access other committees as necessary? 100% 16 Does the committee meet regularly? 100% 18 Are meetings free and open without political influences being 100% displayed? 19 Are decisions reached promptly? 100% 20 Are agenda papers circulated in advance of meetings to allow 100% adequate preparation by members?
21 Does the committee have the benefit of attendance of 100% appropriate officers at its meetings? 22 Is induction training provided to members? 100% 23 Is more advanced training available as required? 100% 25 Are the key officers available to support the committee? 100% Responses which merit further discussion/action: Table 2
No Cipfa Questions Yes No Comments
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.