RESOLVED that In respect of Troedyrhiw 60 On the balance of probabilities that insufficient evidence has been provided in support of the application to record the claimed Right of Way, to advise the applicant that their application has been rejected and that they may appeal, in writing, against the decision of the Council to the Planning Inspectorate within 28 days from the date of the decision letter.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk
DETERMINATION OF APPLICATION TO RECORD A PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY, TROEDYRHIW 60. Unless otherwise stated, all PRoWs in this Item are claimed PRoWs.
A. THE ROUTE
1.1Description of Claimed Route
An application was received on 31st January 2008 to record a number of PRoWs across land at West Merthyr. These Rights of Way are depicted and described respectively on the National Coal Board Map No. 2 and in the Schedule referred to below.
Troedyrhiw 60 is depicted as “ Footpath S” on the NCB Map and described in paragraph 19 of the Schedule.
As depicted on the Plan, Appendix 31, this route commences within Blaencanaid Farm at Point A, grid reference, SO03560478 on Troedyrhiw 59. It follows a field boundary in an arc around Troedyrhiw 59, initially, for a very short distance in a general south-easterly direction, then veering to the south-south-west and finally turns in a south-westerly direction. In this final section it is joined by Troedyrhiw 61. The route terminates at the north east corner of Blaencanaid Farmyard, again on Troedyrhiw 59, grid reference, SO03540470, Point B on the plan.
1.2Land Ownership
This route lies within Blaencanaid Farm which is owned by Mr. and [name removed].
1.3Maps
The route is only depicted on the Tithe Map, 1850.
1.4Government Orders and Records
1.4a Planning Applications and Applications to Suspend Public Rights of Way
Troedyrhiw 60 formed part of the Application to Suspend which accompanied the Planning Applications by the National Coal Board (NCB) in 1966 and 1970. It was depicted as Footpath S on the NCB Map and was referred to as Footpath S and described in detail in paragraph 19 of the NCB’s Footpath Application which stated:
“A footpath delineated and marked ‘Footpath S’ on the Map which runs from a point (numbered 43 on the Map) about 120 yards North East of Blaencanaid Farm on the footpath described in paragraph 18 above in a South South Westerly direction for about 100 yards to rejoin the footpath at the point numbered 42 on the Map”. At its northern and southern termini, Footpath S joins Footpath R; it is also joined by Footpath T. Both Footpaths R and T were subject to the Application to Suspend.
It was one of the twenty nine footpaths described in the Vehicular Routes Application.
This route was not depicted on the map which formed part of the National Coal Board Opencast Executive Application for Suspension in 1988.
1.5Site Visits
Officers were unable to discern the line of this claimed route when [name removed] accompanied them on his land.
A site survey prior to the 1966 Application by the NCB showed this route to subsist at that time.
B. CONSULTATION
1.1MTCBC Internal Departments
No response received.
1.2Investigation Reports
An investigation report into this route, Troedyrhiw 60, was issued in June 2008.
1.3Observations and Information from Applicants and Other Users
1.3a The Claim
The claimant, [name removed], Head of Engineering, MTCBC, submitted:
a map depicting this route coloured in red, correctly completed forms WCA 5 (Application to Modify the Definitive Map) and, WCA 7 (confirming that the main claimant has served notice on the owner/occupier).
1.4Interviews with Other Users
Eleven users of routes within the Merthyr Village area have stated that they do not go onto any section of Blaencanaid Farm.
2.0Landowners and Other Parties - Interviews and Written Observations and Objections
2.1Notes taken at a meeting with MTCBC Officers and Mr. and [name removed] reveal that Mr. and [name removed] expressed concern about the letter they had received stating that there were legal rights of way crossing their land.
2.2They stated that they had purchased the land after searches indicated there were no PRoWs across the land. 2.3 No members of the general public had ever walked on their land since they had purchased the farm although they stated that they are accommodating to anyone who requests permission to go onto their land to look at the industrial archaeological relics there.
C. ASSESSMENT
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.