RESOLVED that Taking into consideration all of the evidence which has been provided, Councillors are asked to confirm:- In respect of Troedyrhiw 158: 1. a) that on the balance of probabilities there is sufficient evidence to support that the route marked with a bold line between Points A – B on the plan, Troedyrhiw 158 has been used for such period so as to raise presumption that it has been dedicated as a Footpath, and that the evidence has not been rebutted by other evidence. b) on confirming (a) above to approve the making of a Definitive Map Modification Order to show Troedyrhiw 158 as a Footpath. c) to approve the confirmation of the Definitive Map Modification Order made as a result of (b) above provided no objections or representations are made within the prescribed period or if any objections or representations so made are withdrawn. d) if any objections or representations are made within the prescribed period and not subsequently withdrawn then to refer the relevant Order to the Planning Inspectorate for determination. Councillors approve the making of the relevant Order as set out in 1 above.
Word for word from the decision Merthyr Tydfil published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merthyr.gov.uk
MERTHYR TYDFIL COUNTY BOROUGH COUNCIL Civic Centre, Castle Street, Merthyr Tydfil, CF47 8AN Main Tel: 01685 725000 www.merthyr.gov.uk
RIGHTS OF WAY REPORT Date Written 5th November 2010 Report Author Judith Jones Service Area Rights of Way Section Committee Date 29th November 2010
To: Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen
Determination of application to record a public Right of Way, Troedyrhiw 158 1.0 INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
1.1Description of Claimed Route
The route commences on Troedyrhiw 72 (a route which was included in the 2010 Order), Point A on the plan Troedyrhiw 158, grid reference SO04820450, and proceeds on a well-defined earth track in a general easterly direction to terminate on Troedyrhiw 68 (a route which was included in the 2010 Order), Point B on the plan, grid reference SO04890451.
Councillors are advised that there is clear evidence that users walk this route as depicted between Points A – B.
They are further advised that Officers identify this route as a well-used, well- trodden track between Troedyrhiw 72 and 68.
1.2Land Ownership
The land is owned by Merthyr Village Ltd.
1.3Aerial Photographs
The line of this route is depicted on a 1967 aerial photograph.
Although obscured by trees, the line of the route but may be depicted on a 2008 aerial photograph.
1.4Site Visits
Officers have made a site visit to this route and found it clearly defined and as described above. 1.5 User Evidence
[name removed] stated that he lived at Lower Colliers Row when first married and has walked the whole of the area of west Merthyr – including this path - from this time.
He regularly uses this route to walk his dogs, even after being prevented from doing so when the area was fenced. He accesses it from the north, from the Parish Road, either via Troedyrhiw 68 or Troedyrhiw 72 or, less often, but when he wants a longer walk, he may walk down from Heolgerrig; he also occasionally accesses it from the south, from Upper Abercanaid.
He has never asked permission of anyone to use this route, has never had his use of any of the paths challenged and does not recognise any obstructions on the route.
[name removed] evidence covers the period between 1965 and 2010.
[name removed] stated that she and her father had been born at Lower Colliers Row and her mother at Melincanaid. She was brought up at Lower Colliers Row and at that time her grandmother lived at Melincanaid. She and her husband lived at Lower Colliers Row when they were first married and she and her family have walked the paths on the whole area all their lives. She has used this route for walks as an adult since the 1950s. She accesses it from the north, from the Parish Road, either via Troedyrhiw 68 or Troedyrhiw 72 or, less often, but when she wants a longer walk, she may walk down from Heolgerrig. She also occasionally accesses it from the south, from Upper Abercanaid.
[name removed] gave evidence of early use of this and other routes as routes to work. Her father and many other men walked certain routes to go to the Cwmdu, Cwm Pit and the Lucy Thomas Pits, men came from the Castle Pit past Melincanaid, men also came over the mountain and from Heolgerrig using all the footpaths. This is one of the routes that miners used to and from Upper Abercanaid.
She and her husband have regularly used this route for recreation, for example, to walk their dogs, even after being prevented from doing so when the area was fenced. [name removed] also pointed out that if people were prevented from using the Merthyr Village Site there would be more dog-fouling of streets and people would become more unhealthy as they would have lost this area for exercise.
She does not recognise any obstructions on the route and she has never been challenged while using the route. She has never asked permission of anyone to use it.
[name removed] evidence covers the period between the 1950s and 2010.
During site visits, officers have noted one person walking this route. 2.0 ASSESSMENT
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.