Resolved
RESOLVED The Committee agreed to: 1. REFUSE the application for the following reasons: · The two main elevations of the proposal did not sit well with each other and the corner of the proposed building does not have sufficient quality or distinction · The design is muted, bland and of insufficient quality · The Committee is looking for a more distinguished building for the prominent site · The proposal does not enhance setting of Vestry Hall or The Old Fire Station · The Proposal does not make a sufficient contribution to views from the public spaces of Cricket Green and Lower Green West · The proposal does not comply with CS14 on Design and does not enhance or reinforce the character of the area sufficiently. Nor does it contribute to Mitcham’s sense of place and identity. · It does not enhance the setting of the Heritage Assets of Vestry Hall and The Old Fire Station as required by SPP policy DM D4 - nor does it enhance the open areas of Cricket Green and Lower Green West. · The proposal does not meet English Heritage Guidance which requires such a new development to maximize the setting of heritage assets · London Plan policy 7.6 (Architecture) which requires that buildings and structures should be of the highest architectural quality has not been met by this proposal 2. DELEGATE to the Director of Environment & Regeneration the authority to make any appropriate amendments in the context of the above to the wording of the grounds of refusal including references to appropriate policies