Development and Planning Applications Committee refused this item on Monday 23 May 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
RESOLVED Refuse planning permission for the following reasons: The proposed additional third and fourth floor by virtue of its bulk, form, scale, height and design would constitute an obtrusive and incongruous form of development that would detract from the appearance of the original building and be out of keeping with, and detrimental to, the visual amenity and character of the London Road streetscene , and would be harmful to the amenity of neighbours in terms of loss of daylight and sunlight and visual intrusion. Therefore, the proposal would be contrary to London Plan policies 7.4 and 7.6, Merton LDF Core Planning Strategy policy CS14 and Merton SPP policies DMD2 and DMD3. The proposed development would fail to contribute to meeting affordable housing targets and in the absence of a legal undertaking securing a financial contribution towards the delivery of affordable housing off-site would be contrary to policy CS8 of the Merton LDF Core Planning Strategy (2011).
Word for word from the decision Merton published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merton.gov.uk
Report to Development and Planning Applications Committee
Recommendation
Refuse planning permission
CHECKLIST INFORMATION
Is a screening opinion required: No Is an Environmental Statement required: No Has an Environmental Statement been submitted: No Press notice: No Site notice: Yes Design Review Panel consulted: No Number of neighbours consulted: 50 External consultations: 0 Controlled Parking Zone: No
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 This application is being brought to the Planning Applications Committee for determination at the request of Councillor Geraldine Stanford.
Page 145 2. SITE AND SURROUNDINGS 2.1 The application site is a three storey with basement mixed-use building located at the corner of Sibthorp Road and London Road in the Mitcham Urban Village. To the rear, the site backs onto a car park area off Holborn Way, which is designated under the Merton Sites and Policies Plan (Site Proposal 69) for potential redevelopment for town centre and residential uses.
2.2The building is two storeys at the frontage to London Road, with the third storey recessed behind the front façade so that it is not readily visible from the London Road streetscene. The building has flats at ground and second floor (nine flats) which are accessed from an entrance off Sibthorp Road. The first floor is occupied by the Mitcham Islamic Centre which is accessed from London Road.
2.3The site’s frontages to Sibthorp Road and London Road are pedestrian only zones (only delivery vehicles permitted on road).
2.4Being located within the Mitcham Town Centre, the surrounding area is characterised by a mixture of town centre and residential uses. The surrounding buildings vary in height from two to four storeys with a combination of flat and hipped roofs, generally oriented towards the London Road high street.
2.5The application site is not in a conservation area. The site is not located in a controlled parking zone and has a PTAL Rating of 4 (good).
2.6The application site is designated within the Core Shopping Frontage and an Archaeological Priority Zone.
3. CURRENT PROPOSAL 3.1 The current proposal is to erect an additional third and fourth floor to the residential building comprising 3 x 1 Bedroom and 2 x 3 Bedroom Self- Contained Flats.
3.2The third floor matches the existing building footprint of the second floor, and incorporates balconies to the eastern (London Road) and western (Holborn Way) elevations. The fourth storey has been designed as a loft level in the form of two new gabled roofs which will be connected by a lower set hipped roof above the stair core and communal lobby.
3.3An internal courtyard has been provided from which the flats will be accessed off. The building will have 2 x 2 bed 3 person flats in the eastern side of the building with balconies oriented towards London Road, and 3 x 1 bedroom, 2 person flats in the western side of the building with balconies oriented towards the rear carpark and Holborn Way. The bedrooms for each flat will be located within the roof area, whilst the living/dining/kitchen and main bathrooms of the flats will be contained within the third floor.
3.4Ten (10) additional bicycle spaces are proposed within the basement which is accessed from the internal hall. A new communal bulk bin store is proposed
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow Development and Planning Applications Committee at Merton and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.