Resolved
RESOLVED that planning permission be refused by reason of its scale and siting in close proximity to the neighbouring properties at Mardles Gate and Manor Croft is considered to adversely affect the residential amenity and the living conditions of these neighbouring occupants by way of odour. (Proposed by Cllr P J Heal and seconded by Cllr Mrs H Bainbridge) Notes : (i) Councillor J D Squire spoke as the Ward Member; (ii) The following late information was reported: 17/00034/FULL – Retention of slurry lagoon at Land (adjacent to Mardles Gate) Brocks Cross, Colebrook, Devon Page 3: Since the report was issued a letter (dated 5 th July) has been received by an agent acting for the applicant: The letter confirms the following information in relation to the application: 1. The Slurry lagoon is to serve the a dairy farm which is 130 hectares ( currently accommodating 250 milking cows). The site was chosen as it is considered by the applicant that it has the following locational advantages: 1. It will allow for direct pumping from the reception pit in the nearby farmyard to the lagoon thus reducing transport movements. Note this is not how the slurry has been transported to date. 2. The slurry can be pumped from the lagoon using a umbilical cord arrangement and therefore further reduce movements. 3. The location has been chosen away from any water courses and therefore will minimise any incidents of pollution. 4. New planting will assist with screening of the unauthorised development. 5. The facility has Environment Agency (EA) approval. 10 th July 2017 Officer Comment: this further information does not affect the officer recommendation as set out in the report. Page 5 and 8: Since the report was drafted the EA has confirmed in a letter to the applicant that the development as it has been constructed meets the requirements of the SAFFO regulations 2010. Page 4: For the avoidance of doubt and to clarify the drafting in the report under comments from the Environmental Protection Officer. The boundary of the unauthorised development is approximately 40 metres from the garden boundary of Mardles Gate, and given the separation distance the EPO is unconvinced that a cover would address the odour concerns arising from the development ... view the full minutes text for item 32.