RESOLVED that planning permission be granted subject to: a) conditions as recommended by the Head of Planning, Economy and Regeneration; b) the rewording of Condition 3 to state that the site shall not be occupied by persons other than [name removed] and her dependents, [name removed] and [name removed] and [name removed] and her dependents and [name removed] der Kolt ; c) an additional condition (7) to state that “No composted matter from either of the two composting toilets on site shall be spread on any land within 50 metres of the bore hole. REASON: to protect the amenity of the health of the occupants of the site by preventing pollution of the proposed water course in accordance with Policy DM2 and DM7 (LP3); d) delegated authority be given to the officer to word additional conditions with regard to: · To restrict any commercial use of the site other than for horticultural use. · The requirement for the bore hole within a specified period of time. · The retention of the green perimeter. (Proposed by Cllr P J Heal and seconded by Cllr Mrs H Bainbridge) Notes (i) Cllr Mrs F J Colthorpe declared a personal interest as the objector was known to her; (ii) [name removed] –Baker spoke in objection to the application; (iii) [name removed] (Agent) spoke; (iv) Cllr Mrs J Roach spoke as Ward Member; (v) The following late information was reported: Location of proposed borehole The location of the proposed bore hole is shown on one of the plans that form part of the presentation. There is currently no bore hole on site. The applicants have received a quotation for the drilling of a borehole. The company that have provided the quotation have stated that the ... view the full minutes text for item 67.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Application No. 16/01830/FULL Planning Committee 6th September 2017
Application No. 16/01830/FULL
Grid Ref: 296570 : 101388
Applicant: [name removed]: Oak Meadow Silverton Exeter Devon
Proposal: Siting of 1 mobile home, 2 motor homes and a compost w.c.
Date Valid: 1st February 2017
AGITEM AGENDA ITEM
PLANNING COMMITTEE 6th September 2017
REPORT OF THE HEAD OF PLANNING AND REGENERATION
16/01830/FULL - Provision of 2 additional pitches to provide 1 x additional travelling showperson’s pitch and 1 x dependent relatives pitch, erection of a wooden decked entrance to caravan and erection of a compost toilet - Oak Meadow, Silverton, Devon, EX5 4HE PLANNING WORKING GROUP – 21 September 2017
Application 16/01830/FULL - Siting of 1 Mobile Home, 2 Motor Homes and a compost WC at Oak Meadow, Silverton
There were 6 Members of Planning Working Group present.
Also present – the applicant, an objector and the Ward Member
The Chairman indicated that the Planning Working Group had been requested to visit the site to consider:
The access The present layout of the site to what was being proposed The location of the bore hole in relation to the siting of the composting toilets The provision of the bore hole and the expected flow Landscaping possibilities.
The Area Team Leader outlined the history of the site and the previous approved application of 2013 for 1 permanent pitch. She outlined the land owned by the applicant and the proposal for the siting of 1 mobile home, 2 motor homes and a compost WC. She highlighted within the plan the routes of drainage and the proximity of the bore hole to the compost WC which was 90 metres (Environmental Health guidance stated that a 50 metre distance was satisfactory). A number of trees had been planted on the site and the site was itself surrounded by trees.
The group then toured the site, identifying the hen house, the current composting WC, the implement shed, the position for one of the proposed motorhomes (which was already in situ), the location of the proposed bore hole, the existing pitch, poly tunnel and shed which already benefitted from planning permission and the site for the proposed for the siting of the mobile home and the new composting WC. The Group then returned to the access to the site.
The objector raised concerns regarding the 2 additional touring caravans on the site, he was informed that one was indeed a touring caravan and the other was used as a store. The borehole had been part of the 2013 application but had not been progressed. He felt that part of the application being dealt with at the present time was partially retrospective, as some of the proposals were already in place. He also raised the issue of elderly people living at the end of a remote lane.
AGITEM The applicant stated that landscaping on the site had taken place, they had planted over 200 trees, footpaths were in place and her parents mobile home would be near to the access. Although her sister owned the site, she did not have responsibility for the access track.
The Ward Member raised concerns with regard to what was actually proposed as vehicles were on site that had no planning permission. She requested that a plan be provided which highlighted what had permission under the 2013 approval, what was on site without planning permission at the present time and what was proposed; there were many sheds on the site and she would like to know what they were used for. The Area Team Leader agreed to provide such a plan.
Consideration was given to:
What did and did not have planning permission
The positioning of the bore hole
The 2 composting WC’s both in use
The additional touring vans on the site
The Group then drove to Killerton where they tried to view the site form the other side of the valley; Hayne House and Lower Hayne House were clearly visible as where a white horse box and some stables. However the site in question was completely hidden by trees.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.