CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Mid Devon District Council
Planning Committee, Wednesday 1 December 2021 at 2.15pm

APPLICATION 20/01458/FULL - ASHDOWNE CARE CENTRE, ASHDOWNE HOUSE, ORKNEY MEWS, TIVERTON (1.41.00)

Refused Planning 1 paper

Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 1 December 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item127

Resolved

RESOLVED that planning permission be refused contrary to Officers recommendation for the following reason: The proposed development would comprise over development of the site and an intensification in use of Pinnex Moor House, leading to increased levels of traffic. Taking into account the under provision of car parking facilities on site, and the restricted width of the public highway, this intensification of use will lead to increased likelihood of parking on the public highway, which would create a severe impact on the highway network. The development is therefore considered to be unacceptable and contrary to policies DM3 and DM5 of the Mid Devon Local Plan 2013-2033. (Proposed by Cllr L J Cruwys and seconded by Cllr G Barnell) Notes: (i) Cllrs [name removed], P J Heal and B A Moore requested that their vote against the decision be recorded (ii) In the event of an appeal it was agreed that G Barnell, S J Clist and L J Cruwys would defend the decision (iii) *implications report previously circulated and attached to the minutes
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Mid Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

Agenda Item

Application No. 20/01458/FULL

Grid Ref: 295889 : 113746

Applicant: [name removed]: Ashdowne Care Centre Ashdowne House Orkney Mews Tiverton

Proposal: Erection of single storey extension to Care Home

Date Valid: 18th September 2020 PLANNING COMMITTEE 1st December 2021

REPORT OF THE HEAD OF PLANNING AND REGENERATION

Reason for Report: At the Planning Committee meeting on 3rd November 2021, Members advised that they were minded to refuse the above application and invited an implications report for further consideration. RECOMMENDATION(S) Grant planning permission subject to conditions. Financial Implications: An appeal may require the appointment of planning consultants to assist in the defence of the reasons for refusal. The applicant may make an application for costs on any appeal against the Council and such costs claims are made by demonstrating that there has been unreasonable behaviour. That being the case, Members must be able to clearly justify each and every reason for refusal in line with the development plan and all other material considerations.

Legal Implications: The report identifies the risks in proceeding with an appeal based on the reasons given by the Committee on 3rd November 2021 – both in terms of outcome of an appeal and the risk of a costs decision. The Council will still need to prepare draft planning conditions for the appeal. External legal representation may be required if the appeal proceeds to a public inquiry. The applicant has already indicated that they plan to lodge an appeal should this planning application be refused.

Risk Assessment: If Committee decide to refuse the application for reasons that cannot be sustained at appeal there is a risk of a successful appeal costs claim against the Council for reasons of unreasonable behaviour.

1.0INTRODUCTION:

1.1At the meeting on 3rd November 2021, Members indicated they were minded to refuse the application and therefore wished to defer the application for consideration of an implications report to consider reasons for refusal, with regard to:  Overdevelopment of the site and that the application did not comply with Local Plan policy DM5.

2.0CONSIDERATION OF THE PROPOSED REASONS FOR REFUSAL:

2.1With regards to the concerns raised by Members at their previous meeting, your officers would advise as follows:

2.2Overdevelopment of the site and that the application did not comply with Local Plan policy DM5

2.3In considering the impact of the proposed development, Members discussed concerns that the existing care home had reached capacity and further development would lead to an increased demand for off-street parking, noting the current under provision of parking space serving the existing care centre, in respect to policy DM5, and ongoing parking issues along Orkney Mews.

2.4Policy DM5 requires that new development of care homes should provide 1 car parking space per bedroom. In this case, there is a parking plan submitted in support of the application suggested that there were up to 15 spaces available within the existing car park, however with the presence of a portacabin serving as an office within the car park, this essentially leaves 12 parking spaces available, with Ashdowne Care Centre as a whole having 60 registered bed spaces. As a result of this under provision concerns were raised about previous proposals to extend the property and provide additional bedrooms. As a result, the proposal was amended to provide only additional ancillary space, as detailed within the application. As the proposed extension did not provide additional bed space, nor did it provide additional space that would lead to additional staff being employed, the Highway Authority withdrew their previous objection.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
APPLICATION 20/01458/FULL: ASHDOWNE CARE CENTRE, ASHDOWNE HOUSE, ORKNEY MEWS, TIVERTON (1.41.00)Report 396 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 24 attended
RM
Richard MarshCouncil Staff, in attendance
KT
Karen TrickeyCouncil Staff, in attendance
MD
Maria De LeiburneOfficer, in attendance
PH
Councillor Peter HealChairman, present
GB
Councillor Graeme BarnellCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor John BerryCommittee Member, present
SC
Councillor Simon ClistCommittee Member, present
PC
Councillor Polly ColthorpeCommittee Member, present
LC
Councillor Les CruwysCommittee Member, present
CD
Councillor Chris DawCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
RD
Councillor Ron DolleyCommittee Member, present
CE
Councillor Clive EgintonCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative

All 24 on the meeting page

On this subject at Mid Devon

Search all
  1. APPLICATION 20/01458/FULL - ASHDOWNE CARE CENTRE, ASHDOWNE HOUSE, ORKNEY MEWS, TIVERTON (1.41.00)This decision
  2. APPLICATION 22/00672/FULL - Development Site at NGR 295336 112490 St George's Court, Tiverton, Devon - Formation of residential parking area and landscaping works (3.31.11)Decided
  3. Application 20/01789/full - change of use of hall solely for use by holiday makers to public use - buildings at ngr 2944462 120596 duvale priory, bampton (3.33.29)Refused
  4. Application - 17/01346/mout - outline hybrid planning application for the erection of 200 dwellings together with associated infrastructure and public open space and full permission for portion of link road (land comprising southern portionNoted
  5. Application 19/00573/full - variation of conditions 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8 of planning permission 17/00910/full, to allow substitution plans, 10 mayfair, tiverton (00-15-04)Decided
  6. Application - 17/01346/mout - outline hybrid planning application for the erection of 200 dwellings together with associated infrastructure and public open space and full permission for portion of link road (land comprising southern portionAgreed

More from Mid Devon Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Sep 2026 The plans list (00:15:54)RESOLVED to grant consent. (Proposed by Cllr G DuChesne and seconded by Cllr B Holdman) 2. 25/01736/MFUL - Demolition... Decided Open
19 Aug 2026 The plans list (00:07:32)RESOLVED that planning permission be granted subject to conditions. (Proposed by Cllr S Clist and seconded by Cllr S ... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 Election of chair for the municipal year 2026/2027RESOLVED that Cllr L Cruwys be elected Chair of the Planning Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. (Proposed by... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 Election of vice-chair for the municipal year 2026/2027RESOLVED that Cllr G Cochran be elected Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. (Propo... Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 The plans listRESOLVED that planning permission be granted for non-material amendments. (Proposed by Cllr S Clist and seconded by C... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies