RESOLVED that planning permission be granted as recommended by the Consultant Development Management Officer subject to conditions and that delegated authority be given to the Interim Development Management Manager in consultation with the Chairman and Ward Members to amend Condition 11 to limit the source of and the type of material permitted to be stored in the clamp. (Proposed by Cllr B A Moore and seconded by Cllr Mrs F J Colthorpe ) Reason for the decision: as set out in the report Note: (i) Cllrs S J Clist , L J Cruwys, R J Dolley and B G J Warren requested that their vote against the decision be recorded (ii) Cllrs G Barnell and F W Letch requested that their abstention from voting be recorded (iii) Cllr R J Stanley spoke as Ward Member
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
01. 18/01711/MFUL - Formation of an open clamp (4630m2) for the storage of silage and provision of new access at Land and Buildings at NGR 288069 117081 (Gibbet Moor Farm), Rackenford, Devon. RECOMMENDATION Grant permission subject to conditions.
02. 21/00782/FULL - Siting of a temporary rural workers dwelling (mobile home) at South West Game Birds, Crediton, Devon. RECOMMENDATION Grant permission subject to conditions.
AGENDA 1 Plans List No. 1
Application No. 18/01711/MFUL
Grid Ref: 288069 : 117081
Applicant: [name removed]: Land and Buildings at NGR 288069 117081 (Gibbet Moor Farm) Rackenford Devon
Proposal: Formation of an open clamp (4630m2) for the storage of silage and provision of new access
Date Valid: 9th October 2018
AGENDA 2 APPLICATION NO: 18/01711/MFUL
MEMBER CALL-IN
This application has been called in by Cllr Ray Stanley and Cllr Andrew Moore in order for the Planning Committee to consider: whether the transport movements associated with the use of the proposed silage clamp will have an unacceptable impact on the amenity of the surrounding rural area, whether the size of the silage clamp is acceptable and whether the development would result in an unacceptable risk of pollution. Another key question would be was the proposal industrial or agricultural development and therefore would the local planning authority or the County be the relevant decision making body.
REASONS FOR DEFERRAL
The item first appeared before Planning Committee on 23rd October 2019. It was deferred to allow for further work to be undertaken on the application.
The item then appeared before Planning Committee on 3rd June 2020. It was deferred to enable officers to answer the following questions raised by the Committee so it could then proceed to determine the application:
1. Whether the use was industrial or agricultural to which NPPF was referred to under paragraphs 170 and 171 under Principle of Development and as such whether DCC should be dealing with the application? 2. Where does the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 define open clamps for the storage of silage as agricultural? 3. Are the size of the attenuation ponds sufficient for the run-off water for both the silage coverings and the concrete hardstanding and is the drainage considered adequate for this site? 4. Had the climate change issue been addressed with the amount of proposed vehicle movements? 5. Had the Ward Members concerns with regard to the pollution and transport impact on the local area been addressed?
PRELIMINARY MATTERS
In response the answers, the officers advise that:
1. Having carefully considered the legal advice obtained with reference to the facts of the current case, the existing use of the land and the proposed development is part of an agricultural use of land, including Gibbet Moor Farm which is one planning unit and which along with other units make up the agricultural business comprising several farms within a 12 – 15 miles radius of the application site. As such the LPA should determine the application. 2. The Town and Country Planning Act does not specifically define whether development relates to a particular use. Nevertheless, agriculture use is defined widely and is considered to include the proposed use, the storage of silage being part of, if not ancillary to the agricultural planning unit. In any event, the fact that there is an application before the committee, means that the use (storage of silage) as well as the operational development (the clamp) is for the Council to determine, imposing such conditions as are reasonable etc.
AGENDA 3 3. Yes, the application being recommended for approval bearing in mind the relevant Development Plan policies and all relevant material planning considerations (the weight to attached to such being a matter for the LPA) – please see further commentary in the report. 4. Ditto 5. Ditto
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.