APPLICATION- 22/00687/HOUSE - RETENTION OF BUILDING FOR USE AS ADDITIONAL LIVING ACCOMMODATION AT OLD PARSONAGE, HIGH STREET, HEMYOCK, CULLOMPTON (3.02.57)
RefusedPlanning2 papers
Planning Committee refused this item on Wednesday 24 August 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
RESOLVED that planning permission be refused contrary to the recommendation of the Development Management Manager for the following reason: 1. The proposed annexe, by virtue of its position, setting, scale and design would result in significant adverse impacts upon the amenity of residents of nearby properties contrary to policies S1, DM1 and DM11 of the Mid Devon Local Plan (2013-2033) and guidance in the National Planning Policy Framework. (Proposed by Cllr S J Clist and seconded by B G J Warren) Reason for the decision: As set out in the report Notes: · *report previously circulated and attached to the minutes · Cllrs B A Moore, D J Knowles, [name removed] and P J Heal requested that their votes against the decision be recorded · Cllrs S J Clist, F W Letch and B G J Warren would defend an appeal if required · Cllrs [name removed] and F W Letch left the meeting at 17.50pm
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
An appeal may require the appointment of planning consultants to assist in the defence of the reasons for refusal. The applicant may make an application for costs on any appeal against the Council and such costs claims are made by demonstrating that there has been unreasonable behaviour. That being the case, Members must be able to clearly justify each and every reason for refusal in line with the development plan and all other material considerations.
Legal implications
The report identifies the risks in proceeding with an appeal based on the reasons given by the Committee on the 27th July 2022 – both in terms of outcome of an appeal and the risk of a costs decision. The Council will still need to prepare draft planning conditions for the appeal.
Risk Assessment:
If Committee decide to refuse the application for reasons that cannot be sustained at appeal there is a risk of a successful appeal costs claim against the Council for reasons of unreasonable behaviour.
Consultation carried out with:
Statutory Consultees
AGITEM The implications of refusing the application:
At the meeting on the 27th of July 2022, members gave consideration to:
As it was an ancillary building it could be permanently occupied National space standards did not apply as the building was not an independent dwelling That there was a proposed condition that as ancillary accommodation that no part could not be let or otherwise disposed of as a separate unit It was not felt that the building over shadowed the neighbouring property That the building could not be extended in the future without planning permission The views of the objector who stated that the main issues were the size of the building and the noise coming from it. He felt that the building was an over development of the site and if the property was sold in the future more noise may be heard from new occupants with children and teenagers The views of the Parish Council who stated that the building was not modest in size, it was located some distance from the main dwelling, it was over development and the application was retrospective. That the development had an adverse impact of the neighbours The views of the Ward Member who felt that the building did not represent the character, setting or design of the existing dwelling, it was over development of the property curtilage, there was a significant adverse impact of the living conditions of neighbouring properties and the design and location was not acceptable
The neighbour spoke as an objector to the application and a statement was read out on behalf of the ward member, Cllr S J Clist. It should also be noted that the applicant intended to speak at the meeting but has since informed officers that he was unable to sign in at reception and therefore did not make it to the meeting itself. He has instead emailed a statement and provided some supporting documentation which can be summarised as the following:
That the house was originally purchased with a summer house in the rear garden; That the new summerhouse takes up a space of approx. 22%. There are no windows overlooking the neighbouring property. The distance from the rear door or [name removed] property to the summerhouse is more than 100 feet, 30.4 M away. A site visit (should it be necessary), is welcomed. The boundary treatments screen the development and can be screened via condition.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
APPLICATION- 22/00687/HOUSE: RETENTION OF BUILDING FOR USE AS ADDITIONAL LIVING ACCOMMODATION AT OLD PARSONAGE, HIGH STREET, HEMYOCK, CULLOMPTON (3.02.57)Agenda
53APPLICATION- 22/00687/HOUSE - RETENTION OF BUILDING FOR USE AS ADDITIONAL LIVING ACCOMMODATION AT OLD PARSONAGE, HIGH STREET, HEMYOCK, CULLOMPTON (3.02.57)This decision
APPLICATION- 22/00687/HOUSE - RETENTION OF BUILDING FOR USE AS ADDITIONAL LIVING ACCOMMODATION AT OLD PARSONAGE, HIGH STREET, HEMYOCK, CULLOMPTON (3.02.57)This decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.