Item24
Resolved
Decision of the Cabinet: 3 Rivers Funding 1. The wording of the Cabinet Decision does not make it clear where the funds for the increased loans, of £2.28M, will come from. Question 1: Will the increased loans be funded by a reallocation within the agreed budget funding of £19.66M for 2022/23 - or an addition to that sum? 2. The level of public interest in 3 Rivers, and this decision, is high. Based on the published report, the public asked Cabinet some very pertinent questions about this funding request. Question 2: Why have Scrutiny Committee only been provided with a Minute extract which contains the answers given to most of the Public Questions - but does not contain any of the Questions they asked? 3. Public questions were asked about the lack of Audit and Scrutiny input to this loan request and Risk. The only statement regarding risk was given verbally, at Cabinet, by Cllr Moore - who said: “Were Cabinet not to approve these loans, to cease funding the projects prior to completion, there would be a sudden and significant threat to the Council’s investment”. Given the gravity of that statement, the lack of any mention of risk in the published report suggests that risks are not being properly acknowledged. Question 3: Will Scrutiny please include, in any recommendation to Cabinet, a request for a proper consideration of risk before any re-appraisal of this funding decision is undertaken? 4. In the Cabinet Minute extract before you, Cllr Moore states that 3 Rivers’ projected spend for 2022/23, including the extra loans, would be considerably less than the total figure budgeted by Council. You should note that Cllr Moore’s figures were only “projected” and were only given verbally - his words are unsupported by any published information. Cllr Moore also forgot to mention that the Council approved this budget total, on the basis of an agreed Business Plan for 6 development projects – some of which are now not being undertaken - and that this funding request covers more than 10% of that approved total. Question 4: Will Scrutiny Committee please consider, in their deliberations, whether sufficient, reliable, information has been put forward to justify this significant Cabinet key decision? [name removed] , a local resident stated: QUESTION 1 Do the majority of this Scrutiny Committee agree with business focused members of the General Public? That MDDC are becoming INCREASINGLY and UNACCEPTABLY exposed to a risk of 3 Rivers SUBSTANTIAL BAD DEBT Especially CONCERNING in these AUSTERE TIMES. QUESTION 2 Why are MDDC Cabinet so easily prepared to lend a further near three million pounds to 3 Rivers and without an updated business plan in place? Especially as it is understood that the revised Business Plan is due for release in October. Additionally, without the results of the 3 Rivers Internal Audit being made available. This with internal auditors being engaged on or before May 2022. QUESTION 3 Can the ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.
Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk