It was agreed that the Head of Finance, Property and Climate Resilience would report back the comments made by the Committee to the Leadership Team and that the risk would be reviewed, removing reference to the closedown risk and focusing on the remaining reputational risk. Question 4. The matrix in Appendix 2, page 28 of your bundle shows that the ‘Risk Owner’ is the Chief Executive. Is it considered that the actions now being proposed or undertaken are in accord with the intention or spirit of the agreement recorded on the 3 rd of December 2024? Question 5. Are Members really convinced that the reputational damage caused by 3 Rivers can be removed by transferring properties to the Council? They were bought by the Council for millions of pounds – not transferred. Question 6. Properties at Bampton have not been all sold and there are price reductions. Land at Knowle Lane was overpriced and remains unused. St. George’s Court is still not completed and let with questions around structural surveys. All these monies could be earning interest for the Council but are not. Are Members satisfied that this is not causing ‘reputational damage’ to the Council? [name removed] 1 This Administration has spent and intends to spend tens of millions of pounds on modular social housing but there is no entry on the Corporate Risk Register covering this. I have provided all Audit Committee Members with a document that reveals other Councils have been “bitten” by failing modular build companies. The consequences have been raised in both House of Commons and House of Lords ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk
Audit Committee Public Questions and Answers (24th June 2025)
Name of Questions person submitting Are any elected members involved in deciding what is included in the ‘risk matrix, and any comments attached to Barry any item? Warren Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
The members of this committee own the Risk Register and they have the opportunity to include or amend it as they see fit.
A relevant bullet point in paragraph 2.3 is ‘CR9a: Reputational Impact of 3 Rivers was removed in May 2025. The company undertook no operational activities in 2024/25 and was formally dissolved on the 26 November 2024 and all assets/liabilities were transferred to the Council during the 2023/24 financial year. As such it has been decided that this corporate risk can now be removed. Any updates on the assets transferred to the Council will be made in the standard financial performance reports received by the Cabinet.’
Question 2.
Who decided this removal please?
Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
This was the recommendation of the Leadership Team to this committee for their consideration and approval. Question 3.
Is there a written minute or note of a meeting when this decision was made?
Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
The minutes of this meeting will endorse that recommendation and remove the item from the register.
At the Audit Committee Meeting on the 3rd of December 2024 it is minuted “It was felt that the reputational damage regarding 3 Rivers would last for a long time. Dissolution of the company was but one event in a long series of events. There were still unsold properties to deal with.’
It was agreed that the Head of Finance, Property and Climate Resilience would report back the comments made by the Committee to the Leadership Team and that the risk would be reviewed, removing reference to the closedown risk and focusing on the remaining reputational risk.
Question 4.
The matrix in Appendix 2, page 28 of your bundle shows that the ‘Risk Owner’ is the Chief Executive. Is it considered that the actions now being proposed or undertaken are in accord with the intention or spirit of the agreement recorded on the 3rd of December 2024?
Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
At its March 2025 meeting, this committee removed any reference to the closedown risk. The unsold properties are a risk this Council took on in closing the company, in line with member’s wishes. Question 5.
Are members really convinced that the reputational damage caused by 3 Rivers can be removed by transferring properties to the Council? They were BOUGHT by the Council for millions of pounds – not transferred.
Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
See the above answer to Q5.
Question 6.
Properties at Bampton have not been all sold and there are price reductions. Land at Knowle Lane was overpriced and remains unused. St. George’s Court is still not completed and let with questions around structural surveys. All these monies could be earning interest for the council but are not. Are members satisfied that this is not causing ‘reputational damage’ to the Council?
Response from the Chair of the Audit Committee:
See the above answer to Q5. Discussion took place during the meeting, which agreed a future reporting method that would supersede the current process.
Paul Question 1 Elstone This Administration has spent and intends to spend tens of millions of pounds on modular social housing but there is no entry on the Corporate Risk Register covering this.
I have provided all Audit Committee Members with a document that reveals other Councils have been “bitten” by failing modular build companies. The consequences have been raised in both House of Commons and House of Lords Select Committees.
This Council has placed large orders and made large stage payments to their MMC Supplier ZED PODS, but I could not find any reference to any risk assessments or possible failure mitigation.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Audit Action Tracking Report (00:30:00)RESOLVED that the recommendations regarding the Patch Management audit remain as a high priority and not be reduced t...
Risk Management Policy (00:38:00)RESOLVED that the updated Risk Management Policy be approved. (Proposed by the Chair) Reason for the decision Effecti...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.