CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Mid Devon District Council
Scrutiny Committee, Monday 13 February 2023 at 2.15pm

DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (00:15:00)

Approved Scrutiny 2 papers

Scrutiny Committee approved this item on Monday 13 February 2023. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item76

Resolved

RESOLVED to: 1. Approve the new 3 River Developments Ltd business plan dated 27 January 2023. 2. Approve the business case for Bampton 2, 5 levels. 3. Approve case for Park Road and accept the revised increased unconditional offer made within the business plan dated 27 January 2023. 4. Continues to fund 3 Rivers Developments Ltd in line with the business plan dated 27 January 2023 Which is proposed to generate £900k gross interest received in 2023/24 which are already included in the Council draft 2023/24 general fund budget. 5. To continue with the due-diligence process agreed by Scrutiny, Audit Committee, Cabinet and Full Council that requires a detailed business case to be reviewed and approved by Cabinet for any development in excess of £1m. 6. Instruct external financial and legal advice should a different scope or direction be considered. The reason for the call in was: 1. The Decision Notice is in Error. 2. The decisions are outside of the Budget & Policy Framework. 3. In relation to 2 above, decisions were not within the power of decision maker. 4. There was inadequate consultation. 5. There was insufficient legal and financial consideration. The Monitoring Officer provided her opinion on the reasons given for the call in: · Reason number 1 - She listed the path this issue had taken through the Scrutiny Committee, the Audit Committee, the Cabinet and Full Council. This included a number of extraordinary meetings. Also, that Cabinet had referred the matter to Extraordinary Full Council at the request of the Scrutiny Committee on the 21 November 22. · Regarding reasons 2 and 3 she confirmed that Council was responsible for approving the budget, however, the Governance Agreement of the company made it clear that the Cabinet had authority to approve the Business Plans of the company. · Reason number 4 - a great deal of evidenced consultation had taken place as referenced in the response to reason 1. · With regard to reason number 5 she again referred the Committee to the committees which previously had considered this and which were all accompanied with reports on financial and legal implications. Discussion took place and consideration was given to: · The rationale for each of the call in reasons had not been provided as part of the agenda for the meeting. This may have been helpful to the public and those discussing the issue. The rationale in each case was then provided by one of the Members calling in the decision. · The short length of time between the publication of documents and the meetings taking place to discuss and decide upon those documents. · The absence of sufficient reasons for the Cabinet decisions. ... view the full minutes text for item 76.
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Mid Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Committee

COUNCIL 18 JANUARY 2023

3 Rivers Developments Limited – Business Plan 2023–2028 and 2 associated Business Cases

Cabinet Member: Councillor Bob Deed – Leader and Councillor Clive Eginton – Deputy Leader

Responsible Officers: Deputy Chief Executive (s151) – Andrew Jarrett

Reason for Report: To review the Business Plan(s) and 2 associated Business Cases.

RECOMMENDATION: That Council considers and approves one of the two Business Plans submitted by the company and the 2 associated Business Cases.

Relationship to Corporate Plan: 3 Rivers Developments Limited’s (3Rivers) key aims are to: increase the level and quality of housing units within the District and look to help regenerate sites/areas in need of assistance and generate future returns in order to grow the business and to recycle monies made back to the Council to mitigate some of the cuts in Government funding.

Financial Implications: The key financial considerations are identified within the report and there are two detailed part 2 consideration papers that focus on the overarching risk, financial implications and the operational consequences of a decision that doesn’t support either of the 2 submitted Business Plans.

Legal Implications: This report is prepared in accordance with the Shareholder Agreement, Company’s Memorandum and Articles of Association. In addition the aforementioned part 2 papers that have been produced include details of the legal implications that would need to be considered in the event that neither of the 2 Business Plans are supported.

Risk Assessment: All commercial lending to 3rd parties, will by default, expose the lender to a degree of financial risk. Risk identification, mitigation and control measures, financial processes, audit regimes, etc. embedded by both the lender and borrower can all reduce/control associated risk levels. The Council will always consider risk vs return in all lending activities in enters into and identify/evaluate the potential level of total exposure. When reviewing these risks the Council will consider: demonstrable track record of delivery and financial forecasting (costs and sales), company qualifications/skills/knowledge, information from 3rd parties, prevailing housing market factors, local/regional supply issues, etc. And ultimately risk vs reward set against other investment opportunities.

This report includes additional part 2 papers that further address the risk implications to the Council. These seek to ensure that members are advised on all areas of risk and additionally respond to questions raised when this item was considered at Cabinet, where a more comprehensive risk analysis was requested.

3 Rivers Developments Ltd – Full Council Business Plan 2023 – 2028 & 2 Business Cases Equality impact assessment: No direct equality issues identified for this report.

Impact on climate change: 3Rivers is a commercial organisation and where deliverable sustainable options are available they are utilised; however, as a commercial organisation it is acknowledged that there is currently a significant cost differential on build options and what the market will sustain plays heavily in the choices made, bearing in mind the mandate to return target levels of investment return (profit).

1.0Introduction

1.1An initial Business Plan provided by the company was reviewed by meetings of both the Scrutiny and Audit Committees back in November 2022. Feedback and comments from these meetings was provided to the Cabinet.

1.2Subsequent to this feedback discussions were held with some members of the Cabinet and the company to propose revisions to the previously submitted Business Plan.

1.3This revised Business Plan and the one previously submitted were both included on the Cabinet agenda for consideration at their meeting on the 3 January 2023 along with 2 Business Cases for projects in Bampton and Tiverton.

2.0Cabinet 3 January 2023

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
3Rivers: Bampton Business Case (site 2): Cabinet 3-1-23, 18/01/2023 Council, 31/01/2023 CabinetAppendix 3 282 KB Download
PDF
DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (00:15:00)Decisions 414 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting
75PUBLIC QUESTION TIMEOn the agenda
76DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (00:15:00)This decision

Who was there

16 of 31 attended
SC
Councillor Simon ClistChairman, present
GB
Councillor Graeme BarnellCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor John BerryCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
WB
Councillor Wally BurkeCommittee Member, present
LC
Councillor Les CruwysCommittee Member, present
JD
Cllr John DownesCommittee Member, present as substitute
SG
Councillor Sue GriggsCommittee Member, present
PH
Councillor Peter HealCommittee Member, present as substitute
FL
Councillor Frank Letch MBECommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
EL
Councillor Elizabeth LloydCommittee Member, apologies
SP
Councillor Stephen PughCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Ray RadfordCommittee Member, present

All 31 on the meeting page

On this subject at Mid Devon

Search all
  1. DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (00:15:00)This decision
  2. Decisions of the cabinet (0.24.28)Decided
  3. Cabinet Member Decisions (01.03.14)Decided
  4. Decisions of the cabinet (00-07-24)Decided
  5. Decisions of the cabinetDecided

More from Mid Devon Scrutiny Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Sep 2026 The Local Government Reorganisation Working Group - Verbal Update (00:43:58)RESOLVED that: The meeting taking place on the 22 September 2026 of the LGR Working Group be postponed. The LGR Worki... Decided Open
17 Aug 2026 Access to Information - Exclusion of Press & PublicRESOLVED : That under S100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, in accordance with Part I of Schedule 12A, the press... Decided Open
13 Jul 2026 Review of Let's Talk Mid Devon - Improvement PlanRESOLVED that the Let’s Talk Mid Devon District Council – Improvement Plan update be presented at the Scrutiny Commit... Decided Open
8 Jun 2026 Election of Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny CommitteeRESOLVED that Cllr S Robinson be elected Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. Decided Open
20 Oct 2025 Election of ChairRESOLVED that Cllr G Czapiewski be elected Chair for the purposes of this meeting only. (Proposed by Cllr C Adcock an... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies