CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Mid Devon District Council
Scrutiny Committee, Thursday 24 August 2023 at 5.30pm

DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (0.24.28)

Decided Scrutiny 4 papers

Scrutiny Committee decided this item on Thursday 24 August 2023. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item30

Resolved

Decision made by the Cabinet on 16 August 2023 in respect of the following report was called in for consideration by Councillor R Gilmour. 3 Rivers Options Appraisal Report Cabinet recommend to Full Council a “soft closure” of 3 Rivers Development Ltd. over a sensible short term period in order to minimise any potential financial exposure and maximise returns from company assets. Delegated authority is given to the Deputy Chief Executive in conjunction with the Cabinet Member for Finance to deliver/instruct all necessary activities in order to deliver a “soft closure” and maintain timely decision making in order to protect the Council’s position during this process. That the Deputy Chief Executive, in discussion with the Cabinet Member for Finance procure any additional professional advice required to protect the Council’s position and maximise the return to the Shareholder and minimise any potential further losses. The reason for the call in was: The decisions are outside of the Budget & Policy Framework. The Chairman read a statement which included the following: That this Extraordinary Scrutiny Committee Meeting had been called today to identify whether the decision of Cabinet to recommend “soft closure” of 3 Rivers Development Ltd, and any losses or costs that would be incurred by Mid Devon Council. That any decision of the Cabinet or of the Full Council around the future options for 3RDL was projected to carry a cost for Mid Devon residents. That the Committee’s objective was to learn any lessons that need to be learned to prevent a repeat of this scenario in the future. As those who do not remember the past, are condemned to repeat it. That the Committee was not here to assign blame, rather to ensure that the blameless – the residents – were not left to pick up the bill for similar failures in the future. That no matter how well-meaning, humans were fallible. This was why we build procedures and controls around decision making. One such role was the role of Scrutiny, with the defined role in our Constitution and, more widely, as Councillors of this Council to speak up and ask questions to ensure good decision making. The majority of the current Councillors had no part in the decision making process around 3 Rivers Development Ltd, until the future options decision be presented to Full Council lessons must be learnt from the past to ensure the Council does not repeat the mistakes of predecessors. Time should be set aside on the Committee’s Work Programme to talk to previous Cabinet members, senior officers and other relevant parties to learn lessons. RESOLVED that: Time be set aside in the Work Programme for a “3 Rivers lessons learned” exercise and that any recommendations that come out of that be reported back to cabinet. A “3 Rivers – Lessons to be learned” issue take place over one or two meetings in November and any recommendations sent back to Cabinet by the end of December 2023. (Proposed by the Chairman, Cllr R Gilmour)
Word for word from the decision Mid Devon published for this meeting. Source: democracy.middevon.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Mid Devon's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Scrutiny Committee

A Decision made by the Cabinet on 16 August 2023 in respect of the following report was called in for consideration by Councillor R Gilmour.

3 Rivers Options Appraisal Report

1. Cabinet recommend to Full Council a “soft closure” of 3 Rivers Development Ltd. over a sensible short term period in order to minimise any potential financial exposure and maximise returns from company assets.

2. Delegated authority is given to the Deputy Chief Executive in conjunction with the Cabinet Member for Finance to deliver/instruct all necessary activities in order to deliver a “soft closure” and maintain timely decision making in order to protect the Council’s position during this process.

3. That the Deputy Chief Executive, in discussion with the Cabinet Member for Finance procure any additional professional advice required to protect the Council’s position and maximise the return to the Shareholder and minimise any potential further losses.

The reason for the call in is:

 The decisions are outside of the Budget & Policy Framework.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Call In: Scrutiny: 24 Aug 23Report 117 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Call In MO Advice: Scrutiny: 24 Aug 23Report 230 KB Download
PDF
DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (0.24.28)Decisions 261 KB Download
PDF
Extracts from Minutes: Cabinet 16 August 2023, Minute 30Minutes 214 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
29PUBLIC QUESTION TIME (0.04.23)On the agenda
30DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (0.24.28)This decision

Who was there

16 of 33 attended
RG
Councillor Rachel GilmourChairman, present
GW
Councillor Gill WestcottVice-Chair, present
DB
Councillor David BroomCommittee Member, present
EB
Cllr Emma BuczkowskiCommittee Member, present
PC
Councillor Polly ColthorpeCommittee Member, present
AC
Councillor Andy CuddyCommittee Member, present
GC
Councillor Gordon CzapiewskiCommittee Member, present
MF
Councillor Matt FarrellCommittee Member, present
BH
Councillor Ben HoldmanCommittee Member, present
RR
Councillor Rhys RobertsCommittee Member, apologies
SR
Councillor Sue RobinsonCommittee Member, present
NW
Councillor Nikki WoollattCommittee Member, present, as expected, virtual

All 33 on the meeting page

On this subject at Mid Devon

Search all
  1. DECISIONS OF THE CABINET (0.24.28)This decision
  2. Decisions of the cabinet (00:15:00)Approved
  3. Cabinet Member Decisions (01.03.14)Decided
  4. Decisions of the cabinet (00-07-24)Decided
  5. Decisions of the cabinetDecided

More from Mid Devon Scrutiny Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
7 Sep 2026 The Local Government Reorganisation Working Group - Verbal Update (00:43:58)RESOLVED that: The meeting taking place on the 22 September 2026 of the LGR Working Group be postponed. The LGR Worki... Decided Open
17 Aug 2026 Access to Information - Exclusion of Press & PublicRESOLVED : That under S100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, in accordance with Part I of Schedule 12A, the press... Decided Open
13 Jul 2026 Review of Let's Talk Mid Devon - Improvement PlanRESOLVED that the Let’s Talk Mid Devon District Council – Improvement Plan update be presented at the Scrutiny Commit... Decided Open
8 Jun 2026 Election of Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny CommitteeRESOLVED that Cllr S Robinson be elected Vice-Chair of the Scrutiny Committee for the municipal year 2026/2027. Decided Open
20 Oct 2025 Election of ChairRESOLVED that Cllr G Czapiewski be elected Chair for the purposes of this meeting only. (Proposed by Cllr C Adcock an... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies